Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 231 by Fantasy Fantasy

What's next?

Some innocent snooping.

When nature calls, it calls. It’s the unglamorous side of sex that pornographic media never shows. Noelle, Alice and I took turns going to the bathroom, with me going in last to pee. But before I went back to the room, I overheard a conversation I didn’t want to interrupt.

I could hear a bit of water splashing and moving. The hot tub was close to the bathroom, so I imagined they’d both gone in.

“I’ve never used a hot tub before…” Noelle said, sighing contently.

“Sarah has one in her house,” Alice said, chuckling. “I haven’t been to her new house, though.”

“How lucky of her. But I suppose that, if you always have one available, it eventually loses its appeal.”

A silence loomed over them, one that grew heavier by the moment. I was about to exit the bathroom to try and prevent it from getting worse, but I didn’t need to.

“Hey… Noelle? This will sound strange, but I’m really glad that you’re here.”

“Eh?”

“It’s hard to explain. When it comes to men, I haven’t had good experiences. Oliver is the first guy I feel I can let myself be **** around. I really wanted to do this with him, but a part of me was hesitant. You being here helped me relax and go with the flow. So, as weird as it is… Thank you.”

“I… actually feel the same,” Noelle admitted bashfully. “You’re so assertive, so proactive… I felt like if I didn’t match you, I’d be missing out on something I wanted.” She chuckled. “I’m glad I did, and I’m glad we did this together.”

“Really? Did seeing me with him not…?”

“A bit,” Noelle admitted. “But only a bit, which was shocking in itself. It’s like the others said. I could feel how much he wanted me.” Noelle giggled. “Didn’t you?”

“Oh yeah…” Alice laughed with her. “It was wild. I think he would’ve eaten me whole if I hadn’t asked him to be gentle.”

“I think I might ask him to be a little rougher next time, actually.”

“Oh my God!” Alice laughed even harder. “Are you serious?”

“Yeah! I was nervous, but it felt so good! And I saw your face! You were totally drunk on it, too.”

“I guess I was. God, I couldn’t think straight. I felt it in my whole body. Grace once said it was like a ****, but I thought she was exaggerating.”

“Seems she wasn’t. And did you notice?”

“Notice what?”

“He was still hard after coming three times.”

“Oh. Yeah, I did.” Alice took a deep breath. “How much longer do we have here?”

“A little under two hours, I think.”

“Then… At least twice more for each of us.”

“Actually… I think I don’t mind sharing a bit more. If you’re also okay with it, I mean.”

Alice remained silent for a moment. “Are you sure?”

“Like I said, this bothered me far less than I thought it would. Actually, watching you two only made me want it more.”

Alice giggled. “Seriously? It was the same for me. You two looked so sexy. He was so into you I almost wanted to get in there as well.”

“That’s it! That’s the bit that makes me uncomfortable! Like, you two looked like you were in your own little world, and… I wanted to be there, too. Is that… bad?”

“I don’t know. I think it’s too early to tell what’s good and what’s bad. But I think that, if we talk about it freely like this, we’ll figure things out quickly enough.”

Noelle chuckled. “Now I’m even more glad that we did this together. If I was alone, I might have felt guilty that I was hogging him…”

“Well, Mila, Grace and Sarah have had him to themselves for three months now. Like I said, you and I have to be assertive to make up for it.”

“Right!”

The two friends laughed together, any and all tension that was still left now gone completely. And as much as I hate snooping, I was glad I got to hear that exchange. My biggest worry was causing these good friends to fight over me. And yet… there was an uncomfortable thought at the forefront of my mind, one that came back every so often.

All the girls kept saying I wasn’t normal, that there was something special about me. I could somehow (and randomly) read minds and they could feel my thoughts. Overnight, I became a sex machine and had only gotten better with experience. They talked about how out of this world it was to sleep with me, and apparently it was all so crazy that they were willing to share me just to keep experiencing it. I… I wanted all this, I wanted to be with all these girls and I loved being able to pleasure them like this. I had already admitted it to myself and decided to use what I had to get it, but I still knew that… if it weren’t for all these supernatural powers, this wouldn’t be happening. If my performance in bed had been lackluster, Alice and Noelle wouldn’t be so happy that they said yes to me. I wondered if that knowledge would ever stop stinging? The only thing that helped me get my mind off those uncomfortable thoughts was renewing my resolution to grow, to better myself, to become someone worthy of the good things happening to me. Because if I wasn’t good enough, it meant I had no time to stop and feel sorry for myself.

I stepped out of the bathroom, smiled at the girls and went to join them in the hot tub.


Patreon.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)