Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 9 by Creature0909
Who does Tails pick?
Amy
“Are you sure about Amy?” Tails asked “She’s Sonic’s girl," Vanilla nodded as a confirmation. Tails was still skeptical, but if this was real, maybe Amy would stop treating him like a kid, but at the same time...why could this even be real? Sonic and Amy were together, weren't they?
Those questions and more weighed on his mind as he made his way towards her place in Station Square, Tails knocked on Amy's door, as Amy opened it rather quickly and practically threw Tails into her apartment. Tails saw Amy already undressing as Tails asked "Amy, wait! It's me!" hoping that this was some kind of mistake, Tails is Sonic's best friend that has to come first before even sex, right?
The pink hedgehog giggled as she said "Oh, Tails. I know it's you," Tails gulped at that as she continued to undress flinging off her dress which caused Tails to go wide eyed, sure he's seen bigger, but Amy was quite busty, which he didn't expect however she was coming on way to strong. He started to back away as Amy walked to him, a hungry predator stalking her fox prey, he stumbled to the floor as Amy's shoes were kicked off next to him which made him more and more scared but Amy smirked as Tails forgot the excitement he had seeing that Amy was far more busty than anticipated had made him start to grown hard. Amy started to rub on his dick gently with her foot as Tails was locked up trying to get out of this.
Amy said "Tails, Tails, Tails," shaking her head as she continued to move her foot up and down his shaft, "I may love Sonic, but I'm still a woman and Tails," she pulled off her panties and slapped it onto his face "and Sonic hasn't been around for days, " Tails saw her pussy dripping "Tails, you can't imagine how bad I feel, but when Vanilla told me you're becoming a massive lady killer, I thought it was a perfect opportunity. I finally get some sex, you add a name to your kill count, and Sonic will never ever have to know." Tails gulped at that "Everyone wins."
Tails sniffed the panties on his face, they smelled so good, she was horny as all get out! He started to think about just going with it, springing up from his state and show her what Wave, Cream, and Rouge got but his mind went back to Sonic. Sonic and him weren't just friends, they were like brothers, this is his girlfriend, no matter how tempting she is making this, there is no way he could do this to him. He wanted out as he said "Amy, I...I just can't, Sonic's my best friend...it was stupid of me to think any other way, look I can eat you out or something but I'm not fucking you. I draw the line at that."
He then tensed up but not in pleasure, but pure fear, as Amy gave a laugh that would make Eggman jealous shaking her head "Oh you sweet little fox boy," she smirked "I can see that orange monster you have right there," Amy said looking at his dick which was standing on end. "Sonic's lucky to have you as a friend, but unfortunantly for you, I'm not as nice..."
The first thing Amy did was yank Tails up so his legs were in the air as she placed his dick inside of her and started to thrust like she was fucking him as he could only yelp and grunt trying to get out of this, maybe find some water, maybe anything...his fox mind still had to admit that it did feel good when she did this to him, but he shook his head. He needed to be a bro, Tails then felt Amy slap him across the face "Don't try to resist, Tails, just enjoy." She slapped him again "Come on, you stupid fox boy, I know you can get harder than this." She slapped him a third time, "It's cute how much you want to be a bro to Sonic, but guess what, he's not here and I'm not leaving until I do whatever I want with you. As far as I'm concerned, the minute you knocked on my door, you were mine for the rest of the day, and you are not getting out of this, so just let me fuck you!"
Tails couldn't move, he couldn't find anything to do, he closed his eyes trying to get soft, trying to go limp but...Amy's pussy was like a vice, she was sucking him in the more she fucked him. Tails looked up at her, and saw her tits slapping uncontrollably, the way her body moved, he closed his eyes giving up and just letting himself enjoy this.
As he felt himself getting harder in Amy, she dropped his legs on the floor and just started to ride him grabbing him by the neck, which shocked him as she started to **** him a bit "Glad we understand each other, Tails. Now until I say we're done, you're going to be nothing more than my bitch!" as she started to ride her normally, but she was still **** him, he was going to pass out soon, until she let go as he coughed Amy leaning back and swirling around his cock in front of Tails essentially using him like a living dildo as she moved her tits up and down saying, "I love this, I missed this so much..." Tails wanted to take control but after the smacking he received he was fearful for any retaliation, Amy smirked and got off of Tails which he sighed with relief over. He hadn't felt any orgasm, but maybe him being static helped.
That was until she yoinked him until she was on his hands and knees "You thought you could get out of this by not thrusting?" She smirked "Sorry, Bitch, but I'm going to have fun with you whether you like it or not. He heard clicking behind him as Tails went to say something he suddenly has to lock up as he felt a foreign sensation. Something slowly entering his ass.
Tails could feel Amy thrust into his ass as Tails went to say something but felt her slap him in the ass saying "Bitches don't talk until I say so." spanking him again and again, "You're such a stand up guy, Tails. You couldn't fuck Sonic's girlfriend, to bad you didn't think that his girlfriend couldn't just fuck you in response!" Tails was crying out in pain, it hurt so much, and he wanted out of this, but knew he was powerless to stop her. So the only thing to do was to just take it and hope it would be over soon.
Amy started to moan out saying "God damn Bitch, I'm liking you as a boy toy already. Sonic would never let me peg him." She grabbed his cock and started to stroke him with her hand. "I'm going to love this more and more ." Tails went to object but she only thrusted harder smirking as she kept going and going until she heard Tails cry out as his cum started to fall on the floor. Amy smirked as she pulled out of his ass "So, is bitch boy ready to play ball now?"
Tails looked at himself, body in his own cum, his ass was hurting, Amy was not relenting, he was shaking as he sat up, looking at his hands. Amy turned and said "I'm not satisfied," in a mocking tone her pussy being waved in front of his face "Eat me out like you said you were going to do, Bitch Boy." the way she was talking the way that she was mocking him, Tails let out a primal growl which caused Amy to back up a bit as the two tailed fox turned to the Pink Hedgehog.
"Okay Tails, I think I went a little to far here," Amy said backing away, her the helpless one "I was just excited for a good dicking, so I thought I could take con..." Tails didn't want to hear any excuses as she was **** onto her hands and knees as he **** himself into her mouth and started to thrush inside of her lips, his cock slapping down her throat as he could hear Amy gagging and panting grabbing at him trying to pull him off. However Tails didn't care, she treated him like a toy so she'll get what she deserved, as he felt his loins coil up again and busted a nice good nut down her throat as she moved Tails yanking out his cock as she started to cough on the ground over and over, throwing up the excess of cum as Amy looked at him terrified.
Tails grabbed Amy and pressed her against the wall from behind "Bitch Boy is going to make Mistress pay for what he did" giving her a good solid spanking as he pressed his cock around her ass, lubbed up by a combination of her spit and his cum as he **** himself in Amy cried out "To Tight! It hurts!" as Tails started to thrust like there was no tomorrow knowing how tight it was as Amy was folding like he was.
Tails, grabbed her neck as he started to **** as he thrusted, her gagging only spurring him on further and further, he let go only so Amy didn't pass out on him as he mauled at her tits thrusting faster and faster. He feroiciously said "Oh, Amy, "Bitch Boy" is going to make sure that you'll never forget this!" as he gave one dominate thrust he saw Amy squirting from her vagina on her floor, as he pumped inside of her, as he pulled out he shook his head as Amy crumbled to a heap on the floor.
Tails started to regain composure as Amy said "Holy...shit..." Amy responded to Tails as she sat up. "What the hell was that, Tails?" she sighed "Though I can't say I didn't deserve that a little."
"I don't know, I just snapped" Tails admitted sheepishly "I wanted you to make you felt what I felt," as Amy turned her head to him, Tails sighed "I lost my mind...it was like my body and mind just wanted to fuck you into submission."
Amy held her ass as she said "You did that," looking at the bruising on Tails's own ass. "Okay, this went way to far." as Tails looked at the mess they made of her living room. "And I started it in the first place." she looked at him and said "I thought I would feel good about this, I really don't..." Amy sighed "I cheated on Sonic with his best friend, and not only that I just..."
Tails put up his hand "As long as we both agree that if we ever do this again it's when you are single, and we won't go crazy unless we want to." Amy nodded to that.
After some cleaning up Tails left her apartment. Not exactly how he wanted it to go, if go at all, but Amy was on his list. He put his hand under his chin as he thought about what Vanilla said about Blaze, or wondered if he could tap that sweet MILF, then again, those weren't the only girls he knew.
What's next?
Sonic Erotic Heroes
Screwing around at the speed of sound
Play as your favorite Sonic Character as they go on their own adventures, for money, love, power, or to just get laid.
Updated on May 23, 2026
by Creature0909
Created on Jun 26, 2023
by Creature0909
- 151 Likes
- 63,057 Views
- 69 Favorites
- 22 Bookmarks
- 115 Chapters
- 22 Chapters Deep
Comments moved below the chapter.

Comments