Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 45 by PhoenixAuthor PhoenixAuthor

What's next?

The Wild Ones

The bottle came to a stop on Zoe Simmons, who grinned happily when she saw the neck of the bottle pointing her way.

“Hmmm…” Zoe tapped her chin, looking around the room before her gaze settled on Jace and a smirk split her face.

“I want you to come over here and spank me, Jace.” Zoe said hungrily, and Jace grinned widely. Zoe loved whenever he got his hands on her ass. Loved even more when he’d been inside her ass. He’d loved it too. She was tight and incredible down there, and she knew it, too.

“If you insist.” Jace said, rising up to his feet and crossing the distance to Zoe quickly. Zoe happily flipped over onto her stomach, and she got up on all fours, shaking her ass eagerly. She didn’t need to take anything off, as Skylar had already removed her shorts back during the clothing dare.

“Make sure you do it good.” Skylar told Jace with a wink. Zoe giggled.

“Oh, Jace has plenty of experience with my ass. He knows what he’s doing.” Zoe grinned.

Skylar seemed briefly shocked by that information before her grin returned.

Jace pulled back his hand, smirking when he saw Zoe’s eyes fixed firmly on his hand, and then he slapped it down across Zoe’s cheek, giving a satisfying smack noise and making Zoe gasp in pleasure.

Jace did it again, eliciting a “Yes!” from Zoe.

Evan grimaced, watching his sister get spanked, and Brooklyn looked on jealously. Well, not jealous of being spanked, um, well, maybe, but jealous that Jace was paying Zoe so much attention.

Brooklyn looked over at David’s empty spot and wondered what was keeping him. Surely there was no way him and Olivia were actually doing anything? Olivia was seven years older than David!

A yelp from Zoe brought Brooklyn’s attention back to the present, and Brooklyn winced at the sound of another hard slap to Zoe’s huge, round, curvy, fat ass. Brooklyn watched Zoe’s cheeks ripple from the contact point and her cheeks flushed.

Imagining Jace spanking her… being spanked wasn’t something Brooklyn had ever considered before, but Zoe was clearly enjoying herself, and Brooklyn figured that Jace would never hurt her.

Maybe it wouldn’t hurt to give it a try one day… if Jace ever paid her any attention.

“Don’t hurt her!” Kayla exclaimed when one particularly savage spank echoed across the room, as did Zoe’s scream.

“Oh, don’t worry, Ms. Roberts, she’s loving it.” Skylar laughed, and the queen bee of Violet River High watched with big, admiring green eyes as Jace spanked Zoe’s phenomenal ass over and over again, until her plump cheeks were bright red, and Zoe seemed dazed from the pleasure she’d just been experiencing.

“That good enough?” Jace asked Zoe, who nodded, her straight black hair falling in her face as she did. Jace leaned down and kissed Zoe’s left cheek, making Skylar grin.

“Sorry for spanking you over and over again.” Jace told Zoe’s ass, making Zoe and Skylar both giggle. Jace peppered kisses all over both of Zoe’s plump cheeks, and when Jace stood up to leave, Zoe bumped him with her ass playfully. He grinned at her, and she grinned back as Jace returned to his seat.

Zoe moved to spin the bottle, and it spun around and around before landing on Rachel, who clapped her hands together.

“Alright. This dare’s going to be a bit of a competition.” Rachel grinned, “Kayla and Daphne. I dare you two to each pick one of the boys in this circle, and then stand by for further instructions.”

Kayla grabbed Jace’s arm before Daphne could hardly blink, and Daphne glared at her best friend before looking back at the options before her.

Jayden, Owen, or Evan.

“I’ll pick Evan.” Daphne said, and went over to sit by him.

“Alright, so here’s the dare. You two need to compete to see how fast you can get your boys off. The twist? You can only use your hands and your voice.” Rachel explained.

“Our voice?” Kayla asked, puzzled.

“Dirty talk.” Rachel answered, “You can tell him dirty stories, whisper your secret fantasies to him, etc etc. You girls ready?”

Kayla and Daphne nodded.

“Go!” Rachel exclaimed, and Daphne and Kayla were both racing. Jace only had boxers on his lower half, so it was easier for Kayla to get to his cock, whereas Daphne had to pull off shorts as well as boxers.

Jace pulled off his shirt as Kayla’s soft hand wrapped around his cock. Jace sucked in a breath, feeling his favorite teacher’s hand wrapped around his cock.

“You like that?” Kayla asked hopefully. Jace nodded.

“Uh huh. It’s really good.” Jace groaned, and Kayla smiled.

“So, I guess I’m supposed to be telling you dirty stories or something, but I don’t really have any.” Kayla confessed, “So… I’m just going to jump in the deep end and tell you my biggest fantasy.”

“Ok.” Jace agreed instantly. Kayla smiled, and as she fondly stroked Jace’s cock, she began to tell him her greatest fantasy, or she would have if a trio of people hadn’t just re-entered the room.

Jace’s mouth fell open upon seeing Olivia. Her face and tits were covered in cum, and she wore only panties at the moment.

“Holy shit!” Rachel exclaimed, grinning.

David was dressed the same as he was when he left, with shorts but no shirt, and Danielle was naked thanks to Daphne’s earlier dare.

Jace saw to his surprise that his mother had a hand on David’s arm as they walked.

Olivia was clearly mortified at being in front of the group covered in cum, but she kept her voice fairly steady.

“Owen? We’re going home now.” Olivia said, and Jace stared in amazement when he realized one lens of Olivia’s glasses was coated in cum, so she could only see out of one eye.

“I think we are, too, Jayden.” Brooklyn announced with very flushed cheeks, and with some quick goodbyes, the Vanes and the Robinsons left through the back door to return to their houses.

While Kayla and Daphne continued their competition, Danielle and David returned to their spots near Rachel.

“You two were gone for a while.” Rachel whispered, “Did you guys get up to some fun?”

Danielle hugged David from behind, and Rachel gave her best friend a knowing look.

“A little bit.” Danielle confessed, and David flushed.

“Look at you!” Rachel beamed at David, “Making it big-time.”

“Don’t be shy, honey.” Danielle murmured to David, “Neither of us are teasing you.”

“Yes, in fact,” Rachel said, taking David’s hands, “I’m very proud of you.”

“You are?” David asked in amazement.

“Very.” Danielle agreed, and Rachel slid forwards so David was practically pinned between the two MILFs’ bosoms.

“So very proud.” Rachel nodded, “You’re really coming into your own, it seems. I’m happy to help you get over your shyness.”

“Me too.” Danielle said, and she kissed David’s cheek from behind him.

Rachel leaned forwards and kissed his other cheek. With Rachel’s huge naked tits pushed against his chest, and Danielle’s slightly smaller tits pushed against his back, David was in Heaven.

Speaking of Heaven, Jace was also really enjoying himself. He had an incredible view of Kayla’s mouthwatering large breasts restrained by just a lacy bra. Her blonde hair was streaming down her shoulders, and her pretty blue eyes were fixed on Jace as she spoke to him.

“So. My biggest fantasy is a little, um, dirty. Ok, very dirty.” Kayla giggled, and Jace grinned.

“No complaints here.” Jace said, and then Kayla started talking and he forgot all about the rest of the group in the room. Kayla took up his entire attention.

“So, my biggest fantasy involves some of my students.” Kayla blushed, “Specifically my cheerleaders and my football player students. The biggest fantasy I’ve ever had is that I’ll be in the locker room with the cheerleaders after a football game, a game they just won. All of the cheerleaders will be changing out of their uniforms and back into normal clothes. And then the locker room door will open and you’ll walk in, Jace, you and the rest of the football team.”

Thoughts of Brooklyn and Skylar and Dana and Reyna and Layla and Ruby and Audrey and Ana and Astrid and all the other girls changing clothes were sexy enough. Throw in Kayla, too? Goddamn, Jace was already enjoying this fantasy.

“The football players will walk forwards, and they announce that they’re here to thank the cheerleaders, for doing such a good job.” Kayla blushed deeper, “And then you football players pull out your cocks. You all walk forwards more, and the cheerleaders happily accept the football players’ gratitude. The football players all start fucking the cheerleaders. And you, Jace… in my fantasies, it’s always you who comes and fucks me.”

Kayla gazed at her favorite student with loving eyes, and Jace’s cock throbbed as his favorite teacher confessed to lusting after him.

“Of course I would.” Jace growled to her, “You’re gorgeous. You’re so fucking sexy, I would happily fuck you.”

Kayla seemed encouraged by Jace’s words, and so she jerked harder, his pre-cum lubing up his cock as best it could. Kayla wasn’t sure if she could properly lube up Jace’s cock, as Rachel had said hands and voice only, so she didn’t wanna break the rules.

“You’ve got me pushed against the lockers. You’re pounding me hard, my arms are wrapped around your neck, your lips are on mine, then they’re on my jaw, then on my neck, then you’re licking my cleavage. I’m writhing in pleasure.” Kayla’s fantasy poured out eagerly now, and her stroke tempo increased, too.

“Fuck.” Jace groaned. He was getting close, really close.

“All around us, cheerleaders are screaming out loud as the football team fucks them. I’m screaming out loud as my favorite student fucks me senseless. I’m so close to orgasming, and then you slam into me balls deep, and when you cum, I do too.” Kayla flushed again, “And then I wake up in my bed, soaked, visions of you burned into my brain, and wishing I could someday get the real thing.”

Jace grunted and he couldn’t stop himself from cumming. Kayla’s tits took the majority of the load, though some hit her stomach and some splashed up onto her chin.

“Oh my God.” Kayla moaned, and to Jace’s amazement, she dipped her fingers in the thick layer of cum on her tits and put her fingers in her mouth, humming happily at the taste of his cum.

“Kayla and Jace win!” Rachel’s voice came, and Jace realized with a start that they were still in the spin the bottle circle, and that there had been a competition going on.

“Fuck, I was so close.” Evan groaned.

“Sorry, you gotta stop now, Daphne. Evan lost, he gets to keep playing with blue balls.” Rachel chuckled.

Daphne laughed at that, and she made her way back over to Jace and Kayla, looking with some kind of weird burning in her stomach at the intimate way they were talking, and at the cum splatter across Kayla’s tits. Daphne’s were bigger, but she didn’t know why she felt the need to reaffirm that.

“Daphne? I think we should go.” Kayla blushed, “I need to get cleaned up, and… I don’t think I should stay.”

“Getting a little too frisky?” Daphne smirked.

“A little.” Kayla giggled nervously.

“Don’t worry, babe, it’s not that she doesn’t like you, it’s that she’s getting horny and flustered.” Daphne told Jace with a smirk as Kayla got to her feet and headed towards the door.

“Really?” Jace asked. Daphne nodded and kissed her favorite nephew’s forehead.

“Oh, yes. Word of advice. Get to her class early on Monday. As early as you can.” Daphne winked, and she followed Kayla out with a pit in her stomach. Surely it wasn’t jealousy? No, it must just be some kind of weirdness from her nephew and her best friend getting it on. There was no way she was jealous that her best friend had gotten to get Jace’s cum all over her… right?

“I probably should leave, too.” Zoe admitted, “I’ve got work in the morning.”

“On a Sunday?” Skylar protested.

“Unfortunately.” Zoe said wryly, and she blew a Jace a kiss as she rose up, wriggled her shorts back up her long, long legs and left through the back door with a “Bye, everyone.”

“Man, everyone’s leaving, huh?” Skylar put her hands on her hips, shaking her head.

Indeed, a lot of the circle was empty now, so everyone scooted together into a closer circle, which brought about some changes in seating layout.

Jace found himself now between Dana and Danielle, while David remained between Danielle and Rachel. Evan sat between Claire and Izzy still, while Skylar had a spot between Izzy and Dana.

“So, Rachel, I believe you’re spinning.” Skylar took charge, and the mature brunette nodded. Rachel, her huge naked tits dangling as she did so, leaned over and spun the bottle, as it was now much closer to everyone.

The bottle came to a stop on Skylar, who grinned deviously.

“Do you know, I’ve always been interested in twins.” Skylar said eagerly, “Call it a side effect of being one myself. I wanna know who’s the better kisser between you twins. Jace and Dana.”

Dana choked.

“Huh? You want to kiss me?” Dana asked in shock.

“Uh huh. Jace, too.” Skylar grinned.

“Need another sample of my kissing ability?” Jace grinned at Skylar.

“Oh? I didn’t know you two had kissed.” Danielle grinned at her only son.

“Me either!” Isabelle exclaimed.

“A few times.” Skylar chuckled.

“Making me jealous.” Evan said, clutching at his bare chest.

“Oh, hush.” Skylar snapped, “The only kiss you got out of me was at a truth or dare game.”

“Still counts.” Evan grinned.

David squirmed in his seat at the prospect of seeing Dana kiss the sexiest girl in school, the untouchable, ridiculously popular Skylar Wayne, a girl David couldn’t get up enough nerve to speak to.

Rachel glanced knowingly at the skinny brown-haired boy, and she rubbed his back consolingly, leaning her head on his shoulder. David swallowed as Rachel’s giant tits entered his field of vision, and his arm reflexively wrapped around her.

Rachel grinned sideways at her best friend’s son. He was getting awfully confident around her, and in part Danielle, too. She hoped she’d be able to extend that to all women across the board, not just the two women he’d grown up around.

Skylar rose up onto her feet, smirking as she came toward the Holland twins, who were sitting side by side.

Skylar stood in front of the two seated Hollands, looking back and forth between them.

Skylar chose Dana to go first, and to make her sexy fellow cheerleader squirm, Skylar stepped forwards and lowered herself onto Dana’s thighs, sitting squarely in the girl’s lap. Dana let out an adorable squeak.

Jace and David and Evan all watched with open mouths as Skylar and Dana’s bra-covered bosoms pressed together.

“Pucker up.” Skylar smirked, and then she cupped Dana’s chin with both hands, and kissed the shorter blonde.

David’s cock was full on throbbing in an instant. He’d always found Dana stupidly sexy, and Skylar was, of course, sex walking.

Seeing the two girls kissing. There tits pressing together. Dana’s hands looking incredibly awkward, but reaching up to touch Skylar’s bare back tentatively.

Dana moaned into Skylar’s mouth, and David jerked suddenly when he felt a hand on his bulge. He looked down and saw a pale arm leading to.. Rachel. She gave him a sideways look, and then she kissed him on the cheek.

“Come on.” Rachel tugged him by the bulge, and she rose to her feet. David quickly stood up, too.

“Where are you guys off to?” Claire asked, confused.

“Getting some snacks.” Rachel answered innocently.

“Bring me some chips.” Evan said, his eyes shamelessly flicking between Rachel’s huge tits and bare pussy. As Rachel passed him, he gave her fat, round ass a hard spank. Rachel giggled, and she bumped her hip against the side of his head.

“Will do.” Rachel smirked, but then Claire exclaimed in shock.

“Evan! Don’t smack Rachel’s butt like that!” she scolded him sternly.

“Jealous, Claire?” Rachel teased her best friend, and she looked to Evan, “Do me a favor, Evan, take care of her.”

Rachel then grabbed David by the arm, and led him quickly from the room. Evan didn’t waste any time in wrapping his arms around the naked Claire Johnson and pulling her into his lap.

“Hey!” Claire protested, trying to squirm her way free.

“Sorry, Ms. J. Mrs. B said I needed to take care of you.” Evan said with a smirk, and he gave her shoulder a kiss. Claire opened her mouth to protest, but Evan didn’t stop planting kisses along her shoulder blades slowly, then gradually traveled upwards, up the back of her neck.

“Evan.” Claire groaned, “You should stop.”

“Why’s that? You’re not like your two friends. You aren’t married. You’re welcome to have some fun, if you want.” Evan said, “I’ll stop if you really want me to… but I think it could be a lot of fun. Me and you, that is.”

Claire turned back around to look at him.

“I suppose it has been a few years.” Claire said weakly.

“Years?! Jeez, now I’m determined. I think… you and I should head off to get some alone time.” Evan said, “Make up for your multi year dry spell.”

Claire flushed lightly.

“It’s like you’re a male Rachel.” she shook her head, but then she looked at him. “I guess… as long as David never finds out, that wouldn’t be such a bad idea.”

Evan leaned down and kissed her neck, making the MILF sigh.

“It’s a great idea.” he agreed.

Everyone else’s attention had returned to Skylar and Dana, who were still lip-locked. Jace especially had his eyes locked on the kissing blondes, as they were sitting right next to him.

The fact that one of the girls was his twin sister took none of the arousal away. Hell, it may even increase the arousal. Jace certainly had a thing for his sisters.

Skylar finally broke the kiss, and to Jace’s horny amazement, Dana’s lips followed Skylar’s, a whine breaking free from his sister’s lips.

“Down, girl.” Skylar giggled, “It’s your brother’s turn.”

Dana’s cheeks flushed, and the hot arousal inside her surprised her, mainly that it came from… a girl. Feeling confused and horny, Dana didn’t put up any more resistance as Skylar slid from her lap into Jace’s.

“Miss me? It’s been a little while since I’ve gotten my mouth on you.” Skylar teased Jace. Jace grabbed big handfuls of Skylar’s pert ass, and Skylar smirked at him, before leaning down and kissing him with plenty of familiarity.

It had been a while, but Skylar and Jace had had several fun encounters together the prior school year.

Jace kissed Skylar fiercely, just as fiercely as he was groping her toned perky ass, just as fiercely as Skylar was smashing her large, round tits into Jace’s chest.

“Damn, you two really have done this before.” Isabelle said surprisedly.

“Did you think I was lying?” Skylar smirked at her best friend.

“Sky’s too hot to resist.” Jace shrugged at his cousin.

“Awww. Thanks.” Skylar said, and laid a grateful kiss on Jace’s mouth.

“So? Which of my kids is the better kisser?” Danielle laughed.

“Mmm.” Skylar said contemplatively. She gave Jace another scorching hot kiss, her tongue sliding inside his mouth to tease his tongue. Jace’s tongue came up to Skylar’s, but she leaned away before he could make contact, dropping him a wink.

“Jace definitely has experience.” Skylar thought aloud, and then, still in Jace’s lap, she leaned over to Dana, and gave her another kiss. Skylar’s tongue slid into Dana’s mouth, and unlike Jace, Dana didn’t challenge Skylar’s tongue, she submitted to it.

Dana quickly submitted to the experienced blonde, and Skylar’s kissing got heavier and more dominant, which made Dana’s hands tremble.

“But mmm, Dana’s lips are softer and yummier and plumper.” Skylar said, punctuating each adjective with another kiss on the petite girl’s lips. Dana blushed at the praise. Skylar leaned back.

“I think the only way to see who’s the better kisser… is to have them kiss each other.” Skylar tapped her chin thoughtfully.

“What?!” Dana squeaked. Isabelle laughed, interested in seeing what came out of this. Surely Jace and Dana wouldn’t really kiss.

“Have you two never kissed before?” Skylar raised an eyebrow.

“Um…” Dana squirmed under Skylar’s intense green gaze.

“Once or twice.” Jace grinned.

“Oh, good. You almost had me thinking Sam and I were weirdos.” Skylar chuckled.

“You and Sam have kissed?” Isabelle choked.

“No way.” Evan grinned, “You two are always at each other’s throats.”

“I’ve kissed my twin brother.” Danielle admitted.

“You kissed Uncle Dean?” Dana gasped, shocked.

“That’s crazy, Mom.” Jace said, and Danielle looked at him with a quirked eyebrow.

“Yeah, back when we were in high school, we experimented a tiny bit.” Danielle admitted.

“I guess it’s a very normal thing to do, then.” Skylar shrugged.

“You people are crazy.” Claire shook her head.

“I’d never kiss my sister.” Evan agreed with Claire.

“Really? Your sister’s a total hottie.” Jace said in surprise.

“She’s also your big sister. I’d never kiss my older brother, Declan, and I can’t imagine you’d kiss Daisy.” Danielle said.

“Yeah, I’d never do that.” Jace agreed, a tiny bit too emphatically.

No one seemed to notice, thankfully, and Skylar took back control of the conversation.

“Alright, Hollands. Kiss.” Skylar ordered, still in Jace’s lap and clearly not planning to move anytime soon.

“Jace…” Dana managed before her brother pulled her close and kissed her. Just like before, back at the party last night, Dana melted into his arms.

She loved the way his arms squeezed around her, and the heat of his mouth. Jace’s hands didn’t grope her like he’d groped Skylar, and part of her was very disappointed, but part of her was relieved.

Their mom was watching! Their cousin was watching! But some part of Dana’s mind didn’t care. She just wanted Jace. The other parts of her weren’t agreeing with her want, but damn them.

Too quickly, Jace took his mouth off hers, but this time, Dana quenched her burning desire to try and kiss him again, and against her own wishes, she leaned back to her spot.

“Well. I think Jace wins.” Skylar smirked.

What's next?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)