Josie in blue

The blue dress matches their eyes perfectly. Something tells you this is a detail that Josie would go for.

"Josie is in blue. It matches her eyes."

You know you guess correctly as Josie begins to smile and Jackie frowns saying "that's just luck! I have the same eyes!"

A memory dawns on you and you hope it'll add you brownie points, "Well and Josie thinks pink is cliche" you add "she told me back in high school."

Josie is beaming now as she moves next to you and slips your arm around her shoulders. "Oh I'm going to rock your world tonight" she whispers into your ear.

Jackie and the redhead are talking to each other. With the noise of the party you can't make out what they're saying, and you're not sure you want too with Josie at your side.

"What do you have planned for me tonight" she purrs, playfully nipping at your ear.

This was an unexpected turn of fate. What do you want?

Perhaps a threesome with Jackie or the redhead, or foursome! Would they be game? Would Josie be offended? Maybe something intimate with just her would be better?