Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by ExpandingUniverseGames ExpandingUniverseGames

What's next?

Back With Alice

Please log in to view the image

Four hours later I woke up to use the bathroom and tried not to disturb Alice sleeping next to me. When I returned I found her sitting up at the foot of the bed. My guilty conscience made me think the worst until I noticed the playful smirk on her face.

“Sit here,” she said. “I want your cock in my mouth.”

I felt my heart beating in my chest. Saying no to such a request would not only be suspicious, it would be insane. But I hadn’t showered and I knew my dick would taste like multiple rounds inside her best friend.

I sat down reluctantly, wondering how long this BJ would last. She didn’t waste time, pulling down my pants and using her hands to get me started. I’d woken up with a boner, so it didn’t take long for it to reappear.

“I felt bad about yesterday,” she said.

“Why? You’re not the one who came within two minutes.”

“But you only got one round, and I could tell you were ready for more.”

I couldn’t help but smile. “I’m the one who should be giving you a turn.”

“Maybe later,” she said. “After I shower, and after you fuck me again.”

Next, she took me in her mouth and proved herself to be far more skilled than I would have expected from her. After all, if you have a magic pussy, why perfect your cock sucking skills?

Please log in to view the image

There were only two reasons I could think of. Either you were a massive slut or you really enjoyed it. And it had taken me five dates to get naked, so I didn’t think it was the first.

She used her tongue like a master. I was so distracted from all the alternating sensations swirling around my head I forgot all about my worry about how I tasted like her best friend’s pussy. But she didn’t seem to notice.

Then she did something that impressed me even more than how fast she got me off yesterday. She took me to the balls.

Please log in to view the image

“Shiiiit!” I hissed as quietly as I could manage. “You’re incredible!”

When she backed off there was an audible pop. “Are you close?” she asked.

I was almost offended, thinking she had a low opinion of me from the day before, but then I realized I actually was. If she continued this **** I wouldn’t be able to last another thirty seconds.

I nodded.

She sat up, pushed me back and climbed on top of me. She fucked me quietly, her pussy feeling like magic but still giving me a break from all her tongue action.

I was thankful to the fact I’d cum three times in the past twelve hours, and I was able to last despite the lovely sight of the sexy tattooed blonde using my cock in the morning light.

Maybe it was the BJ, maybe it was the lust, maybe it was how incredibly tight she felt, but I started to regret sneaking off into her best friend’s room four hours earlier. Maybe there was a future here after all, and I could only hope I hadn’t already fucked it all up.

This time she orgasmed, a cute picture as her eyes scrunched up and she did her best to keep quiet. When she finished I climbed on top of her and kissed her as I sped up the pace. I cherished the moment, enjoying her tightness as I fucked her, wondering if I could bring her to a second orgasm as I…

Came inside her.

Shit.

When I finished, her eyes opened.

“Did you finish inside me?”

“Of course. Did you want me to pull out?” I asked, playing it off like I meant to.

“Well, yeah. It’s risky.”

“Are you not on the pill?”

“No.”

“Shit. When you said we didn’t need a condom…”

“I thought you’d pull out.”

“Wow,” I said. “Twice in two days, huh?”

“It’ll be fine.”

“I know,” I said. “But you do realize the pull out method isn’t really a method, right?”

“What do you mean?”

“Accidents happen. Like, all the time.”

“Really? Lots of my friends do that.”

“And one of your friends just had a baby.”

"Ha! True.”

“Plus, your pussy is insane. I didn’t even last one song yesterday.”

“Okay, fine. We can use condoms.”

“Yuck.”

“Right?”

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)