Try explain yourself to Jennifer

Everyone splits off to go to their respective rooms. You wait for Riley & Chad to be fully gone, then head towards Jennifer's room.

You absolutely have to try and explain the whole merchant situation and your embarrassing failure in the caves if you want a chance with her during the getaway.

*knock* *knock* you knock on her door.

"Come in~" you here Jennifer say on the other side of the door, flirtatiously.

"Was she expecting you? Is this your moment?" you think to yourself.

You open the door and walk into the room.

The cheeky smile on her face instantly melts into disappointment as she sees you.

"Oh, I thought you were someone else" She says disappointingly.

"What's up buddy?" she asks condescendingly.

You attempt to explain to her that the situation with the merchant was an accident and how you thought it wouldn't be as realistic as it was. You continue to also explain how in the caves, you simply forgot the spell you were going to use to save her. It was an honest mistake. She nods half heatedly as you explain, showing no real interest in your excuses.

Before you can finish trying to redeem yourself, you're interrupted by a knock at the door.

"Oh shit" Jennifer says in a hush.

"One moment!" she calls out.

"You need to hide. Now." she says to you in a low stern voice.

She grabs your arm and pulls you towards her closet. She opens the door and throws you in there with ease.

(Have you always been this weak? You just got man-handled by a girl who's smaller than you.)

She closes the door while looking at you with a finger on her mouth "ssssssh, don't make a sound" she whispers.

"It's dark in here" you think to yourself. You can barely see anything inside the closed wardrobe, but between the wardrobe door gaps you can see out clear as day.

You hear the door open.

"Hello~ my savior~" you hear Jennifer say.

"Your hero is here!" you hear Chad's familiar voice say

Your heart sinks.

"Chad, that bastard. What is he doing here!?" you think to yourself.

"I'm here to collect my reward for saving you today." he continues.

"hehe I suppose I do still owe you for that~" Jennifer replies.

You see them both walk over to the bed and Jennifer starts removing her clothes.

"Are you sure this is what you want?" Chad asks.

"Of course, this is what we agreed too" Jennifer replies.

You see her remove her shirt and reveal her bra and panties. She removes her panties and bra, fully revelaing her perfect body that you so yearned for, then lays down on the bed, flat on her stomach.

"I guess it's time for the main event" Chad says.

"Fuck. That should be me standing there getting the reward for saving her. Why did I not just learn 1 spell??" you think to yourself.

Chad pulls down his pants to reveal his cock.

"This jackass is cheating on my sister, in the same house as her!" I think.

"I should go tell her" you think.

Just as you go to get out of the closet, Jennifer wraps her lips around his cock.

The girl you've wanted for so long is currently sucking the cock of the guy you hate most. All because you failed to do one simple thing.

You try to leave, but watching her suck his dick is hypnotising. You feel your own cock growing in your pants.

"Maybe... I can tell my sister after..." you think to yourself.

You pull out your dick and start stocking it as you watch her pleasure Chad.

You notice that your dick seems a bit smaller than usual... must be the cold.

She continues to suck his cock with full passion. Her perfect tits on full display throughout.

"I wonder how big his cock really is..." you find yourself thinking.

"Do you like that? Do you like sucking my cock?" Chad asks her.

Jennifer moans and nods in response.

"How about your pussy? Would you like me to fuck your tight little hole?" he asks.

Her eyes light up as she looks up from Chad's cock.

"Yes, please" she says.

You feel a sinking feeling in your chest again as you realize what's about to happen.

Jennifer spins around and presents her wet pussy to Chad. Her head is now facing directly at you.

He grabs his cock and rams himself into her. He begins pounding her pussy hard and fast.

She sees you through the wardrobe door gaps and stares directly at you. She knows full well that you're watching.

You can't help but continue to pump your cock in your hand as you watch your Crush get thoroughly fucked in front of you.

"Hmmm, this pussy feels nice and tight" he tells her.

He pounds away at her pussy. His thrusting getting faster and harder with each stroke.

"Ooohhh yesss, fuck me Chad! Fuck me hard! Please don't stop!" Jennifer begs.

"Please, please cum in me Chad!" she pleads.

You continue to watch as your crush is getting taken away from you right in front of your eyes. All you can manage to do is jerk off and watch. You feel pathetic.

He pulls her to her feet and begins fucking her senseless, holding her in place with his fingers as hooks in her mouth.

"Ahh, Ahh, yes, fill me with that cum!" she cries out.

He grabs her ass cheeks and picks her up, slamming her body against the wardrobe. Her perfect tits bounce wildly while he fucks her savagely.

You close your eyes and start pumping your cock harder as you listen to him pound the shit out of her.

You feel an intense orgasm building inside your balls. You begin to ejaculate in your hand as you open your eyes and watch Chad fuck your crush senseless.

At the same time, Chad drops Jennifer to the ground and shoves his cock down her throat.

He begins pumping cum deep inside her. Cumming in her mouth until he has nothing left.

He stands up, completely spent.

"That was... amazing" he states.

Jennifer falls to her knees, still gasping for breath. She looks towards you and smiles as the cum deposited into her mouth drips down onto her tits.

You can't believe you just witnessed your crush get completely claimed in front of you. You feel so helpless.

You are angry that Chad, who is dating your sister, just cheated on her right in front of you.

You go to readjust your position so you can burst out of the wardrobe and confront him, however, you accidently bump something over in the process.

The object hits the ground with a large thump.

"What was that?" Chad asks.

Jennifer doesn't respond and just looks at you, her body still covered in Chads cum.

Chad walks over to the wardrobe and flings the doors open.

Revealing you. With a hand full of your own cum. Looking up at him.

"haha looks like you had some fun in there." Jennifer says giggling.

"what the fuck you little shit. did you just watch us you little perv." Chad says.

You're speechless. Your cock has gone soft in your hand. You cannot believe this has happened.

"Here's the deal. You'll never tell anyone about this. Ever." Chad says.

"But-but-" you stutter in disbelief.

"Wait, I have an idea!" Jennifer says.

She walks over and rummages through one of her bags and pulls out a small chastity cage.

"I like where this is going!" Chad says as he pulls you out of the wardrobe forcefully.

"oh no, oh no!" you think.

Chad proceeds to hold you down on the bed while Jennifer positions the cage over your spent dick.

"I was worried it wouldn't fit, but your dick looks a little smaller than average so it should be fine" She says giggling a bit.

She locks the cage with the key and places the key around her neck as a necklace. The cage feels tight.

"Now, if you ever want to use that little dick again, you'll need to keep this whole ordeal as a little secret - ok?" she asks.

You nod your head in agreement.

"Good boy. Now get dressed and get out of here" She tells you.

You stand up and quickly leave the room.

You walk back to your room, completely stunned.

"Well that was interesting." you say to yourself as you lay in bed.

You recount the events in your head as you drift off to sleep.