More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 8 by Decipiat

What do I tell her?

Honesty

'Hey, Sarah long time no see,' I cringed as I read the text I just sent my ex. We hadn't spoken in close to 8 months and I wasn't sure how willing she would still be to talk to me.

'Hey, yeah it has been a long time handsome,' she texted back. Oh yeah, now I remember.

Sarah is absolutely infatuated with me, we were each others first relationship. We met in high school and had a lot of firsts together, we eventually broke up because we went to different schools on other sides of the country, but she had moved to my city and asked if I were still available. I had started dating Sarah by that point though so I told her I was not.

We settled into a friendship and everything was going well until one night we all got a little drunk and she confessed that she wanted me back. She wanted to steal me away from Sarah. She claimed I was her one true love. It was a bit of a mess. We all decided no contact was the way to go from then on.

'What's up?' she texted.

'How would you like to hook-up sometime?' I figured being straightforward would be the best approach.

'I'm in,' she sent before sending another text just after, 'wait are you still with Lara?'

'I am,' I texted, 'is that a problem?'

'No,' Sarah said, 'I was just curious why you would cheat on her now all of a sudden.'

So I explained the situation. How Lara had asked me to cheat on her and how Sarah was the obvious choice.

I waited a long time for her response, 'Kinky.' She sent one word that encapsulated the situation quite nicely.

'So,' I sent, 'You in?'

'Meet me at my apartment at 5:00 and you'll find out.'

Should I stay or should I go?

Comments

      More fun
      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)