But How

I took both girls to the hospital the next day. They each got a checkup as I sat in the waiting room.

“Dan?” A nurse called for me.

“Yes?”

“Your girlfriend would like you to join her in the back.”

I followed her down the hallway into one of the rooms, finding both sisters waiting there. Both seats were taken so I leaned against the wall.

Finally, the doctor appeared.

“Both of you are in great shape,” she told us.

“That’s great!” Victoria said.

“The next step is to schedule you for an ultrasound. And we are already at the point where we can determine the gender, if you wish.”

“For me, right?” Asked Victoria. “But Angie can’t be that far along yet.”

“Your sister is actually close to twenty weeks along already,” the doctor told us.

“But… how can that be?” Victoria asked. “I only moved out a couple of months ago. Twenty weeks is… back in August.”

“Shit,” Angie whispered.

“That’s what it was, wasn’t it?” Victoria asked us. “When the two of you stopped bickering. It was because you eased the sexual tension. Because you started having sex with each other.”

“The doctor probably doesn’t want to hear this,” I said. “Is there anything else to know?”

“We’ll find out more at the next appointment,” she said, looking like she was eager to leave.

“Thank, you, Doctor,” I said as she left the room. “Victoria, I-”

“I have nothing to say to either of you.”

On the drive home Victoria hadn’t said a word for the past ten minutes as Angie and I took turns trying to explain things to her.

“This wasn’t something we did lightly,” I explained. “We tried our fucking best, we really did, for your sake. But eventually it was too much.”

“I love him,” Angie repeated. “This past month has been the hardest thing in my life, to stay away from him for your sake. But I did it because I wanted you to be happy, and I knew that he loves you.”

Silence.

“And it’s been hard on me, too,” I added. “I hate seeing her suffer. I hate seeing either of you suffer.”

“I get it!” Victoria yelled. “You love her? Okay! Message received!”

“And I love you.”

“So which is it, huh? Do you love me? Or do you love my sister?”

“I love both of you,” I repeated.

“Well, you can’t have both of us. So you need to choose. Who are you in love with?”.

“Both,” I said. “I‘m in love with both of you.”

“And,” I continued, “I want to marry both of you. I know it’s not legal, but I want you both to be my wives. I want us to raise our children together. And I really think we can be happy.”

“So you want us to share you?” Victoria asked.

“You already have been, right up until our last conversation a month ago.”

“Yeah, right.”

“He’s serious,” Angie spoke up. “He has been entirely loyal to you since then, but before that, we were both sharing him quite successfully.”

“It doesn’t work that way,” Victoria said. “We aren’t Mormons.”

“It could work if we wanted it to.”

“No, Dan. It wouldn’t. You need to make a choice. Me or Angie.”

“I told you. I choose both of you.”

“You can’t! You can’t leave it up to us! We are both having your children. You need to pick one of us!” She was yelling now.

“No, he doesn’t,” Angie whispered in the back seat.

I was about to interrupt her, thinking that she was going to fall on the sword again. But I didn't need to worry.

“Because he already has,” she continued. “He chooses for all of us to be a family, and that’s my choice as well.”

Victoria was silent.

“I want us to be equals,” Angie told her sister. “Dan has enough love for the both of us. And who says we can’t do our own thing? I don’t care what other people think.”

Silence.

“So the only one that needs to choose is you, Victoria. Decide if you want to share Dan with me. He wants to be with you. I want you to be with him. But I also can’t be away from him. I was ready to do that, for you. But now that I know I have a child of my own on the way, I can’t.”

"Oh, so you get everything you want?"

"We all get what we want," Angie said quietly. "I would get to live with my sister, the man of my dreams, and both of my best friends."

She took a breath, hesitating as if worried for the response. "And so would you."

Victoria turned her head to look back at her sister with her eyes glistening. They put their foreheads together, and I chose not to interrupt.

"And Dan would get to be with the two hottest girls he ever had. At the same time."

Victoria snorted. "He should be so lucky."

"You don't have to decide right now," I reminded her. "But give the idea a chance."

Victoria sat up. "The thing I still don't understand is why you lied to me."

"When?" I asked.

"You told me you had only slept together after I left."

"No, I only told you that we had hooked up. You may have assumed it was after you left, but I never told you that."

"Oh." She looked out the window. “What, so we all sleep in the same bed?”

“Yeah,” I said. “Basically.”

"Alright, stop trying to act so normal," Victoria told us when we got home. "It's making you both act really weird."

Angie and I looked at each other. We both knew she was right.

"So… how did this happen?" I asked. "You were both on birth control."

"It's only ninety-eight percent effective," Angie told me. "With a two percent chance of getting pregnant each time, that means you only have to have sex fifty times to make it a hundred percent."

"Your math skills are outstanding," I told her sarcastically.

"The real reason," Victoria confessed, "is that I may have forgotten to take the pill once or twice."

"You too, Angie?"

"Well, there was the first time that neither of us planned for," she reminded me. "Then there was the two weeks after when we waited for the birth control to kick in."

"But I pulled out," I protested.

"Oh, yeah, the pull out method," Victoria rolled her eyes. "Because that's a real thing."

"Exactly," Angie agreed. "Truth is, we're all idiots. We should have been using condoms."

"That would have been a lot of condoms," I said. "Alright, Victoria. What can we do to save your night?"

"Nothing. This day is beyond salvaging." She sighed. “I can’t believe this is happening.”

“It’s not that surprising. Mom always warned us that women in our family are extremely fertile.”

“Now you tell me.”

That night I found myself sandwiched between two gorgeous, pregnant and entirely overly curvy women.

We all fell asleep, but Victoria woke me back up. She backed her ass against me and slid herself around my dick, thrusting her body in the opposite motion of mine.

I felt kisses on my back as Angie reached between my legs and played with my balls. She kissed down my back, then did something to surprise me.

“Holy shit!” I yelled.

“Shhh,” Victoria moaned as she focused on fucking me. “Don’t wake up Angie.”

“Don’t worry about that. She’s licking my asshole at the moment,” I told her.

“What?”

“Fuck!” I yelled as I came inside my girlfriend.

We lay there for a moment before Victoria put her arm over me. “Mine,” she said.

Angie reached over and put her hand over her sister’s. “Ours,” she replied.

No one tried anything else, and the three of us lay there contentedly until we all fell asleep.