3.2 - David’s Remorse

David sat at the bar with a warm drink in his hand, his fingers rotating it aimlessly as he let out a deep sigh. For the last several weeks, he had thought about little else than that night with Sage. Porn didn’t do it for him anymore, strip clubs didn’t come close. He even tried burying himself in work and picking up golf again, but nothing worked. Sage was always there. She had been perfect, and he let the opportunity go.

_Didn’t even get to fuck her, _He thought passively. He wondered what could have happened if he had pushed it that night, if he had backed off, if he had said something different. He replayed that moment with Sage over and over, lost in his own lust at the idea of doing more with her. But before his thoughts could go much further he felt a tap on his shoulder.

“Usually don’t see you nursing a drink old timer,” A familiar voice said from behind him.

“Theo, pleasure as always,” David said, raising his beer bottle lazily, he looked at Theo and gave him a nod.

Theo was an incredibly handsome, dark-haired man in his mid-thirties. He was tall, fit, and charming. His man-bun, unshaven face, and relatively aloof demeanor made him and David an unlikely pair of friends.

“Retirement hasn’t been doing you any good I see?” Theo asked.

“I didn’t retire, I went private, and I’ll have you know my sales numbers have been better than ever,” David shot back, before taking a swig of his beer and motioning the bartender to bring to more their direction.

“Shit sorry I always forget, you were the best after all,” Theo replied.

“Still am the best, how’s that company treating you these days anyway?” David asked.

“Same as usual. Battening down the hatches, unfortunately, they capped commissions,” Theo replied as the bartender brought two beers over. Theo went for his wallet, only for David to stop his hand.

“I got it, kid, just put it on my tab,” David said calmly to the bartender, who gave him a nod.

“Thanks old man,” Theo said, grabbing one of the beers and swigging it quickly. He sat next to David, noting his friend’s hesitance to drink. “Seriously, what the hell is going on with you?”

“You don’t want to know kid,” David replied.

“I think I do. I’ve never seen you off your game, not like this. Even when you and your wife split, you always kept your head on straight. So this has got to be big,” Theo said. His concern was genuine, and it made David sigh.

“This one… this one is weird. I got caught up in something strange and now,” David paused, looking at Theo, “You sure you want to hear all this? It gets… a little fucked up.”

“Well now you have my full undivided attention,” Theo said, leaning forward. With that, David shared the whole story.

He talked about Sage, how he saw her naked, what they had done, and how things had ended after face fucking her in his living room while her husband watched. Telling the story felt like an eternity, and after he had finished, Theo sat back in his stool dumbstruck.

“Jesus Dave,” Theo said.

“Yeah…”

“You really did that with your neighbor’s wife?”

“Yeap…”

“And she was hot?”

“Hottest girl I’ve ever fucked around with Theo,” David confirmed.

“How old?”

“What the fuck does that matter?” David asked defensively.

“Ah, there it is. She’s ‘hot’ but she’s old right? Like what, fifty? Your age?”

“Oh fuck off, you can still be hot at fifty! But no she’s not fifty, she’s… well she’s young. In her twenties, I think around twenty-five… maybe younger,” David said.

“No fucking way!” Theo nearly shouted, causing a few bystanders to look over curiously.

“Keep it down will ya?” David shot back.

“Ok look, I’m not saying your a bad looking guy or anything but… I mean come on. You’re making it sound like she some kind of Only Fans model or something.”

“What the fuck is Only Fans?”

“You serious? Only Fans is… doesn’t fucking matter. Ok uh… porn star? You know that right?”

“Of course I know what a fucking porn star is,” David said shortly.

“Relax, I’m just saying you’re making it sound like she’s some kind of porn star living next door.”

“She is!” David replied, a little louder than he had meant. which again caused some bystanders to give them some annoyed glances. David and Theo nodded apologetically.

“Well, seeing is believing. You got pictures?” Theo asked.

“No, I don’t have any pictures… well…” David mumbled, fumbling out his phone and squinting as he opened his image gallery on his phone.

“Don’t tell me you’ve been spying on your neighbor?” Theo asked with a smile.

“Look I’m not saying it was an ok thing for me to do or anything. When I saw her changing through their bedroom I watched for a while, then when she was fully nude I… well I snapped a shot of it alright?” David said, handing the phone over to Theo, “The curtain blocks her face, but you can see her body real good.”

“Let’s see this girl, but I have a feeling my definition of what is hot is probably very different from…” Theo stopped speaking as he looked down at the picture, “...your definition…” He was stunned by Sage’s large breasts, perfectly curved waist, and thick thighs. She absolutely had a porn star-quality body. The pose was perfect as well, David had caught Sage running her hands through her long black hair as she leaned slightly to the side, accentuating her plump ass and thighs.

“She’s something right?” David said, now feeling triumphant in Theo’s response.

“Jesus Christ Dave… she gave you a blowjob?” Theo asked.

“Yes she did,” David said, a mix of pride and disappointment eeking out from him.

“Holy shit…” Theo said, forcefully peeling his eyes off David’s phone as he handed it back to him.

“Yeah…”

“Well, I can see why you are down in the dumps about everything. That’s a one in a lifetime bang…” Theo said, and while he would not admit it, he envied David. That woman was, without a doubt, the single hottest woman he had ever seen, and he had never come close to fucking someone of her caliber.

“It really was, and now I can’t get her out of my mind. I was so close Theo. If I had just… I don’t know… done things differently. I feel like I could’ve fucked her,” David said.

“Well I mean, don’t count yourself out yet,” Theo replied.

“Oh yeah? Because you know the situation so well right?” David asked. He spoke with some brashness, but there was hope hidden inside it.

“Well, you said she was into it right? And not only her, but her husband, right?” Theo said.

“Yeah?”

“So I mean, let’s be real. Maybe you pushed some boundaries, but you are exactly what they want, right next door. It’s not like they’re going to up and move anytime soon. I don’t know much about swinging or whatever this is, but I do know a thing or two about friends with benefits, and I also know a thing or two about selling,” Theo took a swig of his beer, his optimism was intoxicating.

“Go on,” David said.

“I’ll be honest, I’m fucking jealous of you right now. You’ve got them cornered. You are literally the only person who can give them what they want. Convenient, discreet, hot sex. Right in their backyard. Play to that, play to the scarcity. If you give them time and don’t act like an asshole, I guarantee they will warm up sooner or later,” Theo said. He spoke with confidence, and deep down, David knew he was right.

“I don’t know why I didn’t see it that way but… I think you’re on to something,” David replied. What Theo didn’t know was how right he was. David had seen how eager Sage had been, he felt it. She may have talked a big game, but deep down he knew she could be pushed to do what he wanted.

He just had to play nice.

“So, you’re feeling better then?” Theo asked.

“Better than ever,” David replied with a smile. The two clanked their beers, and with a smile, Theo spoke.

“Happy hunting old timer.”

Hope you guys have enjoyed the story so far! I've actually started up a Patreon if you'd like to read things early / give me some support. Happy reading!

patreon.com/mrjakobs