Defeating the thief, and turning them into your plaything

You had always been into bondage. Something about being in control, something about the way it looks and even the simple satisfaction of tying the knots. You didn't get to have a lot of practical experience sadly, your one girlfriend not sharing the same excitement as you and the club where you used to practice being dissolved. But those few moments when you had somebody tied up. In those moments you could finally stop worrying about the future. Your paranoia pushed aside to focus purely on the pleasure of the here and now. For both yourself, and your partner.

But that was just a fantasy... right?

Sure you have a baseball bat, and from what you could see the robber was unarmed. And you have the homefront advantage, especially in the dark. And you have a pair of handcuffs which would make their restraint trivially easy should they surrender, not to mention the pile of bondage gear you still own thats just begging to be used.