The next morning

The next morning you are awoken by screaming. A few moments later, Bethany bursts into your room, covered in cum and bursting with rage.

"Beverley tried to steal $30 from me because I let a bunch of drunk college guys tattoo a nirvana logo and the phrase "RAPE ME" on my ass cheek", she screamed.

She pulled up her skirt and shoved her ass in your face to prove her point. You notice her asshole is red and raw and her cunthole is crusty with cum. On her left ass cheek, there is indeed a drawn-on nirvana logo and the text "rape me"

"No, it's my $30", screamed Beverley while entering your room. "I earned it fair and square by letting a guy tattoo this on me." Between her tits is a hastily drawn picture of a cock with hairy balls with a few drops of cum (or piss) in the direction of her mouth. Upon closer inspection, you notice that Beverley's tattoo had a red outline around it. By contrast, Bethany's tattoo was perfectly sharp and healed.

"Bethany, who are you trying to fool? I think you should tell the truth now."

Bethany burst out in tears: "Alright I lied. The tattoo is fake. I tried to get back at Beverley because she won yesterday."

Beverley screamed: "You lying bitch! You should get punished for what you did!" By now Beverley was boiling with rage.

"Bethany I'm very disappointed with you. You are not even pierced yet and still, you look for more ways to be punished. I'll think of some long-term punishment for you but in the meantime I let Beverley think of a punishment for you."

Beverley has a short think but then has an idea: "We should fuck your ass with something, maybe a toy or an object or something. No lube allowed of course."

"I like that idea Beverley. Look for something fitting and shove it up Bethany's ass. Make sure to record it with her phone and post it on her social media as punishment. Make sure to not permanently harm her with the object you choose, and be aware maybe Bethany gets to punish you in the future, so keep that in mind.

After a hour you call the twins down because it's time for your appointment at the piercing parlor. Beverley is already ready and jumping down the stairs to get her victory nipple piercings. Bethany on the other hand is walking funny. Deep in her ass is a Hitachi magic wand and the cord is tied loosely around her thigh. You quickly grab your newly arrived package and take Gloria's car keys to drive to the piercing parlor.

At the piercing parlor, you get greeted by an old man covered in tattoos. He leads them to the back and sits them down on the chair.

Beverley and Bethany are so sparsely clothed that they don't even need to dress down much for the piercer to prepare Bethany's clit and Beverley's nipples for the piercings. You start small talk with the piercer. You discuss the outstanding punishment for Bethany. After a bit of back and forth, you and the piercer decide on the princess Albertina piercing. The piercer finished prepping the girls and you pull him aside. From your pocket, you pull a small box with multiple silver piercings.

"These are the piercings for the girls. They are made from nickel", you tell him.

"I strongly advise against nickel piercings. The chance for women is that one out of five shows allergic reactions to nickel", the piercer responds.

"I think you should ignore the risks and use the nickel piercings."

The piercer takes the nickel piercings and returns to the two waiting girls.

Half an hour. The girls are back in the car and on the way back home.

Beverley and Bethany are clearly in pain. Beverley's nipples are swollen around the silver metal rod through them. Bethany's pussy is on fire. Not only did her clit, the most sensitive spot on the female body get pierces, no there was also a ring on the entrance of her Peehole. Adding to her discomfort was the Hitachi magic wand still shoved up her asshole.

Back home, Beverley unraveled the cord of the magic wand off of Bethany's leg and led her to the nearest outlet. Then she plugged in the Hitachi and went to her room.

Within minutes Bethany was a moaning, quivering mess on the floor which was also not helped very much by Mutt Bitch who had walked over to her and lapped up her pussy juices.