Piper wins

A little less than an hour later, Piper Halliwell hurried into the house. She had dried cum in her bangs, cum soaking through her sweater, and she turned her head to show John the dried cum in her hair. She looked around and did not see her sisters. "Did I win?"

"Yes!" said John.

"Oh my god! YES!" she cried. "Will you fuck me now?!"

"Let's wait until your sisters get back, so you can rub it in."

"Awww, I need you to fuck me now though!"

As soon as Piper said that, a breathless Prue barged in. She had cum on her face and soaking through her white top. She saw her sister. "Oh, come on!" she said

Phoebe, came in next. Her face was coated in cum, and she could see she was last. She pouted.

"I'm going to fuck your sister, and you're going to watch and cheer me on. Do a good job, and I may fuck one of you."

"Yippeee!" said Piper. She was in such a hurry to get her jeans off, she tripped over them and fell to her hands and knees. She pulled her panties to her knees and stayed on the floor.

John stripped and got behind Piper. He started spanking her.

"Spank that ass!" cried Prue.

Phoebe chimed in. "Yeah, spank that naughty slut's ass!"

John kept spanking Piper as her sisters egged him on. After she was good and wet, he slid his cock into her pussy.

"OH god, YES!" cried Piper.

"Fuck her! Fuck that slut!" said Phoebe.

"Yeah, fuck that skank!" said Prue, who like her sister was jealous and angry.

As John fucked Piper, the Buffy girls came back with Buffy looking totally ridiculous. The gasped at what they saw, and John started to laugh when he saw Buffy, but he kept fucking Piper.