Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by Deepdarkwhisper Deepdarkwhisper

Did anyone hear you?

You are rudely awakened by Nicole

"Hey! Fucktard!" You are startled awake by a kick to your foot, which is dangling off the edge of the bed. You jolt up to see Nicole standing at the foot of your bed, arms crossed and looking firmly annoyed. It takes you a blurry-eyed moment to remember where you are and the fact you are still naked. You quickly grab one of your pillows and press it over your lap.

"Excuse me!" You retort in a matched whispered yell. "What are you doing in my room?!?"

"Well since you clearly didnt pass on my message to Jessica about being quiet, I have also been rudely awaked."

You flush a little bit at the thought of Nicole hearing Jessica moaning from the other side of the wall your bedrooms share.

"That's right, dickwad, I had to listen the whole time Jessica was moaning your name." Nicole paused and her look softened a little, more to a look of concern. "I heard her begging you to cum inside her. I really hope you didn't! You can be an irresponsible idiot sometimes, but I definitely thought you'd be smarter than that. You're getting cut in less than a week and you can't wait till then?!?"

You put up a hand to cut her off. "I didn't fuck Jessica, not that its any of your business... Well... I didnt fuck her pussy at least..." You look up somewhat sheepishly as you watch Nicole's reaction. Her face morphing from confused, to shocked, to almost impressed.

"Well... I didn't think that little slut had that in her. So what, she just climbs through the window and bends over for you?" Nicole questions you.

"She was wearing this sexy lingerie and, it had a hole in the back... wait, why do you even care what I do?" You fire back, a little embarrassed you just described what you and Jessica shared with your sister.

"I care a lot. If you fuck up and get Jessica pregnant, then I'll never be rid of her. She'll be a part of your life, and by association, mine, for at least 18 years." Nicole lets out a big sigh and then sits beside you on your bed. Turning to you, Nicole says, "Listen, you may be a prick little brother, but as your older sister, it's still my responsibility to look out for you." Nicole places one hand on top of the pillow over your crotch, petting a small circle on the fabric. "I would do anything to make sure you don't end up a teenage dad loser." Her eyes flick up at yours and you feel your heart flutter and your cock twitch.

After lingering another moment, Nicole stands up and starts towards your door. Looking back over her shoulder, Nicole says, "You know, I have to admit I'm a little jealous. It's been a while since I had a guy make me moan that loud. I swear I could hear Jessica's orgasm trembling through the wall." Nicoles eyes look down at your pillow and then back up at your eyes. "Be a good boy now and keep your cum out of her pussy." Nicole opens your bedroon door and steps out. Peeking though the crack as she closes it, she finishes, "And seriously stuff a sock in her mouth next time so I can get some sleep."

You couldn't help but notice how nice your sister's ass looked in her bootycut panties and black tank top. She had obviously not been wearing a bra and you can swear you saw the outlines of peircings through the fabric. Your cock grew hard and long as you lay there thinking about what Nicole had said. There was something hot about knowing your sister was listening in to the pleassure you were giving Jessica. But that was wrong.. wasn't it? You fall asleep with confusing thoughts running through your head.

The next morning

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)