Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 53 by Artican Artican

Do you bring Gemma in on the Onlyfans?

Hold off for now

You’re sure that Gemma would be game to join the party, but things are tenuous to begin with, so you’re not comfortable introducing a third element to the mix. Besides, you kind of like being with just the twins.

“Maybe after we get set up and things are going well,” you answer.

“Yeah… that makes sense,” Sabrina replies with a small smile. She turns back to the video. “I bet she’d take to this like a duck to water though,” Sabrina remarks. The two of you watch through the video even though you are done editing. After a prolonged silence, Sabrina announces, “I’d say that you were my boyfriend.”

“Hmm?” you respond.

She looks at you. “If my mom were to see the video. I’d tell her you were my boyfriend and it was a private video,” Sabrina says. She suddenly becomes demure as she asks, “You’d be OK with that, right?”

“Being your boyfriend?” you ask, perking up at the notion.

“Well, as an alibi…” Sabrina clarifies, looking shy about even bringing it up.

Of course, you’d be over the moon about the idea of Sabrina as your girlfriend. You’ve been fawning over her since the first day you saw her in class. She is a smart and intelligent woman that any heterosexual male would find attractive. You could tell her that and gush about how great she is, but that sounds and feels cliche and empty. Instead, you decide to tease her about it.

“Well, what if your mom were to ask to meet me?” you ask.

“I could say we broke up!” Sabrina reply, a little too quickly for your ego to take. You pat your heart and mouth the reaction, ‘Ow!’ Sabrina realizes her misstep and tries to coax your pride. “I mean, I wouldn’t want to inconvenience you, it’d just be cleaner to go with that story.”

“I get it.. I’m not ‘meet your parents’ material,” you chuckle.

“No no…” Sabrina says, doing her best to placate you. “You would be a total catch! I would totally take you to meet my parents!”

“Well, then we’d have to act like a proper couple for them to believe you,” you point out.

“We could do that,” Sabrina resolutely says, straightening up.

“Oh yeah? Your mom would probably expect us to be very intimate. Like we’d have to kiss…” you goad.

“We could do that too,” Sabrina affirms. You raise your eyebrow in challenge. Perturbed, Sabrina lets out a dramatic sigh and stands up from her chair. She approaches you. Your heart skips a beat as she sits on your lap, completely nude. “See? I can be intimate,” she says in a low voice, wrapping her arm around you. You can see she is blushing as she says this, but her body feels relaxed on yours. She looks you in the eyes and leans in slowly. You lean into her and meet in the middle for a soft kiss. Your heart flutters.

Even though you’ve done much more lewd acts together, this feels different. Her lips are warm and tender and her body is soft and comforting. Then, the moment is gone. Sabrina pulls her lips away, leaving you craning for more. She sits up, still on your lap and gazes into your eyes again. You could really get into the boyfriend/girlfriend act with her, maybe even turn it into something more.

Suddenly, Sabrina’s face is covered by white and she flies off your lap! You look down to see her pulling off a damp towel from her head and look up to see Katherine standing nude, having just thrown it at her sister.

“I’m done with the shower,” she says in passing with a snicker. She heads back to your room for her clothes.

Sabrina pulls herself up and wraps herself with the towel, scowling at her sister. She then returns her attention to you. “Well,” she says, “I guess I should shower too.” She pulls the towel up to her chest and heads for the bathroom, looking ashamed by what her sister just saw.

So, you had two hot, naked women in your apartment. It’s too bad Katherine interrupted your moment with Sabrina. You wonder how things would have gone if you had a little more time. You also want to talk to Katherine to figure out how you were going to get paid.

Do you follow up with Sabrina or Katherine?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)