Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by Maddoggon Maddoggon

What's next?

The Stalker

Please log in to view the image

I wake up in my bed hungover from the party the night before, everything feels like a blur. I am completely naked but there is a note on my chest. I read it "I really loved your party! I also think you are really cute and I really want to go out with you! Here's my number... XOXO ~Lucy" Wow that came out of nowhere, I've never been asked out before, and of course it had to happen after three beautiful women moved into my house. The strange thing is I genuinely don't know a Lucy, granted I didn't know most of the girls at the party, but it felt odd.

I sit in my bed looking at note, contemplating. On one hand I shouldn't waste an opportunity like this, but to be honest I have strong feelings for Megan, plus Hannah and Bethany are alright I guess. I keep looking when Hannah barges into my room. I had completely forgotten I was still naked. She smiles and says "I would say put that thing away, but I can barely see it." I just roll my eyes and look at the note again. She snatches it from my hand. "What do we have here?" She says as I try to grab it back. She then has a look of horror on her face. She rips the note in half and says "Ignore this, Lucy is insane." I then get visibly upset. "What is wrong with you?! I have never been asked out before, and you won't let me go out with her just because you're jealous?!" She then rolls her eyes "As if, I was just looking out for your safety." I then say "Look out for yourself, I can make my own decisions." She then says "Fine, but if that psycho tries to kill you, don't come crawling back to me." She then leaves the room and slams the door.

I text the number "Hey is this Lucy? I would love to go out with you!" I get a response back almost immediately "OMG YES! Let's go to the Cheesecake Factory tonight!" I agree, and it's kinda funny, she literally picked my favorite restaurant, what are the odds?

I meet her at the restaurant and I finally get to see what she looks like, she is very cute, petite, and has dyed pink hair, she is also wearing a cute pink dress. I say hi and she immediately hugs me. "You have no idea how long I've waited for this!" I blush and smile, I have never been treated this nice by a girl before. We get a table and sit down, the entire time she is staring in my eyes. I excuse myself to the bathroom and I start thinking to myself "Okay I know I have never had a girlfriend before, but this is weird right? Why is she so clingy already?" I snap myself out of it and head back to the table.

At the table we already have our drinks. I then ask her "So at what point at the party did you want to go out with me?" She responds "I've wanted to go out with you way before the party, silly." I am taken aback by this "When did we meet before?" She says "Oh we have never met, I've just been watching you for a while..." And that's when it hits me, she actually is crazy. She continues "You see... I know you are destined to be my husband, I saw it in the stars..." I then start getting nervous, I pull my collar and I take a sip of my drink, but suddenly, I start getting dizzy and everything gets blurry, this bitch **** my drink! I pass out, and the last this I see is a devious smile on her face.

...

I wake up in a dark room. I am completely tied up in bondage, and there is a ballgag in my mouth. I then see Lucy appear from the shadows, completely naked, she even has her pubes shaved into a heart, she would actually be pretty cute if I wasn't fearing for my life right now. "Hey cutie~" she says as she runs her finger down my chest. "I had no idea your dick was so tiny and adorable!" She grabs it between two fingers and starts tugging on it. "You know I like them small, the little ones are just so cute!" I try to say something but the ballgag keeps me silent. She then gets down and starts sucking on my cock. I hate to admit, but it feels amazing. She then slips a finger into my ass while she sucks. I shoot my load into her mouth and she swallows every drop.

She then pulls down my gag "How was that, Love?" I then say "Let me go! I didn't agree to this!" She then says "Oh Honey, I know you're a little confused, but you will learn to love me." I then say "I could never love a psycho like you!" I can see I struck a nerve in her. "Oh I see... Give me a sec..." She then leaves the room and comes back with her arms behind her back. "I'll give you one last chance to say you love me before you get punished..." I then say "Never!" She then says "I was afraid you would say that..." She then puts my gag back on and pulls a knife from behind her back. My eyes widen and I try to break free of my bondage to no avail. "Well if I can't have you and your adorable penis, no one can" she says as she grabs my dick and places the knife against it. I shake and try to break free but it's no use. "Baby it's okay, I'll still play with it, you just won't be attached anymore." I start to tear up and she then starts to feel bad. "Fine I'll let you use it one more time..."

Please log in to view the image

She then lies me on the ground and she sits on my face. She rubs her ass against my mouth and I can feel her juices leak onto me. She then gets up and positions herself above my dick. I shake my head in protest but she goes ahead and rides me, and thus I have lost my virginity to this lunatic. She bounces on my dick until I can't take it anymore and I cum inside of her. Great so now I'm going to be castrated and I may have to deal with a kid too. She gets off of me and she sticks the knife against my junk again. I clench my eyes shut when I hear the door get kicked in...

It's Hannah! "Let him go you insane bitch!" She shouts at Lucy. Lucy responds "Oh hell no, you aren't taking him from me, he's mine and only mine, find your own man!" She then charges at Hannah with the knife, but luckily, Hannah know some martial arts. She kicks the knife out of Lucy's hand. Hannah then tackles the naked girl to the ground and chokes her until she passes out. She walks up to me and unties me. I immediately hug her and tear up "Why did you save me after what I said?" She blushes a bit and says "I care about you, okay, and I knew something bad was going to happen if you saw that bitch." I the apologize and she says "It's fine, now let's get you dressed and get you home." I say "but I don't know where she put my clothes..." She says "That's okay, I stole hers."

I once again find myself crossdressing as we go home, but I'm not too upset this time, I'll gladly wear a cute pink dress over losing my manhood. And with me wearing Lucy's clothes home, she won't have anything to wear, and the thought of her having to streak home as punishment does put a smile on my face.

Please log in to view the image

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)