Go to the couch.

You hear Madame and Eli's muffled conversation just outside the door. You then wonder if Miller will notice your absence and come looking. But you're mostly concerned with Mitch and how he'd react if he caught you boning his older brother. You had a mild inkling that Mitch was interested in you, ever since day one. Would he be upset to see you with someone else, especially if that someone else was his brother? But seeing Benji kneeling on the couch and ass spread open, your cock makes the decision for you. You spit in your hand and start lubing Benji, so he can accommodate your sizeable girth. Though you can barely fit two fingers in, you start getting impatient and begin teasing the tip of your cock to his puckered hole.

"Fuck, you're big." Benji moans as you push in ever so slowly. You try to ease his tension by stroking his cock and kissing his neck. He eases up a bit and arches his back but you still can't fit the head in his tight virgin hole.

"And you're fucking tight." You whisper into his ear.

"Well, you're my first."

You give up for the time being as you can tell this wasn't going to work today. So you turn Benji around and take a seat next to him on the couch. You take his hand again and motion for him to continue stroking your cock. His hand feels nice and surprisingly soft. Much nicer than your rough working hands that's suffered years at the mines. Benji then leans over and you kiss him. You slide your tongue inside his mouth and he follows suit. It felt nice having a big man stroke your cock while kissing you deeply, his body nice and warm against yours. But as your cock throbs, **** for more attention, you break away to ask Benji, "Have you sucked cock before?"

He shakes his head. "No. I've always been the one getting sucked."

"You wanna try sucking mine?"

He hesitates, unsure about the idea. So before he can answer, you stroke his cheek and kiss him again. Hopefully getting him hornier will make him open to the idea. It's clear now through conversation and action that Benji isn't used to being submissive. You feared this would be the case when you first entertained the notion. But now, in the heat of the moment, this doesn't discourage you. Rather, the thought of making him your bottom becomes even more appealing. You start by teasing his hole again as this seems to be his weak spot. As your tongues wrestle inside each other's mouths, you can hear Benji grunt every time you find and massage his prostate. Finding this spot seems to be the key as he breaks off from your lips and diverts his entire focus on your cock. But knowing he still can't fit it in his back end, accepting it in his mouth becomes ever more appealing.

You gently guide his head towards your cock as you continue fingering his virgin hole. You let him smell it then slowly play with it up close. First, he licks the shaft and then lightly suckles on the head. Like a man discovering candy for the first time, his eye widens as he tastes your pre. "It's sweet," he mumbles, mouth now full with the first few inches of your cock. Seeing him look up eagerly into your eyes as he goes down makes you want to cum. You encourage him by stroking his head and telling him, "It's all for you." You find yourself no longer needing to finger him as he works your cock well on his own. A few minutes pass as the horny bartender discovers his newfound love for sucking dick. For a guy who's never sucked dick in his life, he was surprisingly good at it. Alternating between his mouth and hand, Benji handled your tool like a near expert. It was like he was born to suck cock, especially yours.

Benji sucking your dick.

"Damn, you love sucking my cock, don't you?"

"Yes," Benji muttered, mouth still busy on your shaft.

"Tell me how much you love it."

"I love sucking your cock, Gael. I love how it tastes in my mouth."

"Yeah? You're my dirty cum whore, aren't you?

"Yeah, I'm your whore. I want your cum."

"Shit, I'm getting close."

Benji eagerly opens his mouth while looking deep into your eyes. You rest the head of your cock on his tongue as you jerk off to finish. Your toes curl and chills run down your spine as a week's worth of load spurts down Benji's throat and onto his face. At first, he chokes on the copious amount of jizz but later licks up the rest, even the pre that drizzles down your shaft. As he finishes lapping up every drop you bring him up to kiss. You can taste the musk and sickly sweetness of your cum on his lips. It's near intoxicating as your cock twitches out the last drop. You then hear footsteps coming from the bar kitchen but Benji doesn't seem to notice. Now unsure if you've heard it yourself you let Benji get back on his knees and finish licking you off.

"Holy shit." You look up and spot Mitch half-drunk, leaning against the kitchen doorway. Coming to his senses, Benji falls back, still half-naked with cum dripping down the side of his face. He tries his best to cover his lower half but the thong won't stretch over his throbbing erection. Giving up the pretense to be semi-presentable in front of his younger brother, he stands up and calmly tells Mitch that he can explain. But Mitch shakes his head and goes back into the kitchen. You stare blankly into open space, wondering what just happened. You didn't have a brother so maybe it was different discovering your sibling in the act. But still, Mitch seemed more upset than disgusted.

**Writer's Note: Relationship with Benji has increased. Relationship with Mitch has decreased.

Choice 2: Do you go after Mitch and see what's wrong or do you stay with Benji and ask what happened?