Katie Decides to Keep Chelsea this way

Chelsea didn’t want to have to get out naked again so she figured if she apologized, she’d be able to get her bikini back. Even if it was a long shot.

“Look I’m sorry I did that to you, but this is different this time, this is very public.” “Oh you wouldn’t want to be seen naked by all of these girls now would you,” Katie said as she began raising her voice. “Keep it down!” Chelsea said. “When are you going to give me back my swimsuit?” “I don’t know, are you going to apologize to me?” “I am sorry Katie that I stole your clothes, and **** you to streak at school.”

“I don’t know, that wasn’t very convincing. Why don’t you say ‘My goddess Katie, who is so much better than me, please could you ever forgive me for my transgression?’” Chelsea gritted her teeth. “My goddess Katie, who is so much better than me, please could you ever forgive me for my transgression?” Katie rested her hand on her chin. “I don’t know, let’s see how the rest of the day goes, then we’ll talk.” “You’re going to keep me naked out here all day?” Katie nodded and smiled. “But why?” “Because I’m in control now bitch,” Katie said as she poked Chelsea in the stomach, startling and accidentally flashing her breasts out of the water. “Now you had better follow everything I do for the rest of the day if you ever want to see your bikini again. Especially if you don’t want all the girls to know.” Chelsea was nervous, scared and shocked that Katie would go this far, just to teach her a lesson, it was bad enough she was naked at a public beach, but to swim naked with skimpy-dressed girls (whom she was attracted to) was too much. Considering that she was still getting aroused from the whole situation from earlier.

“Okay fine, you have me in sort of a difficult situation,” Chelsea said. “Now could you please tell the girls that we should go swimming in the deep section?” “I suppose so,” Katie said as she swam back over to the girls, Chelsea watching her hypnotizing ass, who soon came back over to her. “Hey girls what are you doing over here,” Chelsea said trying not to blush. “Katie thinks that we should stick closely together for the rest of the day,” said Abbey, the blonde with the green bikini.

“Great,” Chelsea said, and for an hour and a half, later several hours, they swam around with Chelsea remaining naked and trying to hide that fact from the girls. Even though this whole situation was terrifying to her, she couldn’t help but find it massively arousing and if she was caught or discovered that she was horny that would just make things even more humiliating. As time passed everyone was still having fun, floating on their backs and jokingly pulling at each other’s skimpy bikini’s and such and it definitely didn’t help Chelsea’s arousal since they looked hot and sexy as they did it, but Chelsea knew this couldn’t last forever. Despite the fact she was enjoying herself she was starting to become terrified because she didn’t know if Katie was going to keep her word or not. That was when Kelly and Donna came over to Chelsea and talk with her. Katie even joined in as Chelsea was getting to know these better in order to tease her.

“So, Chelsea is in the same class as Cindy and Katie and you three are all planning to go to the same college?” Kelly asked as Chelsea tried to keep her boobs and maidenhood hidden. “Yup, that’s right, and you, Kelly, you said your in my same statistics class right?” Chelsea said trying to keep the conversation going for a little while. “Yeah I’m surprised I never noticed you before, with that cute little face and sexy body like that,” she teased Chelsea a little and she felt her face get redder from it. Chelsea forgot that Kelly was a full on lesbian and didn’t try to hide it. “So you gals ever done something naughty before?” Katie asked deciding to keep Chelsea on her toes. “What do you mean,” Donna asked curiously and was a little embarrassed and red in the cheeks. “Like, as in, like got to second or third base, you know, sex?” “No I meant like gotten naked in a public setting, or maybe, got someone else to get naked in public?” Katie said as she glanced at Chelsea and smiled. “Oh, God,” Kelly exclaimed, Donna was also embarrassed by this. “I’ve never done that myself, but there was this one time down in Florida that I saw this 29 year old black haired woman steak from the water to her towel, butt-ass naked! Apparently she lost her bikini in the water.” Kelly was shocked to her that and replied with, “I’ve never done that nor have I ever seen anyone attempt to do that. What about you, Chelsea?” Chelsea was startled, embarrassed and almost bumped into Donna but fixed herself and tried to brush it off as nothing. “No I would never and no I haven’t seen anyone do something that dumb.” “At least we agree that it’s dumb to do that,” Katie said smiling devilishly. “While I’ve never personally done that, I did get some people to go skinny dipping with them being the only one naked.” Chelsea swallowed hard and realized where this conversation was going.

“No way! Are you serious girl?!” Both Kelly and Donna exclaimed at the same time, curious to hear the details. Katie nodded and smiled as Chelsea became terrified. “There was this girl…and a boy,” Katie decided. “Wow two people?” Kelly said, Katie nodded to her question. “And I wanted a little payback on both of them for exposing my body to some boys. I forgot their names now, but I remember how I did it.” Katie said as she had explained this fake setting and scenario based on Chelsea’s own humiliating scenario, with a fake girl and boy and how Katie had gotten both of them to skinny dip at a public lake. The boy was the easiest, obviously, but the girl took some convincing and eventually she got her bikini off as well, Katie then held onto the boy’s swim trunks and the girls blue bikini and told them both to wait there and close their eyes, and they did. Katie then got out of the water and gathered some people who she told the whole situation to, and they all found them, some even put on goggles to see which humiliated both of them. Eventually they both had to walk out naked and couldn’t find their towels so they streaked home, which really made Chelsea terrified, and subconsciously covered before remembering there were people present, because she didn’t want to do that. “Why did they both walk out of the water naked?” Chelsea asked cautiously. “Didn’t you give the guy his trunks and the girl her b-bikini b-b-back?” “Well I was going to,” Katie started to say. “But I accidentally let go of the swim trunks and bikini and lost them both, so neither of them had a choice.” Katie looked at a scared and surprised Chelsea and then proceeded to wave bye for now to talk with Abbey. “Okay we’ll see you in a little,” Kelly said. “Yeah let’s go find Megan and Cindy,” Donna said her farewell and the two swam away.

Chelsea was petrified by that story, Katie hadn’t actually done something like that, and has she? She never seemed like the type to strip people and leave them naked as punishment, but then again, that whole story was based on Chelsea. She was scared that Katie had been lying and she was going to have to get out naked, which se really didn’t want to do. “Calm down,” Chelsea said to herself. “Katie’s not going to leave you like this, just learn your lesson and never do it again.” Chelsea convinced herself that was the case and after psyching herself up, swam back over to the group to at least try and relax.