Girlfriend's Payback

I checked my phone on the way home and noticed a call from an unknown number. I thought about it for a second and remembered Kelsey. Coach Williams had me give her my number in case she needed more cum. She actually used it? Interesting, maybe it was still part of the punishment.

I pulled into my driveway, walked up to my front door, and found it unlocked. "Oh, hey honey." I said, looking into the disappointed face of my sweet Chloe. "Uh...what's up?"

"Come in. Don't talk." She said sharply but softly. I raised an eyebrow and walked behind her. She lead me upstairs where my sister Sam was waiting at the door to her bedroom, holding a strap on. My eyes went wide.

"Uh, honey?"

"Don't. Talk." Chloe said firmly. My sister grinned wickedly at me as I walked down the hall toward my bedroom. Chloe turned around and yanked my pants down.

"Ow!" She came up and held my face with one hand.

"I said. Don't. Talk." She was getting mad. She then shoved me hard and I fell back onto a chair in the corner of my room. "You cheated on me, John." She took her clothes off and folded them slowly onto my desk. "You fucked Kelsey behind my back. That's cheating." She said, pulling the strap on up around her little naked hips.

"Babe, this is a bit..."

SLAP! I winced in pain, almost speaking but I didn't. I wasn't about to let this happen though, if this was how the world was gonna go, I wasn't interested.

"Kelsey!" She called. I looked around at my bedroom door and it opened gently. In walked a second redhead, a little tired looking but just as naked as the first. "He got to fuck you. I would say that's not very fair, wouldn't you?"

"Yeah. He totally cheated on you with me." Kelsey said seductively to my sister. "I think you need to settle the score."

Oh. Wait, this was nice. If this was going where I hoped it was, I was perfectly okay with this. Chloe grabbed Kelsey by little skinny little neck and gave her a searing hot kiss. My cock was very excited. Kelsey pulled back nervously.

"Wait. He didn't let you watch. Why are you letting him watch?" Her voice was filled with lust and excitement. She was just as into this as Chloe was....wait, what did she say?

"That's a good point, Kels." By the way, Chloe and Kelsey barely knew each other from what I could tell. I had never seen them hang out or interact except for right now. If she's called her Kels, they must have gotten very close in the last couple of hours. Chloe continued. "Sam, would you take him in your room? I want him to listen, but he can't watch."

Sam was standing at my door now with a big grin on her face. "Absolutely. Come here you fuckin cheater." Sam pulled me up by my hand and I tried to look back as Chloe threw Kelsey onto the bed. Kelsey giggled and then moaned as Chloe got on top of her. Sam pulled me into her room and threw me on her desk, just on the opposite wall from my room. She let her hand fall onto my cock and she started rubbing the head of it.

"Listen, don't talk." She pushed my neck against the wall. I could hear the moaning and the lust, the thrashing around and more moaning. "Kelsey was sooooo eager to do this, by the way. Cucking you with your girlfriend? Perfect retribution for a cheater." I let her stroke me and I turned to her.

"What do you get out of this, I thought..."

SLAP! FUUUUCK that hurt.

"Chloe doesn't want you to talk, this isn't about you. Just listen to how loud Kelsey is getting. How much she loves it. Or is that Chloe moaning? Maybe they switched. Mmmm, what if Kelsey is better than you?" She was whispering in my ear while she stroked my cock. The head games were actually turning me on. The fact that Kelsey and Sam also gave a shit about my relationship enough to punish me? Or did they just agree because a punishment needed to happen and this was what the universe came up with? This head game was not turning me on.

Whoever was being pleasured in there, it sounded so fucking hot. I made a mental note that I would have a three-way with Chloe and Kelsey at some point. For now though, I listened to the wild lesbian sex that was happening behind me. That, and my sister's firm grip on my cock. She rubbed my head like Del Moro had done and she even licked on my neck while I listened. Fuck, that felt good.

It didn't take long for me to reach the edge and Sam giggled as she held me there for a second. "Are you gonna cum? Are you gonna cum listening to your girlfriend fuck the mother of your child?" Oh fuck, that phrase did it for some reason. I moaned in Sam's embrace and I started cumming. I pumped into the air in my sister's room, and it thudded when it hit the carpet. She giggled and cooed as I came. "There's a good brother. Now I think you and Chloe are even, don't you?" She pounded on the wall twice and the moaning stopped in my room. "Let's go check on them."

By the time we got in, they were already getting dressed. Chloe smiled at me slyly and swayed her hips over to me. "Don't cheat on me again." I was totally gonna cheat on her again.

"Of course, baby. I'm sorry." I said half heartedly. I looked awkwardly at Kelsey who was getting dressed and then they all left. "Don't you wanna stay?" I asked Chloe.

"Nope. Not tonight. Good night, John." She waved me good bye and left my house. Sam walked back up to her room and I decided to go up to mine. I turned and locked the door like I normally did, and I turned around to see that Kelsey was sitting on my bed.

"Oh shit! I thought you left."

"I have a question for you. Why did you cum inside me?" Her voice wasn't angry or anything. I thought about it for a second.

"Honestly, I wasn't planning on it. I was just gonna walk in and cum on some pretty girl's face. When I saw you sitting there, with your wet hair and your hot little one piece, I changed my mind." She took that in.

"So...you wanted to get me pregnant then. You wanted to fill me with your seed when you saw me." She scooted closer to me.

"Uh. Well yeah, I guess that's what I'm saying." I wasn't sure where this was going. She bit her lip and took my hands.

"That's...really really hot." She said giggling. "The fact that you couldn't help yourself. UGH! John, that's so hot! Did you like... have a crush on me or something?" Her enthusiasm was infectious but I wasn't going to lie to her.

"I've always thought you were sexy but I've never thought about like...dating you." I said.

"Just using my pussy for your personal pleasure? Have you thought about breeding me?" She took my cock out and playfully licked at it.

"Yeah, definitely. You deserve to be pregnant, Kelsey. Your sexy body should only be for making babies, nothing else." She pushed her mouth down on my cock. "Won't...won't Chloe get mad again?"

"Why? Coach Williams entrusted you with feeding your pregnant woman your hot cum. I'm just following up on that since you didn't answer your phone." She said with faux innocence.

"Oh, that was you then. I should add you to my phone so I know to pick up immediately." I grabbed my phone while she sucked on my cock. She moaned around my cock head.

"It's so big, John. Is it bigger than it was this morning?" She held it out and looked at it from the sides. I looked down too, I had thought that before. Was my cock growing?

"Might be, I've gotten punished a lot today." I said. She suddenly looked so upset.

"Oh my god, John. I'm soooooo sorry about that. I did NOT tell anyone about what happened, Carla fucking did. That was so unfair what Officer Rose did you to, are you okay baby?" She pulled me into her warm, soft tits and held me firmly. I wasn't expecting this.

"Uh, yeah. I'm..." What am I doing? "Today was rough, baby." I played into it. "Everyone wants me to get in trouble, I'm surprised you don't. I impregnated you and ruined your life."

"No! No, baby! You didn't. I think this was...MEANT to happen. You couldn't help yourself and you HAD to fuck a baby into me, this was like...divine intervention or something. It was really really hot, feeling your hot seed pour into me. I could feel that I was pregnant instantly. I...overreacted and I was surprised. You did nothing wrong baby." She sat back on the bed. "I...I need to spend the night."

I smiled.