Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 16 by CandidBandit CandidBandit

Does he give in?

Whispers In The Dark

The bra came loose and fell away from her chest. The black clothing slid down her arms before she caught the straps in her hands. Ruby dropped the cups onto the chair on top of her dress and paused. She looked into the mirror above the sink and stared for a moment at her body.

Gray also stared at her body. The convenient pause gave him time to really soak in the image of the cute girl’s breasts. He gulped.

They may not have been as big as Yang’s tits but the handholds in front of him were still mouth-watering. And come to think of it, Gray didn’t really focus on Yang’s boobs when he was fucking her. He squeezed them a couple times but never really indulged.

Huh. Now he was getting the strong urge to suck on a pair of breasts. And Ruby’s cute nipples looked really tempting. They were small and were only a couple shades darker than the rest of her creamy skin. They were a pale sort of tan next to the white.

Gray wanted to latch onto them. He wanted to go to sleep sucking on them. Or Yang’s. The other girls would be good too. A boob job would be amazing as well. He wanted to leave his seed all over someone's chest and watch as the gooey mess dripped down her skin.

A movement from Ruby had him shake his head, throwing him out of his lustful daydream. The girl was picking up her pyjama pants from the sink counter. The same rose printed white pajama pants that she had worn last night.

Ruby, wearing only her black panties, began to lean down to start getting dressed.

Gray felt incredibly conflicted.

A part of him desperately wanted to rush up to Ruby and touch her mostly nude body before she got dressed. He wanted to feel her breasts and to suck on them. He wanted to kiss her as his hands felt up every inch of her. He wanted to bend her over the sink as he filled her. All those urges were wracking through his system right then and there, telling him to just go for it.

The more decent part of Gray still wanted to hold off. It wanted to preserve the last stalwart bastion of self-control. It wanted to treat at least one of the girls with respect--

--then he saw Ruby’s breasts hang down as she leant further to put one foot into her pants.

Shit.

That was the single thought of resignation Gray had as he could feel his control break at the sight of gravity pulling on her globes. He felt himself move forward, almost as if his legs were on auto-pilot. In the next moment he was in front of her reaching out a hand towards her breasts. Anticipation made it seem like time had slowed down as his hand drew nearer to her flesh but it was only a short moment before he felt soft contact.

So, so soft.

Warm too.

Gray’s heart fluttered like a love-struck fool as he held Ruby’s hanging breast. He squeezed her softly and groaned inwardly at how satisfying the feeling was. Yang’s was similar but Gray was a little distracted at the time, what with the need to put his dick in her.

Speaking of his dick, he also wanted to put it in Ruby but really put a hold on that feeling. If he really needed to cum again, he would rush out of the bathroom and do something with Yang or one of the other girls.

He was pulled from his thoughts again when Ruby stood up straight, pulling her pants up with her. There was a slight jiggle to her other breast when she needed to shift her hips a little to get her pants sitting just right. Gray’s mouth watered at the sight of that small motion. Small tremors made her breast stand out to him, his eyes zeroing in on the boob flesh. His other hand reached out and cupped the lonely tit.

More warm softness filled his hands.

Gray sighed in contentment as his hands kneaded at Ruby’s chest. His mind mellowed out as the softness of her breasts took over his thoughts. He was so caught up in the soft sensations that when she turned back to the sink to pick up her pajama top, he was caught off guard by the loss of one boob from his hand. That small sense of loss jumpstarted his brain and his libido gave him a sense of urgency to get back what was lost.

Gray moved around till he was behind Ruby and pulled her in, preventing her from picking up her black tank top. He was now pressed up to her body, crotch against her butt and his hands palming her breasts fully once again.

“Don’t put your top on just yet.” He told her.

Ruby’s arms, which were lifted towards the sink counter, lowered once more.

“Okay.” She replied. Now she just stood there in his grasp and looked at the mirror.

Then Gray went to town and indulged himself with Ruby’s tits. He also pressed his boner against her butt and humped her a little. He looked at her through the mirror and once again realized how short she was. Not so short that he couldn’t lean down and kiss her shoulder, only that it was a bit of a stretch.

And stretch he did. Gray kissed her shoulder and licked her skin, all the way up her neck before pressing his nose just behind her ear and breathing in. His mind exploded with lust at her natural smell. She actually smelled like roses. It was a subtle scent, unlike perfume that could be quite abrasive to Gray’s nose. He kept breathing in, snuffling at her like a pervert, before going back to her neck and sucking on the skin. He heard Ruby gasp quietly at the sensation but when he looked in the mirror at her face, she had barely any expression. The only thing that gave away that she was feeling good was the small blush that was obvious on her pale face.

Feeling unreasonably aroused at being able to take advantage of this girl, of any girl, Gray hugged Ruby tight. Waves of warmth flooded his groin once again when in contact with her butt. His hands kneaded her chest to his heart's content. Her smell took over his senses and he completely forgot about his earlier promise of restraint when one of his hands travelled down Ruby’s stomach.

Gray felt her smooth skin beneath his fingertips until they met with the waistband of her pajamas. Without much thought Gray slipped his hand past the waistband of not just her pajamas but also her underwear. He felt his fingers brush past a small bush before his fingers slid over a smooth valley that was slightly wet. His middle finger almost immediately sunk into her flesh.

Ruby let out a sharp gasp at the sudden sensation in her nethers. Gray watched her face bloom into a bright red in the mirror. Her eyes fluttered a little and her body twitched against him. The image of an aroused topless Ruby captivated Gray. Just the sight alone pleased him in a way he couldn’t describe. His heart beat wildly and tremulously as he gazed upon this cute girl in his arms.

His fingers pulled back and forth inside her depths and his self-control was pulled further away from him as he witnessed her body jerk in response. Her breath quickened and her eyes glazed over, staring at nothing in particular. Gray’s eyes focused in on her open lips and the sounds of her quiet panting.

Dear gods he wanted to kiss her.

Gray took his hand out from her pants and spun Ruby around to face him. There was a small moment of whiplash as her arm softly collided with Gray and an expression of slight dizziness overcame Ruby’s features. It didn’t last long as Gray leaned in and pressed his lips to hers.

The moment their lips touched Gray was overcome with the soft sensation. Her lips felt really nice against his own. He stayed like that for a moment and basked in the warm feeling of Ruby’s lips.

This was a kiss he appreciated having. Weiss’ lips were nice but considering her attitude she wouldn’t have been his first choice for a first kiss.

Well... his first kiss since that time in the forest with that childhood friend. He still wasn’t sure if that counted or not. It was so long ago.

Ruby on the other hand was adorable and surprisingly hot under her clothes. A sexy dork like her would have been nice to have a first kiss with. A shame that ship had already sailed.

Still, just because he had his pseudo-first kiss with an ice bitch didn’t mean he couldn’t enjoy his second. Third?

Gray finally leaned back to look at Ruby’s face. She was slightly flushed but that passive expressionless face looked back as if nothing had happened, coupled with the fact that she didn’t move her lips in the exchange at all. Which Gray kind of expected.

He was tempted to tell her to kiss him back but a thought stopped him. He would prefer it if she kissed him of her own volition. Without the use of his Semblance.

Gray wanted to see if he could get Ruby to like him, to flirt with him and to kiss him because SHE wanted to. Of course, that didn’t mean that he wouldn’t do things to her and the others while using his Semblance or his Semblance-induced-commands. He just felt that he could pursue a relationship separately to sexual gratification.

Gray felt that he could manipulate the situation enough using his Semblance to have a bunch of sex friends as well as potentially build romantic relationships simultaneously. It would just take a lot of planning and carefully worded commands.

Of course, there was the moral implications of doing such a thing, but he was too horny right then to think beyond the contact of his boner against Ruby’s navel. His hands squeezed her butt cheeks as he looked at her face up close.

She wore no make-up. Her face was youthful and smooth. She had no scars or blemishes. Her skin was a pale white and her eyes...

Her eyes were a color that seemed grey at first, but the deeper he looked the more he thought of the reflective sheen of silver. A precious metal...

Gray stared into Ruby’s eyes and only snapped himself out of it after a while. The horniness in his lower half was getting impatient and he had only been standing there admiring Ruby’s eyes. He broke eye contact and felt a disconcerting yet subtle pull on his eyes to look back. He ignored the feeling and distracted himself by pressing his face close to Ruby’s before licking her cheek. In much the same way he had done to Weiss last night.

The strange moment had passed as he felt his arousal spike once more.

He busied himself with perving out over Ruby’s face. He licked her like a dog. His tongue glided over her skin. He sucked on her lips and shoved his tongue into her mouth. The taste of her mouth was something he couldn’t describe. Gray caught her tongue and sucked it out of her mouth. He sucked on the small pink appendage like he would suck on a nipple.

The thought of sucking on an actual nipple made him stop after a few seconds before licking his way down her jaw. Onto her neck. Then to her collar bone. Ruby let out small gasps here and there at the physical attention. Then Gray’s neck began to ache before he even went past the collar bone.

“Ruby, sit up on the counter, would you?” He found himself asking, standing up straight and rubbing his neck.

“Oh, sure.” Ruby replied, nodding and turning away from him. She stepped up to the sink, turned slightly with one hand on the edge, and hopped up until her ass sat on the marble of the bathroom counter. Her breasts shook wonderfully from the motion, making Gray’s mouth water again.

Gray hurried up to her and eagerly spread her legs so he could get close. With a groan he pressed his face into her chest and felt the incredible softness of her breasts. He rubbed his face all over and motorboated to his heart's content. He kissed and licked whatever was in front of him until he found one of Ruby’s nipples. Gray latched on and sucked like a baby.

All throughout his attentions Ruby just sat there on the bathroom counter, occasionally twitching from the sensations. Small gasps and moans escaped her lips serving to urge Gray on. He then switched to the other nipple while pinching the one he had just left. Ruby twitched harder from that.

Gray’s other hand travelled up and down her back and sometimes came down to fondle her butt. His fingers would poke under her pajamas to grasp at her butt flesh. Sometimes he would grasp at her thighs too since they looked so sexy.

Ruby’s legs were almost wrapped around Gray’s hips and he felt his groin brush up against her warm core. He pressed himself harder up against her to chase that feeling. Unfortunately, that meant having to release her nipple from his thirsty mouth. He was a little too tall to comfortably suck on her tits AND grind his junk into her. So, he opted to hug her tight while he pressed his boner to the point where her legs met.

“Hold me tight, Ruby.” He whispered to her, mouth to ear. Her scent filled his nose once again and he breathed her in.

Ruby’s arms wrapped around Gray’s neck and her legs locked in place at the ankles behind his butt. He felt her squeeze him for all that she was worth and he squeezed back. There was no space between them now. Gray began to hump this cute short girl, reveling in the warmth her crotch provided. His tired dick no longer remembered being tired, now that it had more pussy to play with. The previous ache he had been feeling was easily set aside in favor of more sexual gratification.

He humped Ruby again and again while listening to her small sighs of pleasure. Her pleasured voice so close to his ear gave him a thrill that made him hump faster. After a small moment he found that he missed having her lips to taste, so he turned his face to her and captured her lips fiercely. He plunged his tongue into her mouth, even if she didn’t respond in kind. He just went to town and cleaned her tonsils while grinding his cock.

One of Gray’s hands reached up to hold her head in place, his fingers sliding through her short hair. The other hand grabbed one of her breasts and used it as a stress ball. This goes on for a long moment with his kisses becoming more and more uncoordinated and sloppy.

Until that familiar feeling presented itself.

Gray was suddenly very close to popping another load. He opened his eyes wide in sudden realization. He really didn’t want to let it out in his own boxers, and he had decided that he was going to go to sleep with Ruby tonight so getting her dirty was out of the question. No one wants to try and sleep with the smell of their own semen close by.

Should he make her swallow?

A part of Gray, the small voice that wanted to keep Ruby mostly innocent, was against it. Plus, he might want to kiss her in the middle of the night while they cuddled. And Gray really didn’t want to taste himself in that way either.

As he thought it over, he had slowed his humping down to try and stave off the impending orgasm and allow himself some time to think. The timing was still pretty tight though, so his thoughts were hurried as he tried to figure out what to do.

No, the feeling was too close, so Gray decided to let go of Ruby. Which reminded him of how tight she was holding him.

“Ruby, let go of me.” He told her.

Her arms and legs released him and Gray took a step back. He noticed her blushing, clouded expression and wanted nothing more than to see her enjoying his cum. However, his conscience reared its responsible head and refused to budge.

“You can get back to getting ready for bed, Ruby.” He told her, taking another step back.

Without looking back, he turned and left the bathroom.

Once he was back in the dorm room proper Gray took a deep breath. His nerves were barely calmed though, now that he moved from one room with a cute girl to a room with three cute girls. He looked around and saw that Yang was now in her sleepwear and sitting on her bed with the covers pulled back. She was doing something with her scroll while talking to Blake across the room.

“How does seven sound? That enough time for some quick showers and breakfast?” Yang asked. She must have been setting up an alarm, Gray realized.

“A bit early but yeah, sounds good.” Blake told her, her eyes never leaving her book.

“Right? After the day we’ve had I’d much rather sleep in.” Yang sighed.

“Just think of it as practice for the kind of lifestyle that Huntsmen lead.” Weiss chimed in from the other side of the room. She had turned over in bed to face the other two. “Early starts are probably the norm.”

“Probably...” Yang didn’t sound too happy to admit that.

As much as Gray would like to agree with Yang, seven was roughly the time he had to get up for his previous school. And he lived outside the city, so getting to school was usually a bit of a rush. Now that he lived in a dorm that was situated right next to the school, he probably didn’t have to worry about being late. Not to mention his Semblance. Heck, he could probably stay in bed all day and make it so that no one was bothered by it. Except he wouldn’t do that. He had too much energy to not go out and do something with his life. Killing monsters and saving lives was worth the few years of boring education.

Anyway, Gray zoned out of the conversation and thought about what to do with his dick. He was idly stroking it this entire time to keep it close to popping but was unsure where to unload. He had already done Yang. Blake got a partial treatment. And Weiss was untouched for today.

Thinking of Weiss reminded him of what he did to her yesterday. He was also reminded of her overall attitude. The bitchy and stuck-up rich girl. Maybe he should mess with her again?

Yep. He was definitely going to mess with her again. For no other reasons than because he was still annoyed with her and that his horniness demanded nothing less than to cream on her. So, he took steps towards her bed and removed his clothes once again. He threw them onto the end of her bed before pulling back her covers, revealing the white-haired beauty’s night gown and legs. She was still turned on her side facing the other girls but their conversation had died down now. Her eyes had now closed, not quite asleep just yet, as she occasionally flitted them open drowsily.

Gray gently nudged her onto her back and climbed on top of her, straddling her hips. He pressed his groin hard against her pelvis and held back a groan. Briefly, he wondered about how he wanted to do this. Did he just want to hump her until he shot his load over her body? Did he want to give her a mouthful? Or give her a facial again?

Feeling the fabric of her white night gown on his dick made him inspect where he was rubbing. Looking down, an idea popped into his mind that was just as good as any. Plus, he didn’t want to think about it anymore.

Gray leaned back and lifted Weiss’ night gown up and away from her stomach. He then scooted forward and pressed his meat against the skin of her navel, he could feel his balls resting on her panties. Next, he covered up his shaft by letting the night gown go and smoothing it over his dick. He gave an experimental hump, found that it felt good but also lacking. Another quick thought led him to grabbing one of Weiss’ hands and placing her palm over the dick shaped bump of her gown.

“Press your hand down firmly here.” Gray told her.

Weiss briefly opened her tired eyes and looked up at him before nodding. Her eyes closed once more as Gray could feel her hand pressing down on him. Now he began humping as he leaned forward, pressing his hands on the bed to either side of Weiss. The pressure on his cock was just right, and the feeling of her skin and the fabric of her gown made for a tag team of sensations. The warmth of her body made him feel like he could melt, while the soft fabric on his sensitive head made him gasp.

His previous orgasms had left him more sensitive than usual and he was pretty close anyway, so it wasn’t a surprise that he didn’t last long. He let out a long groan as his vision blurred and dimmed around the edges. His dick throbbed and good feelings filtered through his mind as he let out a shaky sigh of contentment. He could feel the fabric surrounding his tip get wet and sticky as his load spread out. The cum stain darkened the white fabric, leaving a blotchy and damp mess for Gray to feel proud over.

Feeling a little tired, Gray leaned down and kissed Weiss. Her lips were unresponsive but that was fine. He just plunged his tongue in regardless. For a moment he went a little wild and even licked her face before he lifted his face away and held her mouth open with one hand. The next thing that Gray would do, even he knew was a little gross but he found that he didn’t mind that much. Gathering some saliva in his mouth, he then fed it to the unsuspecting girl. Her mouth muscles responded with instinctual panic and she made a gluck sound before her mind then realized that there was liquid in her mouth. The next instinctual response was to then swallow the liquid.

Gray allowed himself to feel a small sense of satisfaction from that before getting up. Admiring his handy work of her night gown, Gray humped one last time to feel one small burst of very sensitive pleasure. However, his cock was truly done for the night.

“You can let go now.” He told the drowsy girl.

“Mm...” Was all he got in response.

Her hand softened its grip and moved away slightly, coming to rest directly over the cum stain that covered a good portion of her stomach. That made him smirk.

Gray then extricated himself from her gown, tugged it back into place for her and got off and back on his feet.

Before he got dressed again, he realized that his dick was now dirty once again. He now had to get it clean again and he immediately looked to Blake, who was still reading her book. Just then the bathroom door opened and Ruby walked out wearing her pajamas. His eyes followed her as she walked over to the dresser she shared with Yang and left her combat clothes on top. She then walked over to her bed; his eyes glued to her slightly swaying butt.

Shaking his head Gray turned back to Blake and approached her again.

“Blake, could you clean my dick again?” This time he asked this while his Semblance was active, so her response was... well, as emotionless as she usually was.

She looked up passively at his hanging dick and nodded. She got up and leaned on one arm before pushing her face forward to capture his dick in her mouth. Her tongue mechanically rolled him around in her mouth as she sucked briefly. Her eyes did shut closed in what Gray thought was enjoyment, but could have been anything really.

She sucked and licked a few more times and stopped when she could no longer taste his sperm.

Gray sighed when she removed herself from him and fell back into bed.

Without thanking her Gray just moved back over to the foot of Weiss’ bed to take his clothes and get dressed again. Once dressed he turned off his Semblance and approached Ruby, who was pulling back the covers over her own bed.

“Hey Ruby, you mind if I cuddle with you tonight?” Gray asked her casually, even if he actually did feel a wave of nervousness suddenly **** him for asking that.

Ruby jolted a little at the question and turned her head to look at him shyly.

“Are... I... Well, I guess that’s fine, but...” Ruby tried to respond. “Are you sure you don’t want to sleep together with Yang?”

Well, he would at some point, sure. But he just fucked her and Ruby was too cute to not cuddle with. But Gray felt like he understood what she hadn’t said. Perhaps boys only ever paid attention to Yang, the older sister, for, well, obvious reasons. Perhaps Ruby just wasn’t used to a boy wanting to spend time with her.

“I will. Tomorrow night, maybe.” Gray answered simply. “But tonight, I want to sleep with you.”

Her eyes went wide and a blush bloomed all across her face and Gray heard a loud snort coming from Yang.

Only then did Gray realize what he just said. But instead of being embarrassed and backtracking, he just stood there and smiled at the bashful girl gently.

“You don’t want to cuddle?” He asked innocently.

“I--I, uh, a, ah...” Noises came out of her mouth. She looked away, her blush still burning her face. “...I do...”

“Great. I’ll get the light then.” He said, moving over to the light switch by the door. Ruby scrambled into bed and hid under her covers. “Everyone else ready for lights out?” He asked to everyone in the room.

“Yeah, I’m good.” Yang affirmed.

Blake put a bookmark in her book and closed it. She placed the book on a bedside table and nodded to Gray.

“Okay. Goodnight, everyone.”

“’night.” “Goodnight.” Yang and Blake said respectively.

“Goodnight.” Ruby said, poking her head out from the covers.

With that Gray turned the light out and walked back over to Ruby’s bed. He peeled back the covers enough so he had room to get in and climbed in next to Ruby. She was still hiding from him by lying a bit too far from him with the covers up past her nose. That wasn’t a great start, Gray thought.

“Ruby,” Gray whispered. Ruby’s eyes flickered to him nervously. “Don’t you want to get closer?”

Ruby looked away bashfully and Gray thought that she was going to stubbornly stay put, but after a long moment she began scooting closer. She still lay on her back with about an inch or two between them.

There was silence as Gray contemplated on what he could say. It came to him after a moment.

“You know,” He began, still whispering. Her eyes looked back to him again. “I’m a little nervous about tomorrow.” Ruby’s eyes shed a little of her nervousness at their proximity and became attentive. “The first day of school and everything. Starting new things with new people is kinda... you know?” He said with a shrug.

“Yeah,” She nodded, feeling empathetic about what he said. “I’ve never been good with new people...”

Gray nodded in understanding. He had a little bit of shyness in him too, though he had learned to ignore it quite a bit through the years.

“It’s pretty daunting, huh?”

Ruby gave a small nod, her eyes telling the story of just how daunting it could be for her. Her expression just made him want to hold her close and squeeze her.

“But you know...” He started to say. “I’m glad I was able to make new friends very quickly with you and Jeanne.”

“Me too,” Ruby nodded vigorously while turning her head fully to him. “I- … I really needed it. Especially after Yang ditched me.”

Her expression changed to one of annoyance and Gray chuckled.

“Yeah, and now we’re on a team together with her. Go figure.”

Ruby giggled. Her laughter trailed off though.

“Yeah, but there's also Weiss...” She said, sounding sad and frustrated.

“Yeah, Weiss is definitely a bit of a handful.” He agreed. “But I think that she’ll come around. Blake too.”

“You think?” Ruby asked. Her voice quiet.

“Yep. And even if she doesn’t, I promise I’ll have your back.” Gray told her with resolve in his eyes.

Ruby was stunned, unable to think of anything to say for a moment. Then her eyes filled with gratitude and she turned to him fully now. This brought them a little closer. Close enough that Gray found himself lost in her eyes, even in the darkened room there was something luminous about them.

“Do you mean it?” She eventually asked softly.

Gray found that words failed him. Her eyes had him mesmerized. All he could do was nod resolutely.

In response she smiled freely, an innocent and childlike glee taking over her face. It was infectious and Gray couldn’t help but smile back, perhaps in exactly the same way too.

The warm moment stretched for a moment longer before Gray felt the need to take it a step further.

“I don’t know about you, but...” He began to say in a cheeky tone. Ruby looked curious now. “I don’t think I could get to sleep without that cuddle I was promised.”

Gray left it at that and waited.

Ruby looked surprised for a moment before her face bloomed into another blush. She looked away, but not for long as she began to smile a little. She looked back to Gray, this time with a wry grin and a lot more courage than she had before. She then wiggled closer until they were finally touching. She couldn’t really hold eye contact as she was still very bashful but she managed to lay her head close to the crook of his neck.

Gray met her the rest of the way and wrapped his arm around her and held her close. Her scent once again took over his world and he breathed her in quietly.

“Goodnight, Ruby.” He whispered to her.

“Goodnight, Gray.” She said just as quietly.

With that the night finally came to a close. The two of them relaxed in each other's arms and Gray did in fact pop another boner throughout the night. Which only embarrassed Ruby a little bit, which probably had something to do with the Semblance commands Gray had dished out earlier.

Still, Gray had managed to wiggle his way into Ruby’s heart. Ladies and gentlemen, that is how you do it.

…if you had magic powers on your side, Gray guessed.

The next morning...

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)