Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 16 by SassySquatch SassySquatch

How do you respond?

Plenty of lotion

As you watch her eagerly wiggle her ass while waiting for a response, you struggle to find the words. “I….I’m….um…..I mean…..it’s probably enough? But it seem to all be concentrated as if in one spot” you mumble while trying to politely indicate to the large amount of lotion around her asshole.

“Oh yeah? Could you help with that? Just reeeeeally rub it all over. But be careful, I’m still sore from earlier” Amy says while chuckling to herself.

You’re stunned for a moment but will not turn down a free opportunity to touch your girlfriends ass. Reaching town you scoop your finger between her asscheeks and collect some of the lotion, a noticeable shiver running up Amy’s back as you do so.

As you rub the lotion between your hands you can’t help but notice how sticky it is. You’ve never seen a lotion quite like it before, yet at the same time it looks awfully familiar. You take the upmost care as the tip of your fingers slowly begin to reach the bruised skin on Amy’s ass, however even with caution she still felt pain.

“Tsk ahh. Be careful!” She yelled back in a voice that was so strange, you couldn’t make out if she was angry or aroused. As you slowly put more and more pressure onto her cheeks and rub the lotion in more she begins to get used to it. Despite the erotic tension of the situation starting to dim out, you could feel your cock finally starting to become erect between your legs. However before you even have a chance to think of something mischievous to do with it, the bathroom door suddenly swings open.

You and Amy both jump back like two school children who have just been caught doing something they weren’t meant to. It’s a miracle neither of you fell over as you both snap back to reality in the slippery wet shower.

Now standing in the doorway is Jamal, a strangely smug look on his face as he stares back at you both. However what really shocked you was the fact that he was completely naked, his rippling body on full display to you both. Out of instinct you couldn’t help but look down, only to be greeted by the sight of a thick black dick so large and veiny that it was hard to believe it was real even with it right in front of you. It looked like Jamal’s day had been very eventful with his filming parter as you can still see that his dick is slimy and wet, still ozzing some type of liquid from the tip.

You’re snapped back to reality however when he speaks “oh sorry you two, didn’t think anyone was in here because the shower was off. Hope I’m not disturbing anything” Jamal says with an arrogant laugh.

“Oh not at all Jamal, in fact we were almost done. Isn’t that right mark?” Amy asks as she looks up at you. “Oh um….yeah sure” you mumble back, not sure how to respond in what was clearly an awkward situation. As the two of you step out of the shower you can’t help but be amazed at how well Amy handled the situation. In the past if something like this happened she would have been screaming at both of you to get out.

You grab a towel off the wall as Jamal passes by you and Amy to jump into she shower. You thought you heard him whisper something as he passed but when you turned around he had already gotten in the shower and pulled the curtain.

Not wanting to spend anymore time in the awkward environment you reach out to give Amy her towel when she stops you. “Shit sorry baby, I just remembered I’ve got all this lotion still on my butt, I better jump back in and wash it off” she says almost as if apologising.

“What!? But Jamal just got in” you try to whisper but she happily talks over you. “Oh he wont mind, right Jamal?” She says loudly, raising an eyebrow as she turns to the closed curtain. From the other side of it he yells back over the running water “not at all, plenty of room for two on here, even with your giant ass” which causes Amy to giggle in a way you’d never heard before.

“But honey you’re NAKED!” You say trying to point out what was already obvious but she didn’t seem to care. “Well it’s not like he didn’t already see it when he walked in. Honestly Mark just go get dressed and I’ll be out in like 60 seconds, just a quick rinse off” she reassures you as she reaches for the shower curtain and pulls it back just enough for her to get in. As she steps into the shower you could have sworn you saw her looking down before licking her lips but it must have been your imagination, after all you did have a rock hard erection.

Do you leave them to shower?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)