Playful petting between the two

I attempted to eat the baked ziti that my mom had prepared as best as I could while my secret girlfriend stuck her finger in and out of my exposed pussy thanks to a purposeful missing seem in the crotch of my pants. Sam was having such a natural conversation with both of my parents as I sat there quietly holding back my moans as her finger was going in and out of my juicy pussy lips. I let out a controlled moan as Sam looked at me and asked with a coy smirk, “You alright, Jaime? Did you bite your cheek?”

I quickly said, “Not my cheek but close. I bit my tongue. Don’t mind me…” My mom and dad continue to converse with Sam. Sam talked about things about her life that I hadn’t known about like that she was into rock climbing and loved going on hikes and even told my parents about a place they had never heard about. (She would explain later that she often would go to that park to hike naked and she planned to have me join her).

She loved the great outdoors and everything about it. She popped her finger out of my pussy and brought her napkin up to her mouth as she sneakily showed me that she was sucking it clean of my juices. My dad asked us, “Alright you two, So what your plans were for the evening?” As I was about to answer, I felt my left hand being guided to Sam’s pussy lips. I felt my middle finger being inserted as Sam kept a poker face while eating the baked ziti.

I quickly answered and said, “No plans really. Did you have something in mind, dad?”

“Best baked ziti I have ever had, Mrs. Summers.” She was able to say without releasing any moans.

I continued to speak to my dad, “Definitely staying in since we were at the mall for most of the day.

My dad chuckled as he said, “I heard you were late and you’re never supposed to be late with mom or you will get it.” My mom shot him daggers as he cleared his throat and went back to eating. I chuckled as I heard a moan slip from Sam just loud enough for me to hear. She quickly cleared her throat and drank some water as I decided to increase the speed of my fingering and using a free finger on her clit.

Sam took a deep breath and I thought she was gonna let out a moan but she turned it into a question of asking my mom,

“By the way, where did you get your nails done?

My mom said, “Why thank you Sam! You are the first person to notice and it’s actually not too far from the mall. I pulled my finger out and did the same thing with my napkin, allowing only her to see me sucking my finger clean of her pussy juices. We traded fingering throughout dinner until we got to a point where we were struggling from just fucking at the table in front of my parents. My mom cleared the empty plates and my dad asked, “Well, it is getting kinda late. Sam, would you like to stay the night?

Sam said, “Oh I couldn’t impose, Mr. Summers. This was so last minute and I…”

My mom stopped her right there and said, “Sam, you can stay as long as you wanted. You are wonderful young woman and we are happy for you to come as often as you please.

Sam smiled and said, “Alright you’ve convinced me. I would love to spend the night.

I offered, “Sam can even stay in my room since my bed was big enough for two.”

My mom was proud of me as she said, “I’m so surprised you are having your first girls night sleepover.”

My dad joined in, “18 years of having no sleeping overs has to be a record.”

Sam chuckled and said, “Well I’m extremely honored being Jaime’s first.” She gave me a wink as I clearly knew what she was implying, not just my sleepover buddy.