Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 2
by
ManRayMansker
Which Prompt will you choose to address first?
Penis
.“Never have I ever seen another penis.”A few people laughed and took drinks right away. Jake shrugged and sipped. One of the other guys downed his shot with a grin. I sat there completely still, my glass untouched in my lap, heat rushing to my face.
I hadn’t.
Not in person.
Not up close.
Not even once.
Porn did not count in my mind, and I had managed to avoid every locker room situation, every awkward sleepover, every moment where it might have happened. I always told myself it was no big deal. Now the truth felt exposed under all these eyes.Mia noticed immediately. Of course she did. Nothing got past her.
Her gaze locked onto me and her eyebrows rose. “Wait. You didn’t drink.”The room quieted. Everyone turned toward me.I tried to shrug it off even though my face was burning. “Nope. Never.”A couple of people looked genuinely surprised. Mia’s expression changed to pure delight, like she had just discovered something delicious.“Oh honey,” Mia said softly, her voice warm but full of challenge. She uncrossed her legs and stood up, moving toward me with that slow, confident stride. “You have been sitting here through all these filthy stories and you have never even seen another cock? That is actually adorable.”
She stopped right in front of me and tilted her head.“Here is what we are going to do,” she continued, her tone leaving almost no room for argument. “Since you have never seen one, you do not have to drink. But if you want to stay in the game and keep playing with the rest of us, you are going to fix that tonight.”
Mia glanced over at Jake, then back at me with a wicked smile. “Jake, be a good sport and help our friend out. Stand up.”
She turned back to me. “You are going to sit right here while Jake shows you his cock. Up close. You are going to look at it, really look, and tell us exactly what you think. No hiding. No looking away. And if you get hard while you are watching, you have to admit it out loud.”
My heart hammered hard in my chest. Part of me wanted to laugh it off and run. Another part, the curious and nervous part I rarely admitted existed, was already reacting to her words.Mia crouched down so we were eye level. Her voice dropped to an intimate whisper that still carried through the quiet room.
“You deserve to know what it feels like to experience something new instead of always wondering. No more avoiding it. So tell me…”She rested a hand lightly on my knee, eyes sparkling.“Are you going to keep playing it safe, or are you finally going to look?”
The room waited.Your move: Do you accept Mia’s challenge and let Jake show you?
Do you ask for different terms or someone else?
Do you try to stall or talk your way out?
Or do you have a completely different reaction?
Your continuation. Take it wherever you want. The night is young and Mia is very patient. Until she is not.
What's next?
- No further chapters
- Add a new chapter
A Compilation Tale of Never Have I Ever
Play the game contributions welcome
Each Chapter is begging for you to take the challenge
Updated on Jun 27, 2026
by ManRayMansker
Created on Jun 27, 2026
by ManRayMansker
- 7 Likes
- 484 Views
- 3 Favorites
- 1 Bookmarks
- 26 Chapters
- 3 Chapters Deep
Comments moved below the chapter.

Comments