Passion takes over.

(inspired by comment from Thrakaboo)

You look into Tara's eyes...deep and blue-green and full of longing and need. Her hand is squeezing yours so tight...
You never stood a chance.
Your lips lock on hers as you lay her on her back.
"James..." her voice is breathy now as you kiss her neck, palming her perky tits as you start to rev yourself up for another go.. "...again, really?" her hands are gripping your head and shoulder as you move on down from her neck to suckle on her tits. She moans...
"I think..." you pant as her hands run through your hair, "I think I might love you, Tara." Wow..you are going to regret saying that later, you are sure, but you're also not sure it's untrue. Beneath this sex bomb exterior, there's a tender, needy girl, **** for someone to take care of her and give her affection.
"But," her voice is hesitant now, "..what about Ms. Jenna?" her hands won't stop caressing your scalp, and her own tits, betraying the concern in her words.
"We'll figure something out." You plunge into the valley of her legs, eating a pussy that's still full of your cum.
"Ooooh....James. You are...." Tara arches her back, involuntarily wrapping her thighs around your head as you expertly eat her out. "Oh wow. You're so good at that. I've never had my kitty eaten out the way you do. Most guys don't have the first idea what to...mmmph....do..."
"Real men eat pussy, Tara." You look up at her over her heaving tits, and she smiles and nods.
"You're so sexy, James. I...." she grips her tits and gyrates her hips. She's grinding her snatch into your face now. "I fucking love you, too!!" Yep...regret.
You slide up to kiss her, and you wrap your arms around her as you plunge back into that warm, ready cunt, now lubricated with a generous dose of your own cum. This fuck is different. You pump slowly and deeply, with passion and strength. Tara is in total bliss, she's gripping your hips with her legs crossed behind you, pulling you into her.
"Cum inside me, James. You've already done it once, what does it matter now?" her enticing whisper drives you to a new orgasm. Strangely, you have no trouble cumming a second time. Is Jenna the problem after all?
"Ah....you're filling me up again. I'm so full of your spunk, baby!" She kisses you, her mouth on fire as she bucks against your hips, trying to milk as much out of you as she can into her waiting pussy.
You roll off Tara, panting, with an arm over your eyes. You're in deep, deep shit. You've demonstrated pretty clearly that you can't control yourself with this girl. How long before it's inevitably discovered?
"Ah! Ah!" You look over to see Tara bringing herself off, her pussy squeezing out a river of your jizz. She rolls over onto you, kissing you with adoration in her eyes.
"We'll figure it out, right James? I never want to stop."
"....sure."
You sit up, cleaning your cock with the towel. "Time to get dressed and tidy up. When you've got the pills and have taken them, you'll give me a hand getting this place ready?" Tara is pulling on her tight black cotton thong over her heavenly rear end, and you watch, mesmerized. Your foot is fully in the bear trap, you might as well enjoy it.
"Sure thing, baby. I have to scoot out of here by 2:00, so I can go home and get ready for work, but that's plenty of time." You're staring at her in James's mirror as she pulls on a tight black v-neck t-shirt, and ties her hair up into a ponytail.
"Uh...yeah...it's a shame you won't be able to stick around...for dinner." You're still in a towel. Your shorts are in the bathroom.
"Alright then!" you clap your hands together and leave Jared's room.

You spend the rest of the morning cleaning and tidying up, trying to return your head space to normal. Tara helps, and then plops down on the couch to watch TV. When Jenna returns, you all help put away the groceries, and just as you finish that, twin car horns honk as they pull into your driveway.