More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 74 by Fever Dreamer Fever Dreamer

What to do with Allie and Sasha?

Out With The Old, In With The New

"Hey, Allie?" Aaron asked.

"Yes?"

"Do you want to be my girlfriend?"

Allie blinked. "Do I?"

"Sure you do."

"Oh, okay. Then yes," Allie said with a vacant smile.

"Have you ever had a boyfriend before?"

"Once, but he cheated on me after less than a month, so I don't think it really counts."

Aaron sighed. "I'm not going to lie, I expect I'll be fucking Natalie once a month from now on, so that probably counts as cheating too."

Allie's eyes seemed to lose focus as she processed this before responding.

"That's okay. She said you have to, so it's not your fault."

Aaron wasn't sure it worked like that, but he was happy to let her believe it.

"Great. Then we're dating now. Love you, babe."

Allie's face slowly formed a dreamy smile. "I love you, too."

Aaron went into Sasha's bedroom with Sasha's soul in a glass, her body managing to sit itself halfway up before collapsing sideways with a frustrated whimper.

"Sorry for getting you involved in this," Aaron said, removing the peach soul and putting it back where it came from before reluctantly taking a bite. There wasn't the spark of electricity he had been expecting, but the burst of flavour definitely contained something else within; a richness that warmed his senses as the juice and pulp slid down his throat. Finishing the entire thing left him feeling... filled. Like a hunger beyond the physical had been at least partially sated.

While waiting for Natalie to return, Aaron dropped Sasha's soul onto the counter and tried his best to remove the memories of his visit that day wearing Natalie's body. It was an imprecise job, and she probably lost more than just memories of the day, but given what he had planned for her, it wouldn't make much difference.

Aaron used Sasha's phone to make a note of every guy (and a couple of girls) she'd been fucking, sucking, sexting and generally stringing along in return for favours. Every one of them received an invitation to the apartment for later that evening with the promise of a night to remember.

Natalie let herself in through the front door, a bag of clothes for Aaron in one hand. She played gently with Allie's unresisting body while Aaron got changed, and he could hear Allie's breathing grow ragged as she became aroused.

"Leave her alone, Nat."

"What are you going to do with her? You've stolen her will and she can't go out like this."

"I'll take care of her until she grows back into herself. It shouldn't take long."

"Okay, but I get to play with her while we wait for that to happen."

Aaron looked at the faraway expression on Allie's face as she lost herself in the pleasure.

"Okay, just don't hurt her."

"Of course."

Aaron returned to the bedroom, dropping Sasha's limp soul back into her body and watching her sluggishly return to consciousness.

"Hey, Sasha," he said when she squinted at him.

"Hhhuh?"

"I just wanted you to know I'm breaking up with you. Have a nice night."

Aaron left without waiting for an answer, leaving the bedroom door open behind him.

"Time to get her dressed," he said. "We're going home."

Aaron and Natalie helped Allie back into her pizza delivery uniform, leading her out by the hand and into the car. Aaron stuck a bent paperclip into the front door lock in a way that prevented it from closing properly, so that whoever turned up later that night would have no trouble letting themselves in.

Aaron let Allie straddle him in the back seat, still aroused and rubbing herself up and down his body. Natalie drove in silence, but Aaron could practically hear her amused smirk.

The new "family" arrive home...

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)