Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 46 by Lexifire314 Lexifire314

Are the girls able to make it home in time?

One more barefoot hike

Jamie dug deep for any remaining ounce of inner strength. She grit her teeth and pushed the feeling of unending stimulation to the corner of her mind. Just get through the night. They were so close to being able to close this unfortunate chapter. Through sheer **** of will, she got back on her feet.

"Jessica, can you please pack everything back up for me, I just need a minute. Oh but leave us a couple candles for light."

"Of course, anything you need." Jessica replied.

Jamie had been exceedingly grateful for the light of the full moon tonight. Without it, they probably would've had no hope of navigating the forest. But now the moon was dipping low in the sky. It would be morning soon. Neither girl would be getting any sleep. Bag packed, flickering candles in hand, the two naked girls set out once more into the night.

"So walk me through the plan again." Jessica inquired. "I've been trying to follow all this magic stuff but..."

"Yeah" Jamie grunted, still lost in the haze of stimulation and arousal coming from her backside. "First priority is getting you home. By the time we walk over there, the plug should have a couple hours of 'charge' on it. It's not much but it should allow you to get through the day if you take a sick day off of school. Just stay in bed and only use the plug for emergencies. Do you have a way to get in your house without anybody noticing?"

"We keep a key under the doormat." Jessica offered.

"Good. So just sit tight for the day and maybe get caught up on sleep. I'll come over later and we can regroup. I'm sure I'll end up getting grounded by my parents but I'll figure out some way to get to you."

"Okay, um... I can do that" Jessica said uncertainly. Her mind was imagining all the slippery situations she might end up in over the following day just trying to avoid exposing herself. She was glad that Jamie had seemingly put some thought into this plan but there were still a lot of unknowns from her perspective.

"What will you be doing for the day?" Jessica continued.

"I have to smooth things over with my parents and hopefully avoid any punishments that keep me from seeing you. They'll probably still make me go to class today. And then there's the bigger plan to fix the rest of your curse related issues. Lots to do, no rest for the wicked." Jamie explained, trying to sound positive.

"And this big plan... what exactly does that involve?"

"You let me worry about that. I got you into this mess and I'll be the one to get you out" Jamie answered.

"You don't have to do this alone!" Jessica exclaimed. "Whatever it is, I can help!"

"This part I have to do alone. Please just trust me." Jamie pleaded.

Jessica wasn't happy with this answer but for now she was too tired to argue further. The two girls continued their long walk in silence, sticking to the cover of foliage as much as possible.

By now, Jessica's inner thighs were completely slick with "pussy" juice. It was a strange, but not entirely unwelcome feeling. Her ass cheeks glided silky-smooth across each other. Her pussy lips joined in the back and forth. It was like someone had massaged baby oil into all her most sensitive bits.

Jamie did her best to lead the way, being the much better navigator. She had never been to Jessica's house before though, so was relying on Jessica's hazy memory to deduce the correct way to travel. Eventually, they did make it to Jessica's neighborhood and the two prepared to part ways.

"You can make it from here yeah?" Jamie asked once Jessica had pointed out her own house.

"Yeah." Jessica replied. "Thank you Jamie, for sticking with me, for everything."

"It's the very least I could do, really"

"Hey!" Jessica interjected, taking Jamie's hands. She stared into Jamie's eyes with a look that demanded respect. Well actually, a look that demanded Jamie respect herself; that challenged her to escape the cycle of self-depreciation. "You know I love you."

"Yeah... I know" Jamie answered warmly. She still couldn't quite believe that the girl who, only yesterday, she had hated enough to curse, was now the object of her deepest affection. Love and hate truly are two sides of the same coin.

After a moment Jessica added "Uhh... should we?"

Jamie caught the intended meaning as Jessica was glancing at her backside. "Right. One cursed butt plug coming right up."

She had almost gotten used to the constant edging induced by the onyx toy. But now that she was thinking about it again, she realized just how **** for release the cursed object had made her. Jamie took a squat and went about trying to evacuate her bowels. She took a firm grip on the base of the intruder and started pulling. It wasn't enough. She contracted her anal muscles like she was about to take the biggest shit of her life. Sticky juices oozes out around the obstruction. Her sphincter slowly dilated wider and wider. 'This must be like what giving birth feels like', she thought to herself as she grunted with effort.

With a sudden final contraction and a whimpering cry from Jamie, the huge plug was free. Excess fluid poured out of Jamie's gaping asshole into a sizeable puddle on the earth beneath her. As she brought the invader into view, both girls gasped. It was certainly bigger than any of the toys they'd purchased earlier that night, somewhere between 3 and 4 inches across Jamie thought.

As quickly as they took notice of its size, they watched in amazement as the cheeky toy began to shrink. After a few moments, it has shrunk down to a very reasonable size, no bigger than the small plug Jessica had been experimenting with earlier that night.

"What the fuck! That sneaky demon!" Jessica exclaimed. "It tricked me into coming up with that dumb lube curse for nothing."

"No, no. Not for nothing." Jamie panted. "I still think I needed the extra help to get this thing out. Nothing that wide has ever gone through my butthole before. And your ideas aren't dumb. Actually I think your ideas are gonna be our only saving grace in the end."

"What do you mean by that?" Jessica asked.

"This demon is inside my mind. It knows everything about me and is always 10 steps ahead of anything I can come up with. On top of that, it has some control over me now. It's almost like it can prevent me from coming up with ideas that go against its interest. But you... You're still a free agent. You can still have original ideas. I'm gonna be relying on you in the future to help untangle this web."

"If that's true, why aren't you telling me about your plan? Maybe there's something you're not considering." Jessica retorted.

Jamie sighed. "I promise I'll involve you more after this next part. It's just... really something I have to do myself."

Jessica pouted but didn't press the issue. Jamie handed over the butt plug and the two girls embraced one last time.

"Think everyone's still asleep?" Jamie asked.

"Uhh, yeah..." Jessica answered with half confidence. She didn't really want to deal with the demon plug just yet so she was gonna take the chance and sneak in the house with just her birthday suit.

"Okay, be safe, see you soon hopefully."

"Oh uhh... one thing... I hate to ask but..." Jessica started to say.

"Spit it out" Jamie teased playfully.

"I kinda left my purse and phone and all my stuff at Scott's house... Any way you could try to recover them? I know you hate his guts and probably don't want to see him but..."

Jamie blinked a couple times. "I'll do my best."

"Thanks!" Jessica smiled relieved. "Okay bye for real" she said as she sprinted naked back to her family home.

Does Jessica Avoid Suspicion?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)