Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by johnsmithhhhh37 johnsmithhhhh37

What does Sarah find?

Oh come on...

Sarah opened the door and immediately gasped and covered her mouth. Beth put her hands in her face. Lisa sighed and rolled her eyes.

Against all odds Felicia lay on the couch with her legs spread and a DKM frat boy pumping enthusiastically away at her pussy. Her eyes were closed and her mouth was slightly open as she lay back and enjoyed the crude thrusts of the guy on top of her. As her sisters watched she spread her legs further, inviting the DKM bro even deeper inside her.

Lisa cleared her throat loudly.

Felicia's eyes snapped open to see her three sisters standing in the doorway with the same look of disgust on their faces.

"Oh shit."

"Seriously Felicia" said Lisa. "We were gone for, like, half an hour."

"I can explain! This isn't what it looks like!" said a breathless Felicia.

"It looks like about 5 minutes after we left a frat bro stopped by and you immediately dropped your panties and spread your legs for him." replied Sarah.

"...oh. Then I guess it is exactly what it looks like..." the last word was cut off by an especially passionate thrust from the man who was rutting her.

"Can you please stop fucking our sister?" asked Lisa.

"Nah, I'm good. I'm just gonna nut in her and then I'll head out" replied the Bro without interrupting his rhythm. His face remained hidden in Felicia's hair.

"Now the guys are going to think we're all as easy as Felicia they'll be all over us... so much for hoping they get bored..."

"I resent that!" said Felicia. Then a few stifled moans later "...ok, point taken..." she whispered closing her eyes, laying her head back and letting the bro continue to have his way with her.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)