Offer something BIG in desperation.

I keep throwing out options at random, willing to try anything to get out of this predicament, and in a panic, I say something that I immediately regret.

“Fuck me in the ass with a dildo, Josh,” I say in desperation.

I gasp. I can’t believe I said that out loud. I’ve never let anyone have sex with me like that before. I’ve never even considered letting someone fuck me there. But I’m ****. There’s no way he’d turn that down, right? I mean, it’s my ass! It’s practically the holy grail of sex. But no. He doesn’t stop. He’s not interested in fucking me. I’m not good enough for him. I feel so pathetic. Not only did he break me into offering my anal virginity, but he doesn’t even want it.

I continue to cackle uncontrollably, throwing out the most perverted and degrading suggestions I can muster in a panic. I can’t think while he’s fucking tickling me! Ha, ha, ha, fuck, just let me think! He doesn’t want to fuck me. He wants to punish me. That’s it. That's the key.

“Josh, please spank my ass again. Please, I’m begging you. I want it. Please, please, please,” I plead.

Josh pauses. It worked. I found something he wants.

Josh cuts the rope tying down my right arm, and for a brief moment I think he’s decided to let me go, but then I realize he’s just turning me on my side. He’s really going to spank me again. He’s so good at pushing my buttons that he’s got me begging him to fuck me instead of the other way around. Guys are so easy, they all want me, but with Josh, I’m the one begging for sex. It’s such a mindfuck. Even as he frees my arm, I know better than to resist. It’s fruitless to argue.

“How many spankings do you want, Jennifer?” Josh asks.

“Um, five,” I reply.