No, so he is penalized. But...

Ben looked out of his window to see the last rays of the Sun sunk under the horizon. He turned to the spirit in pink and asked, "I don't suppose that the new day don't start from now?"

Inara smirked as she said as she snapped her fingers, "No. And your punishment has been chosen and implimented."

"Wait? What? What punishment?" Ben asked freaking out, trying to figure out what his punishment was.

"I just punish you. I don't have to tell you what it is. You can have fun figuring out what it is." Inara continued, enjoying herself. She then continued, "So you want to make a wish? Or wait until after next sunset for your new punishment?"

"Fine" grumbled Ben as he released that she was making part of his punishment not tell him his punishment. So he was getting to prepare to wish. What he didn't know was that his penalty was the removal of all resistance to indulging with his lusts as well as people reacting to that as if it was a bad thing.

Something Ben would object with, normally, but would allow Inara to get what she wanted with. Sex, and lots of it.