Chapter 24
by
Samus1001
Not going overboard. Not one bit.
No, Going Overboard in the Theater
This chapter originally written by CrossC, minor edits by Samus1001
Rachel was rocking, hammering her ass back into Caleb's hips with every thrust he made into her happy pussy as she moaned breathy "yes's" into her arms wrapped around the back of the gently rocking seat. God. He was in heaven, his hands holding her cute well-rounded butt even as he looked around to see every woman in the theater in a similar position just waiting for his attention.
To be honest, more than a few of these women were unattractive to say the least but he didn't know if it was his level of lewd arousal or if it was the effect of the obscene position he'd made it normal for every lady to take when watching a film in the theater but all of their naked bottoms were attracting his interest, even though some of them were just as fat as the angry/happy black woman he'd penetrated to start off this amazing sex spree.
Despite the overpriced tickets each person had paid to see this movie, Caleb couldn't help but notice that for more than a few of the occupants of this large auditorium it was him that was the center of attention even over that of the main actor on the silver screen.
The lights were down low but he could see a lot of women rocking back and forth in their seats, some of them were even stealthily touching themselves, their stroking fingers only truly visible to someone like him who was positioned to face their raised bottoms as he pounded Rachel's mewling quim (thank you, Loki, for that though you've passed by this point in the timeline, you will be missed). As he fucked his date, Caleb found his attention continually drawn to the raised bottoms of the two women that had accompanied the middle-aged dude sitting beside him, a mother and daughter pair if he wasn't mistaken.
He pulled out of Rachel, her pussy protesting with a wet squelching grasp upon his retreating length. He believed she'd had at least one maybe two orgasms in the short time he'd been plunging, his recent plethora of sexual experiences perhaps giving him the discerning eye to detect such things from a certain way a vagina throbbed around him the telltale pulse of muscular contractions. So he wasn't feeling too bad about following his wandering urge to plow a new pussy, plus with the watch she'd be happy enough whatever he did.
As he gave her offered derriere a happy slap and fondle, he twisted in the confined space of the aisle to move towards the other women. Rachel spun around on her seat, hand clutching his side, the other brandishing her smartphone, "Woah babe, let me get a selfie real quick before you go about doing your public service!"
Caleb grinned, having already forgotten his last crazy change to what people considered normal. He stopped and turned to face her, standing tall in the aisle. He noticed he was blocking the view of the screen to the grey-haired man in the aisle behind, but he didn't appear to mind if the intense expression on his face was anything to go by as he stared at Rachel as she posed with her face next to Caleb's cock and held up her phone. It also probably didn't hurt that to either side of him were the depantsed asses of his seatmates.
As his date snapped her pic, the fat black woman suddenly sidled up to Caleb, her hand cupping his naked ass, "Oooh. My turn next, girl-stretcher. My ladies aren't gonna believe the monster-dick I just got."
He chuckled, "Okay... fuck...." Rachel slipped back into her seat, furiously tapping away at her phone, and the woman squeezed down between them to go with pressing her chin into his balls and laying his shaft atop her face as she pressed it into her cheek, stretching it down to press it against her lips and nose, rubbing them both as his meaty length stretched just beyond the top of her head.
Caleb didn't even know the woman's name, but she gave him a toothy grin around his meat as he felt her hand slide down and cup his balls, fingers pressing into his thigh as she winked and took her pic, holding her smartphone up around his stomach.
Then she was pulling away slightly and mirroring Rachel, plump fingers expertly manipulating the apps on her phone. He caught the image of his stark white cock atop her dark smiling face going up on the usual social media site, the caption she wrote something like, 'Look at this great big white boy that gave me the STRETCH tonight!'
Soon enough she was getting up and returning to her seat, but not before pressing a tiny slip of paper into his hand that had the words 'Your slam-piece anytime' and a phone number. Jesus. This was too much. Shaking his head and stroking his slick cock wet with the juices of two women, he awkwardly stepped past the knees of the dude in the seat next to his and settled in behind the ass cheeks of his probably-daughter, an even bigger buttocks on the other side that had to be the mother of this little family.
Laying a hand on the mother's plump hips and ass, squeezing them even as he felt the daughter lean back against him as soon as she felt the contact of his dick on her skin, the supple curve of her lower back fitting into his loins as her buttock cleaves parted slightly, inviting the tip of his glans in its slick coating of spit and feminine juices to nuzzle in and out of her crack.
He gave her a little spank and she jiggled, giggling.
Caleb glanced at the bland faced Hispanic dad beside her, feeling unreasonably, except- no, reasonably confident, he met the older man's eyes and remarked casually, "You mind, bud?" he slapped his thick cock down on her butt-cheeks, drumming back and forth between them, "I'm about to put this in your daughter."
He snorted, a big smile on his face as he actually reached out and slapped his own daughter's ass, splayed fingers grasping most of one butt-cheek and actually spreading her a bit for Caleb, "For you? No, man, I'm honored! Go right ahead and stick it in my wife, too! No need to ask. Doing me a favor, giving my girls the ol big dick stretch!"
Caleb was briefly taken back by the way the man fondled his daughter in this situation. Yes, he'd gotten used to the way men casually played grab-ass with various women all the time now but this seemed a bit much, butt-touching between father and daughter. Despite that, he found he didn't actually care that much and in fact found the normally taboo action to be arousing in an uncomfortable way. So instead of worrying about it, he shifted his hips down and plunged into the girl's waiting cunt.
She squealed in delight and the man laughed, "A'ight! Go 'head an' give it to my little girl, big boy!"
What's next?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
The Normality Dial
Changing reality with a word
This story is based off a branch of Murakami's Normality found here. https://chyoa.com/chapter/Introduction.174576 In this story, our hero Caleb Anders, finds a watch that allows him to change reality, with certain rules based on the time the watch is set at. A special thanks to BiBiComte and CrossC for allowing me to reprint their own chapters here. I have credited them for each of their chapters at the start of those chapters. I may have made a few minor changes and grammatical corrections, though I am by no means perfect myself.
Updated on Jun 8, 2026
by Samus1001
Created on Jul 20, 2025
by Samus1001
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments
