Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by Phantom23 Phantom23

What's next?

Night after Initiation With Pyrrha.

I laid awake at night, staring at the ceiling just an hour after getting into bed, Nora started to snore...

And it was loud!

Lin was asleep peacefully, how? Practice.

Something I had to get over time, but right now Nora was like lawnmower.

I rubbed my face as I tugged on my black shirt and shorts.

"... John are you awake?" Pyrrha whispered from her bed.

"Yes... Do you wanna-" "Yes." I turned and Pyrrha was already getting up, her sleepwear consisted of a white shirt and pajama pants.

"Let's go." She said and I got up, we both left the room and walked down the hall.

... Okay I had the chance. "Not how I expected the second night to go." I started off.

"No." Pyrrha giggled. "But I suppose we'll get used to it over time."

"Hopefully... Maybe we can get some makeshift earplugs, but then we wouldn't be able to hear our alarm." I said.

"That's a downside..." Pyrrha sighed. "Although I do wake before my alarm most days." A silence fell between us.

"... Ever had a boyfriend?" I asked her.

Pyrrha pasued and looked at me, blushing. "W-what kind of question is that?" She asked.

"It's valid!" I raised my hands. "A beautiful champion like you, must've had many guys after you."

Pyrrha blushed more and crossed her arms. "Well... I have had no boyfriends... I didn't find any suitors interesting."

I nodded. "Probably didn't know the real you."

"And what do you think the real me is like?" She asked, giving me a narrowed stare.

Don't show too much... Or maybe...

"Hmm well it's only a first impression but I get a good read of you." I explained. "Would you like to hear it?"

Pyrrha's lip quirked up. "Very well, impress me with your idea of the real me."

"Pyrrha Nikos, champion of Mistral tournaments, you love to fight against others, you love a challenge but when was the last time someone was able to challenge you? When has the Invincible girl ever been a normal girl like everyone else?" I told her.

Pyrrha's eyes grew wide. "... Hmm that's good but what about my traits?" She asked softly.

"Loyal." "Every boy says that." "Competitive." "I'm a tournament fighter." "Kind." "Everyone knows that from my interviews." "Looking for someone to dominate you in every way possible."

That last sentence shut her up. Pyrrha bit her lip. "I don't know what you mean." She denied.

"Winning all the time must be exhausting." I told her. "But... You don't want to lose, you want to have a fair fight... But maybe you also want to have a man take you and humiliate you." I lean closer to her.

Pyrrha's breath hitched. "I... No I don't." She denied.

I had her! Just gotta bring her in. "Oh? You don't want a man to just... Take you, overpower you and take you?" I whispered into her ear, making her shudder.

"I... If that's the case then I would have a boyfriend already." She whispered.

"You're not looking for any man, you're looking for one to give you a good time on the side, you want to be with good guy to the public while indoors, you're nothing but a toy." He cupped her cheek, her emerald green eyes stared into my brown ones.

Pyrrha started to shake, she licked her dry lips. "We just met." She said hoarsely.

"Does that matter?" I couldn't help but smirk, the feeling of towering over her was intoxicating.

"... No..." She grabbed my shirt and pressed her lips against mine.

I wrapped my arms around her waist and returned the kiss with ferocity.

Pyrrha wrapped her arms around my neck and I pushed her against the wall.

A sound caused us to pull away. Pyrrha looked to the source of the noise in panic.

I looked to my left saw a supply closet, I grabbed her and dragged her inside, closing the door behind us.

The supply closet light was already on and it was cramped, we were pressed against each other to avoid any hanging appliances, I heard the footsteps get closer, I looked down at Pyrrha who looked at the door in trepidation.

I leaned down and started kissing her neck.

Pyrrha withheld a squeak as I did this, her eyes growing wider in panic as she grabbed my head but made no move to push me away.

I grabbed her shirt and pulled it up, revealing rather large breasts and pink nipples, she looked at me in shock but bit her lip as I dived down and started sucking on her nipple.

The footsteps stopped right outside the door. Pyrrha bitting her lip harder than before to keep her moans in, I just twirled my tongue around her nipple.

The footsteps started again, but they got farther every moment.

Pyrrha closed her eyes and finally let out a moan as she held my head. "We were almost caught." She whimpered.

"That excites you? The great Pyrrha Nikos, falls from grace because she was caught having sex with her new partner in a supply closet?" I whispered as I pull away from her nipple.

"W-we're not having sex." She whispered.

"You don't want to?" I asked her.

Pyrrha stared at me, her heart beating wildly, she nodded. "Please... Fuck me." She begged.

My grin couldn't get any wider, I pushed my shorts down and my cock flopped out.

Pyrrha's eyes went wide, she bit her lip and looked around, she moved some appliances aside and leaned back, pulling her shirt up, placing the hem of her shirt between her teeth, pushing her pajama pants down, I got a good look at her body, her stomach was toned with abs, her breasts firm yet bountiful, her pussy was wet with a small patch of red hair over it, she looked like a goddess.

"Don't stare." She murmured.

"I can stare whenever I want." I stepped closer and slowly pushed into her.

Pyrrha gasped and whined as I stretched her out, her eyes on me, her arms around my neck, she bit on the fabric of her shirt as I started to move in and out of her.

A bit of red could be seen on my cock as I moved.

Her whines and moans were muffled from her biting her shirt.

I groaned softly and thrusts faster, her pussy was squeezing my cock so tightly, she was sucking me in.

Her eyes closed shut as I rammed harder into her, she started shaking and put her legs around my waist, holding me tightly, her whines growing higher in pitch.

"Fuck I'm gonna cum!" I hissed, she didn't let go, she doubled down and locked her legs around my waist, she made a sound of consent and used a hand to cup my cheek, she let go of her shirt and kissed me hard.

I erupted inside her, filling her pussy with my cum, she moaned into my mouth and tightened her hold on me.

I finish cumming and pull away from the kiss. "Was... This okay?"

"Yes... Today is a safe day." She assured me and smiled. "This... Was amazing." She bit her lip, she reached down, taking some cum onto her fingers and licks it, she moaned in delight, Neo's power taking effect.

"... We should head back." I told her.

"Agreed." Pyrrha nodded and we got dressed after cleaning up with the supplies that was in the closet.


We arrived quietly and thankfully, Nora and Lin were still asleep.

"Okay... Good." I sighed in relief.

Pyrrha smiled and kissed my cheek. "Good night." She whispered and then went to the bathroom.

I got into bed and tried to ignore the snoring, but having sex with Pyrrha wore me out, I fell asleep in moments.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)