Nicole

"Nikki..." Kenny breathed as he gave his blindfold a firm tug. His eyes adjusted to the light and fixated down on the redhead below him. During the fray, she had ended up on her back, laying sprawled in the center, completely bare and open. Her pale chest was rising and falling rapidly, bright blue eyes wider than ever before but remained deadlocked on Kenny in utter disbelief. "Nikki," Kenny sighed with an assuring nod, his eyes trailing up and down her filled-out body, first admiring her gorgeously large tits and then her still tightly squeezing cunt that slowly dripped out his cum from around his shaft.

"I...wasn't expecting that..." Nicole stated in a calm, if not completely uncertain tone, still unable to take her eyes off Kenny, who was staring back at her with a dreamy look,

"Are you fucking serious?!" Quinn sprang out, screaming out in fury, "Nicole?!"

"Kenny, really? After everything that we've been through together, Nikki, is your choice?" Ellie added on, sounding a bit calmer but in no way less offended,

Kenny looked over to the pair and slowly retracted his softening cock from Nicole, "Listen, I'm sorry, but you all wanted me to be honest and make my choice, and I..." Kenny let out a breathy half-laugh, looking over to the redhead who slowly sat up, remaining ever stunned, "I pick Nicole,"

"No fucking way, this isn't a fucking joke, Kenny! This isn't some hook-up; you had to pick the girl you loved! The girl you wanted to be with!" Quinn seethed though Kenny merely narrowed his eyes,

"I understood the rules, Quinn. And I'm sorry that I didn't pick you," His voice was nothing but genuine and respectful, "I'm sorry to both of you, but I didn't make my choice based on how good it felt,"

Ellie shook her head in clear refusal, "That doesn't make any -- you weren't like this with her before! What happened?! What changed?! The last time you had Nicole and I both, you were focused on me; I saw it!"

"And you promised me, Kenny, we talked about this before!" Quinn swiftly added, "This wasn't supposed to happen! Not with her!"

The teen let out a low exhale, gathering his clothes and redressing, "Listen, I am, honestly, fully, genuinely sorry, okay? I am sorry. But nothing changed. Nothing is different from any other time I've been with Nicole. This time I just...I woke up, alright? I realized that I had to make my choice, and for once, Nikki was...an option. I never thought I'd have that chance to be with her like this," The teen looked to the redhead who tugged down her shirt, finishing her redressing while her blue eyes stared at the floor and her cheeks were completely flush, "I've...trusted Nicole, with everything. She's been there for me as a friend first and then...as something more."

"This is such bullshit," Ellie turned away, crossing her arms; her face began to turn red, and her eyes started to water, "You didn't care about me...or Quinn...or anyone else but her, didn't you?"

"That's not true," Kenny immediately denied with a shake of his head,

"Fucking liar," Quinn hissed back,

"I'm not lying!" Kenny exclaimed, "I never lied about caring about you two! I still do! But you asked me here, you asked me to be honest to both you and myself, and the truth was, I wanted Nicole, okay? That doesn't change anything that happened before with us; I mean that." The girls were silent for a long few moments before Ellie finally turned her head, the blonde's eyes red and streaming with tears,

"You're...making a mistake." She finally uttered with a cracking voice. Quinn pursed her lips but nodded in complete agreement. Kenny lifted a hand, letting out a low disappointed exhale, understanding the response but nowhere near accepting of it,

"Maybe they're right, Ken," Nicole finally spoke up and Kenny was immediately overtaken by her words, "I mean, maybe this whole thing was a bad idea,"

"No," Kenny stepped closer to the redhead, giving his head a firm shake, "This was the right idea. Things needed to be settled once and for all; there was no good way for this to happen, I see that now. All that was left with at least honesty. And I honestly want to be with you Nicole,"

Nicole nervously swallowed but just as quickly put on one of her standard winning smiles, "That's not what I meant, Clark," She gently pushed him aside with her hand and walked over to the girls, "I made a mistake in fucking all this up. Why were we complaining about this in the first place? For months we've all been sharing him, and for months we've been happy, why change that?" Quinn's raised a brow and Ellie blinked a few slow times, "What's so wrong with sharing?" The two girls briefly looked at one another before going back to Nicole, "So Clark picked me, so what, I'm willing to share the love. He can be with me, but he can be with you both too. It's a win situation for everyone," Nicole finished, her chest confidently puffed out.

Ellie wet her lips, thinking it over for a few long moments, "I...I suppose that I could...I mean, it wouldn't change anything really..."

Quinn pursed her lips, "I guess that's true, I mean, fuck...what difference would it make, it's already been running this way all summer," The redhead reluctantly agreed, "I could work with that,"

"Me too," Ellie nodded, and Nicole smiled wide,

"I can't." Kenny suddenly said causing all three girls to look over in shock, none more than Nicole, "I don't want all three of you. I don't want two. All I want is you Nicole. I made my choice. That's final."

"You've got to be fucking kidding me!" Quinn exclaimed as Kenny walked up to Nicole,

"Kenny, what are you doing?!" Ellie furiously added as the teen took Nicole's hands,

"I only want you, Nikki," Kenny calmly continued, "You and me. That's it. No one else. You'd be mine and I'd be yours."

Nicole face went pale and the normally confident, carefree girl all but slunk away looking like a terrified child, "I -- I don't -- Y-You can't be --" Nicole stumbled out, her face turned bright red and her body was trembling, "I can't do this!" The finally exclaimed turning and bolting out of Ellie's dorm room without so much as a look back.

"Nikki?" Kenny softly asked as the redhead slammed the door shut behind her, leaving him alone with Ellie and Quinn.