Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 57 by JohnLocke4 JohnLocke4

Who Is It?

Nicole Looks Out For Her Friends

Ellie checked her phone as she rode up the elevator of the Mountain Lodge Hotel. "Room sixteen..." She softly said under her breath. "He said he needed to talk to me, but here? Not the gym?" A smile flickered over her lips, "It's just like our first time." She whimsically added, "All the stress of these last few weeks, having to play it safe. We haven't been doing anything. He must have been planning this for a while," The elevator opened and Ellie confidently strode to the hotel room, "Fuck I'm getting turned on just thinking of what he's been planning for me," The blonde's left hand danced to her mound and teased herself just a little while she knocked on the door.

Her growing smile of anticipation abruptly fell into a scowl as the door opened, and she merely saw Nicole Moore standing in unashamed nudity. "I was wondering if you'd actually show," Ellie glared at the redhead.

"Nikki? You're here?" Nicole smiled, "No...don't fucking tell me." Ellie gritted her teeth and shoved Nicole to the side storming into the hotel room.

Kenny shot up in bed swinging his legs onto the floor but froze as Ellie planted herself in front of him, "Elle...I..."

"Kenny?" Ellie's fists tightened, "Why would you -- you invited -- I don't understand why you --" The blonde stammered, too confused and in shock for her anger to be in complete control.

"Ellie," Nicole shut the door and made her way towards the pair, "Take it easy. I sent the message." Ellie snapped her attention over to the redhead, "I was only trying to do you a favor."

Ellie's jaw was agape, she looked to Kenny who looked just about mortified, and then back to Nicole who couldn't stop from smiling, "A favor? This is a fucking favor?!" The blonde finally exploded.

Kenny flinched and squeezed his eyes shut, not sure what to expect. Yet, Nicole didn't miss a beat, "Yeah, exactly," The redhead stepped to Ellie and wrapped an arm around her, "Kenny is amazing to fuck but then I was thinking about my poor, neglected, lonely friend. The idea of you suffering for so long with, ahem, half a man? It killed me, so I figured I could share. Aren't I great?!" She finished with a light-hearted cheer.

Kenny meekly peeked an eye open just in time to see Ellie grinding her teeth. She slowly turned her head and stared into Nicole's eyes, "You fucking...you know, don't you?" Nicole let out an innocent hum of confusion, "About us! About me and Kenny!" The blonde clarified and Kenny raised his brow.

"Oh, that!" Nicole tilted her head and merely shut her eyes, smiling all the wider, "Maaaaaaaybe?"

Ellie finally pulled away from Nicole's grasp and let out an eerily monotone laugh, "You knew about us..." Ellie's face twitched a few times before she pursed her lips and glared back at Kenny, "I should've known; you're nothing but an asshole." Kenny's eyes filled with guilt and then utter concern as Ellie turned away, her eyes misty, "I'm fucking out of here. Have fun with Nicole."

Is she crying? Kenny watched as Ellie kept her head low and stormed towards the door, "Ellie, wait! Please, let me talk to you!"

Ellie ignored Kenny's pleads and kept walking only for Nicole to suddenly intervene. "Hey now, that's not very nice, rejecting a perfect gift like this," Nicole extended an arm, blocking Ellie's march. Kenny's eyes widened as the moment Ellie attempted to shove Nicole's arm away, the redhead grabbed her by the waist and pulled her to the floor. "Where do you think you're going?" Nicole grinned, keeping the blonde pinned below her, "You're already here, we have the room for the night. Don't you want to play with me and Ken?"

"No, I don't!" Ellie snapped back, "Now get off me and let me leave, Nicole. Now!"

"Don't be like that, Elle," Nicole breathed back and slid a hand down between them, pressing it against Ellie's mound. The blonde's eyes bugged out and she instinctively let out a moaning gasp. "Whatever happened to that girl I knew before she went all straight and narrow?" Nicole's hand continued to tease Ellie's g-spot while her middle finger danced around the girl's clit, "You remember the fun we used to have? Like with Devin? Come on, Elle, we both know Kenny will be better than that. Don't be so boring. Cut loose." Kenny slowly lowered onto the bed, merely watching the two girls on the floor.

"Nicole are you fucking insane?!" Ellie exclaimed only to tense as the redhead sensually dragged her tongue along the nape of the blonde's neck.

Nicole let out a murmuring laugh, "Oh yeah, I'm real crazy," Nicole planted a sucking kiss on Ellie's neck and the girl let out a whine, clearly fighting off another moan. Nicole's other hand began to pull up the girl's shirt, exposing her breasts and already hardened nipples. "Come on, Elle, let's play."

Kenny swallowed hard, his eyes glued to the scene. Do I stop this? Am I supposed to stop this? I...don't know what the fuck is going on. Kenny leaned forward as Nicole wrestled with Ellie, pulling the girl's shirt off. I really should stop this. But...maybe I just watch for a minute? Yeah...just a minute. "Nicole! I swear to God! I'll -- Aah! -- Ugh, would you s-stop! -- Aaaah! -- F-Fucking no! -- Oh Fuck, Ahhh!" A mixture of Ellie's protest and then full moans filled the room followed by her clothes being stripped off one by one. Kenny rolled in a lower lip and could only calmly exhale as Ellie's underwear was tossed and smacked him right in the face. Thank...you...God...

Nicole hopped up and wiped her brow with a huff, "Okay, there we go, I think she's willing to talk now," She grinned while looking down at the squirming, naked blonde at her feet, "Aren't you, sweetie?" Ellie let out a short mew as she attempted to regain control of her body. Nicole looked over to Kenny and motioned to Ellie expectantly, "Well? Aren't you going to say something?'

"O-Oh," Kenny croaked, "U-Uh, Ellie...are you okay?"

Nicole giggled, "Oh trust me, she's just fine." Kenny gave a quick nod and stared down at the blonde, unsure of what to say next. Ellie in turn was finding her breath and was now staring back, seeming to share the sentiment. "Okay, fine, let me start for you. Kenny, Ellie likes you a fucking lot. That's why she broke up with Will, isn't it, Ellie?" Kenny flicked his eyes up to Nicole in surprise then back down to Ellie who bashfully diverted her eyes.

"Y-You're not dating Will anymore? L-Like for real?" Ellie squeezed her eyes shut and nodded.

Nicole felt a lightbulb turn on in her head and smiled wide again, "Oooooh, okay," She said to herself and cleared her throat, "Ellie, you're still friends with Will right now, huh? You two hang out and go places like...oh maybe...the carnival together, but you let him go, didn't you?" Ellie flinched in embarrassment and Nicole lightly tapped Ellie's thigh with her foot, "Come on, say it."

"Yes, okay? I...I broke up with Will officially! God, why do I ever tell you anything?!" Ellie cupped her hands over her face and Kenny's eyes grew all the wider.

Nicole glowed vindicated and looked back to Kenny, but the truth seemed to hit him like a truck, and he was once again lost for words. "Oh my God, the both of you." Nicole suddenly reached down, lifting Ellie right off the floor. Kenny's entire body tensed as Nicole held Ellie up by her ass and walked her right over to him. Her legs were spread eagle, her cunt on full display as well as her breasts, and her blushing face was almost level with his, "Will you please just fucking say the truth to each other! Ellie, you like Kenny, riiiiiiiiight?"

"No, don't say that," Ellie growled, turning her head to glare at Nicole, "Stop, Nikki, please!"

"Nicole, you can stop trying to do whatever you're doing. She just said no," Kenny argued only for Nicole to scoff,

"Neither of you is being honest, and I can't stand dishonesty." Nicole sternly retorted, "Kenny, you look her in the eyes." The redhead ordered and Kenny reluctantly followed suit, "Ellie, last time. You like Kenny, yes?"

Ellie's head tilted to the side and she very weakly looked up at Kenny. "I...do," The blonde softly whispered and Kenny's cheeks went red.

"Seriously?" He immediately asked as he stepped in a few inches closer, "Nicole was right, what's been going on between us hasn't just been about getting what you've been missing from Will? You really left him because you've started...well, liking me?"

Ellie lifted her hands to her face and did her best to shield the blushing embarrassed mess it was becoming, "God, is this really fucking happening right now? I didn't want it to come out like this! This is the worst!"

Kenny felt a surge inside him, a feeling of worry or perhaps fear, lifted from his shoulders and he felt light. In the next moment, he found himself looking up and down the blonde's body again until his eyes locked on her spread, slick slit. He inched forward until his bulbous tip was at her entrance, "Elle..." The blonde opened her eyes, peering out from behind her fingers, "Can I?"

Ellie felt Kenny's cock nudge at her lower entrance, "J-Just...I -- Fuck, I don't know, do whatever you want. If you want to put it in, then put it in!" She rapidly replied.

"That a girl," Nicole cheerfully smiled,

Kenny let out a few panting breaths and reached his hands out, grabbing onto the bottom of Ellie's ass, joining Nicole in the effort to keep her held up. With a low, groaning exhale, he pushed his hips forward and his cock slid deep into Ellie's cunt. The blonde let out a shouting gasp and her entire body seized. Her hands flew down from her face, and her wide eyes stared at the ceiling for nearly thirty seconds before she finally exhaled. Ellie's head dropped down and Nicole and Kenny both leaned forward, looking at her intently, "Elle, are you alright?" Kenny softly asked only to groan as his cock was abruptly squeezed by Ellie's soft, hot interior.

Ellie lifted her head, her eyes dreamily looking back at Kenny, "I'm perfect," Her hands reached out, planting on his broad shoulders and she licked her lips, "Please, just kiss me," Kenny flicked his eyes between Nicole and Ellie for a moment before a grin grew on his face.


Just part one of the threesome scene. I'm thinking it might go for one or two more chapters at least haha.

How Does Kenny Handle Both Ellie And Nicole?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)