Natalie Gets a Little Dominating

Lisa chewed on her lips with pinched eyes and a needy expression. “I understand… I’m yours when I’m here,” she agreed as the words came out with her moans. Her head tipped back against the wall, parting her lips, and the water sprayed down on both of them.

“When you crawled out of the hot tub after that bottle-” Natalie pressed, “-on your hands and knees like that.” She caught Lisa’s ass again in her palm, squeezing until her fingertips pushed slightly into the cleft. “This cute little ass was bouncing around for all of us to see.”

Lisa gasped, catching her lip between her teeth. Her eyes fluttered when she pictured how she must’ve looked. “I bet they were eating it up,” she croaked out in a husky voice. “Probably picturing taking me right there, watching me crawl and thinking how easy it would be.”

Natalie’s jaw tightened, the words sparking both a thrill and a slight pang of jealousy. She spanked her once more, coming down on the exposed side she could reach due to the wall behind her.

“And you like knowing they thought about that, don’t you?”

“About them fucking me there on the pool deck?” Lisa asked and quickly nodded. “One of them holding me in place by my hips while the other shoved himself in my mouth. Both of them watching my ass in the air as I give in.”

Natalie’s hand slid between her cheeks, then pressed lower, as if testing. Lisa stiffened and her body jerked, though her voice carried on. “Yeah… they wanted it. They wanted to split me open, one behind, one in front…”

Natalie felt the tension building in her, even though she said nothing and didn’t try to pull away. She eased her hand forward, abandoning the probe. Her palm cupped Lisa’s mound instead, covering her fully, and her middle finger easily slipped between the saturated lips when she applied the slightest pressure.

Lisa gasped and her body relaxed again, humping instinctively against Natalie’s hand. “Fuck, Nat…” she whimpered. “You know I’m yours, even if they were imagining me.”

Natalie leaned in, catching her lips in an urgent kiss. “As long as you know. They can imagine but that’s all they get.”

Lisa’s lips curved against Natalie’s, breaking the kiss with a shaky snicker. “You should’ve seen their faces when you bent over,” she teased back, getting the words out while she could. “Both of them were staring at your ass like they’d never seen one like it before. I don’t think they could believe one as nice as yours was, right there in front of them.”

Natalie tightened her grip on Lisa’s mound, sliding fingers through her slit and dragging another gasp from Lisa.

The expression on Lisa’s face was wicked and her brow twitched in response to Natalie’s fingers. “And when I smacked your ass while you were bent over…? You should’ve seen their faces then. It was like they couldn’t believe I’d actually done that. I bet they were both imagining what it would’ve been like to get to do that.”

Natalie’s other hand squeezed and kneaded at Lisa’s cheek. The memory replayed in her head, hearing the unexpected sound of the smack echoing in the night. For a moment it tangled with something else: the muffled cracks she’d heard from Aiden’s room, and that blonde girl’s high-pitched squeal. Her own thighs had squeezed tightly around her hand as she pictured it. Even later, with Matt’s hand coming down at her urging, she’d been thinking of Aiden.

“I’ll admit, it was exciting when I realized I was pointing straight at them and you smacked my butt.” Her lips brushed Lisa’s temple.

Lisa hunched into her hand. “So you liked teasing them with your perfect ass?” she probed, but didn’t wait for an answer. “God, Nat, you have no idea what all of that did to me.” Her hips rolled harder, grinding down in time with Natalie’s ministrations. “When his girlfriend came, I couldn’t stop thinking about both of them watching me as I crawled for that bottle.” Her voice caught on a broken moan.

Natalie readjusted her fingers, spreading Lisa open with her index and ring fingers before using her middle finger to circle her clit. Lisa pressed her head against the tiled wall.

“Tell me,” Natalie pushed, nipping at her ear. “Tell me what you wanted.”

“You,” Lisa gasped. “I wanted you to bend me over right there and make me cum while they watched- Fuck-” Her words dissolved into another cry as Natalie’s fingers worked faster, now pushing inside her.

Natalie held her steady, one hand now on her chest, trapping her against the wall as her other hand relentlessly drove into her. Lisa writhed against her, causing her little body to twist and her mouth to fall open as she climbed the wall.

Natalie leaned in to whisper in her ear. “Cum for me. Right here. Nobody else, just me.”

Lisa’s body began to tense up, and her thighs trembled as Natalie’s fingers drove into her. They plunged inside her quickly, then smeared her natural lube over the swollen bud at the top, before plunging back inside and continuing to smack her clit with her palm with every thrust of her two digits.

The first sharp cry came out of Lisa in a strangled groan that was muffled as she bit down on her own hand. It moved into broken whimpers as the waves kept coming.

“Fuck, Nat, your fingers-” she squealed between gasps. “So good. God. So fucking good…”

Natalie curled her fingers inside her, dragging across that tender spot that made Lisa’s whole body jolt and her walls fluttered hard around the intrusion. She pressed her mouth to Lisa’s neck, biting down just enough to make her whine, then kissed the mark she had left.

Lisa’s hips bucked helplessly, grinding into her hand. “Don’t stop, please, don’t you dare stop-” Her nails dug into Natalie’s shoulders, practically clawing at her while the orgasm wracked her in pulsing waves.

Natalie adjusted her hold, firmly palming her clit with continued pressure, letting her grind as her fingers fucked into it. The sensation was wet and hot, clenching and oozing around her hand. It was intoxicating.

Lisa’s whimpers began to turn into sounds almost like sobs, her body convulsing as Natalie refused to let up. “Y-you’re ruining me. Fuck. You’re gonna break my little pussy!”

Natalie pressed her mouth over Lisa’s gasping lips, stifling her protests as her palm rubbed harder against the throbbing bud. “Cum for me again,” she whispered into Lisa’s sagging mouth, tongue tracing over her teeth. “I want to see you have another.”

Lisa answered with a strangled moan, her whole body seizing as she concentrated. Moments later, another spasm gripped her. She clung to Natalie as though she’d fall without her, riding out the tremors until she finally collapsed forward, resting her forehead against Natalie’s collarbone.

She slumped against her, trembling, exhaling hot bursts of air against Natalie’s skin. Her chest rose and fell in quick, shallow gasps as the last shocks rippled through her body, leaving her small frame twitching against Natalie’s hold.

Enjoying the story? You can support my work on Patreon where this story is currently through chapter 144 at the time of this posting. Happy reading!