More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 19 by Alostsoul Alostsoul

How do you guys spend the rest of the night?

Movie then sleep

“Meh I’m kinda tired.” Harper says yawning, and stretching.

“Oh come on you want to go to sleep already?”

Amy crosses her arms, and gives Haper a look of disapproval.

“Honestly I’m kinda drained to...” Riley says yawning as well.

“What really, guys we can’t go to bed there’s still so much time left in the night!” Amy says pouting.

She looks over between you and Ava, hoping that the two of you will object to Riley, and Harper’s stances on the matter. Yet just by looking she can tell that the two of you aren’t exactly up for any strenuous activities. Though Amy really should have expect this as the two of you were the most active this night what with fucking, and being edged together. With a vibe in the room being very fatigued, Amy frowns as she still had so many things she wanted to do with every one. Her mind a boundless source of energy, that last thing she can consider right now was winding down. Then her face lit up, and you can practically see the light bulb above her head.

“Oh I know then we could all watch a movie together till we fall asleep come on Haper help me get the second couch from up stairs.” Amy says excitedly

She then grabs Harper by the wrist, and some how starts pulling the taller, stronger up the stairs behind her.

“Wooahhh hey hold up.” Harper says as she’s yanked up to the top of the stairs by Amy.

With the two girls gone you, Riley, and Ava are left alone together.

Riley’s eyes flick between both you and Ava’s naked bodies. Eyeing your new chastity cages, she smirks, then gives a nod both of amusement and approval.

Ava looks away, her ears burning with embarrassment. She stills up, and tucks her knees into her chest trying to obscure her cock and breasts from Riley with out trying to make it look to blatant that’s what she’s doing. There’s a deep prickling of embarrassment, as she feels like a dog who had just been put in it’s place, and collared. The steel chastity cage between her legs most certainly the collar in this analogy. Still the humiliation wasn’t really to distressing to her. She had been a naughty, and she had gotten what she deserved. To her it was erotic to act out, and then have others put in her place. The little push, and shove of the play, the give and take of it all, it was just such a turn on to her. Still as much as she got off on it that didn’t mean she didn’t feel the burning embarrassment any less.

“C-come on don’t stare at me Riley.” Ava says in soft meek voice.

“Heh, was just thinking that Amy was right, that cage would go well with your stage outfit.” Riley chuckles.

Ava looks down, suppressing a frown as she tries not to give a reaction to Riley’s teasing. A tinge or defiance and pride still within Ava still urging her to try and save a little face here. Riley sees right through Ava though, and can clearly sense the embarrassment she was holding in. Riley doesn’t press her any further though, her friend was already tamed for now so there’s no point in humbling her further. Instead she just shakes her head and, taking pity on her friend kicks Ava’s clothes over to her.

“Thanks...” Ava says as she starts to redress herself while keeping her self covered as much as possible.

“Yeah no worries.”

Riley then turns her gaze over to you noticing you looking at her with an expecting look.

“Eh, sorry Doug I’m sure Amy would say the penalty from the truth or dare still stands so I can’t give you your clothes back.” Haper says sounding genuinely sympathetic.

“O-oh right....” You say.

She then shakes her head and shrugs.

“Sorry nothing I can do about that.”

Dang it, you completely forgot about the penalty you had received during the little truth or dare game. This sucks as your body is really starting to strain and ache in this sitting position. Yet you don’t want to just have your body out on display for the girls. All naked... and exposed.... your cock shamefully locked up..... Just thinking about it makes your cheeks turn pink, and your cock hard for reasons you can’t explain. Maybe..... NO, no way in hell are going to willing expose yourself it’s too embarrassing!!! So you stay put, huddled up with your knees to your chest trying to cover your now caged cock as best you can.

“Hmmm.” Riley looks you over, seeing your visible discomfort.

She decides that having you curled up on the floor for the rest of the night was no good. So she comes up with an idea. She then trots over to Amy’s bed and snatches the blanket of the mattress. Then trotting beck over to you drapes the blanket around you, covering you in the warm fabric.

“Hehe Amy said you couldn’t wear clothes but I don’t think a blanket really counts right?” Riley says beaming a friendly smile as she pats you on the back.

Now with a bit of modesty you relax into a less tense sitting position. Not putting any more stress on your body you let out a relieved sigh.

“Hmph, why does he get a out of his punishments...” Ava grumbles quietly to herself as she finishes redressing.

You then start to hear some rattling coming from the the top of the stairs.
Then you hear Amy go “oh shit!” before some loud banging, as you, Riley, and Ava all look up to see a couch careening down the stairs like a run away train. The thing’s front leg then hit the bottom step, bouncing upwards into the air, and landing with a crash on the bottom floor.

The sound of it slamming down makes all three of jump, as the couch now sits at the bottom of the steps.

“Well it’s down Amy, just like you wanted.” Harper says casually as she crawls over the couch in the door way.

“Oh crap, oh crap, oh crap, nothings broken right, my parents are already gonna be mad about the closet, I can’t have this broken too.” Amy says following Harper over the couch and immediately examining the it for damage.

“Well maybe if you had just let me guide it down from the bottom, everything would have been smooth sailing.” Harper said leaning against the other couch, (the one that didn’t just go flying down the stairs).

“Well I didn’t want it to crush you if it was to heavy.” Amy retorts as she checks each of the legs.

“Like that old thing could be considered heavy.” Harper snorts.

“Well then why did you drop it?” Amy says with a bit of snark.

“Obviously because I couldn’t get a good grip on it, which is why I said I should be under it guiding it down.” Harper says, annoyed as she rolls her eyes.

“Well what ever, it doesn’t look like anything’s broken so it’s all good.” Amy wipes her forehead relived that at least her parents can’t be mad at her for that.

She then notices you with the blanket.

“Hey! Doug..... what do you think your doing?” Amy says, hands on her hips with atone of parent who just caught their child in the cookie jar.

“He’s just getting things ready for us, you know I thought we could all snuggle up under a blanket while we watched the movie together.” Riley says coming up with an excuse to save your bacon.

Amy’s expression quickly changes as soon as she hears this. Her eyes now sparkling, Amy looks filled with excitement. Such a fun form of bonding, Amy can’t believe that she hadn’t thought up such a fun sleep over activity here self. After all it was one of the classic girl things. You know that thing that girls friends love to do together. That skin on, skin warmth shared with good friends, a soft blanket, and a entertaining movie. The idea enthralls her so much that you technically getting out of your punishment completely slips her mind.

“That’s a kickass idea!” Amy enthusiastically looks from face to face in the room, like she’s already picturing all of you snuggled up together all cozy like

“Wait so we’re going to sit all together then why did we even bother bringing this down?” Harper asks gesturing to the other couch.

“Oh it’s fine we need the couch down here for when we go to sleep anyways.” Amy says dismissively.

Her face then suddenly perks up.

“Hold on we need popcorn I’ll go make some while you guys go pick out a movie.”

Then Amy dashes up the stairs leaving the rest of you without another word. Haper just shakes her head and face palms. Though she then perks up as she looks over to Ava, a small smirk starting to crawl across Harper’s face as she does. Ava tense up, suddenly feeling like a rabbit in the predatory gaze of a fox, Harper then strolls over to Ava, placing a hand on her shoulder. Her grip being soft enough to not hurt, yet firm enough to let Ava know she wasn’t going anywhere. Ava holds her breath in waiting in anticipation for Haper’s next move.

“Heh, how’s that cage on ya, nice and snug?” Harper asks before darting a hand under and grabbing hold of Ava’s caged cock.

“Ah, Harper...”

“Harper...? Harper what Av? speak up I can’t hear you.” Harper says as she shakes Ava’s cage around, the lock making an audible rattling against the cage as she does.

“D-don’t touch me there your gonna make it growwww.” Ava whines, a bit more defiance in her voice then Haper cared for.

Well now, she’ll see to that little attitude right away.

“No, I think do what ever I want.” Harper says moving her fingers to play with Ava’s balls

Harper starts to softly fondle Ava’s balls. Her hand surprisingly soft hand for her tough exterior. Ava almost tries to get away, yet Harper simple tightened her grip on her shoulder. With the hold now iron clad it was clear Ava wasn’t going any where. All she could do was make cute little noises while being manhandled by Harper’s devilishly pleasurable hand. In no time at all Ava is straining against her chastity cage. The metal bars of the chastity cage ruthless in their confinement of her cock. The whole time Harper keeps her gaze on Ava’s face drinking in every little detail of emotion as she continues to use gentle little touches as she draws out Ava’s arousal. Working her body with so little effort Harper is like a puppet master. While Ava is helplessly all tied up in her strings dancing the way Haper wants whether she wants to or not.

“S-s-top Harper.”Ava begs as her swelling penis continues to painful trying to expand in its cage.

Harper then pulls Ava close, moving the hand on her shoulder down to her hips. Their faces are now only a few inches apart, Ava can feel Harper’s breath on her cheek.

“Beg me.” Harper speaks in a tone which gives no room for negotiation.

“P-please...” Ava begs in a **** whisper.

“Not good enough...” Harper then plunges her tongue in to Ava’s mouth.

A squeak of surprise from Ava turns mute as Harper’s lips press against her’s before she can make a sound. Still fondling her Harper begins to aggressively kiss Ava. Using her mouth like her own personal play thing, Harper is remorseless, exploring ever inch of Ava’s taste as she makes out with her. The whole scene is damn captivating , so much so that you space out a bit just watching the two of them. Then Riley snaps her fingers right I front of your face, and that brings you back to reality.

“Hey while there doing their thing you want to get cozy?” Riley asks grinning down at you.

“S-ure.”You say a bit blindsided by the offer.

Riley then reaches out her hand, and as you take it she her helps you up to your feet. Then still holding your hand she guides you over to the couch. As you walk with her you feel the little weight of the chastity cage between your legs. It’s a strange sensation to be sure, though hopefully you’ll get used to it during the week. Riley then sits on the far left side of the couch, pulling you with her into an embrace as she does. Quickly she worms her way inside the blanket, and you feel her clothed body press against you naked one.

“So whaddya think of band?” Riley asks casually like she’s isn’t holding you in her arms.

“Oh umm, you guys are all pretty cool it’s nice to meet you guys.” You say shifting ever so slightly, the fabric of Riley’s clothings tickling a little as you do.

Man she feels so warm. The rhythmic pattern of her breathing. The pleasant fragrance she gives of. It just feels so good to be cradled in her arms. She doesn’t show any shyness either nonchalantly letting her boobs press against the side of your back as she keeps talking.

“Huh, no I mean the music what’d you think of our songs?” Riley asks.

“Oh, well Amy showed me here guitar skills, an she sounded pretty good.”

“Wait you mean she didn’t actually play you any of our songs?” Riley says with a look of surprise.

“Well in her defense we kinda were um uh-.”

“Busy, Or getting busy should I say?”Riley cuts you off giving you a wink.

You nod.

“Yeah I know still super lame that she didn’t show you any of our music It’s pretty good.” Riley then fishes her phone out of her pocket.

She taps it a few times, then some music starts playing. Fast paced guitar, and drums
immediately blitz your ear your hearing. Then suddenly a high pitched shriek cuts though both instruments, as they stop for a second then start up a rhythm, as the singer starts to sing.

“Black heart, burned bones, ripped straight though my skull, Skelton of fire!”

Then another voice joins in.

“Bright light called hope, calling me home, wings from a far.”

“That’s me.” Riley said proudly.

“Your a singer in the band?”

“Hell yeah, well technically I’m a back up singer, our lead girl is Scarlet she does most of the vocal work, but I play a couple supporting instruments as well when ever we need some one, one of our songs I even play a piano.”

“You bring a piano on stage?”

“One of those electric ones duh, we aren’t bringing some ivory piece on stage just for one song, besides it would clash with our image.” Riley says.

Riley then stops the song and puts her phone back in her pocket.

It feels kinda awkward having a conversation like this, being held like this. Still Your interested in this band the girls all have, your taste in music weren’t exactly main stream but, you’ve never heard of a band quite like this.

“So your lead singer Scarlet um, what is she like?” You ask trying to not sound like your to privy for the details.

“Oh right you haven’t meet Scarlet, well she’s probably the biggest personality in the whole group.” Amy says seeming like she’s trying to choose her words carefully.

She then grins, and seems to have a Ah fuck it look on her face.

“She’s also a bit of prick, likes to always think she’s the leader when really this band is in it’s heart a group, no one is more important then any one else.” Riley seems to take a more genuine tone when talking about the band as whole, despite her trying to sound nonchalant you can tell it’s something she truly holds dear.

You also get the feeling this Scarlet person might be a source of contention in the group, and not in the same vain of Ava’s brattyness that is mostly is done just to have some one show her whose boss. You get the feeling that scarlet is a potential source of genuine conflict with in the group, perhaps that’s why she didn’t show for the sleep over. After all you did her the girls talking about how she was probably out fucking. Anyone who would rather be out on a booth call then spend time with all their friends especially when all the girls seem to be so close, doesn’t really give off the best impression. Then you hear steps on the stairs, and Amy emerges from the bottom with a big bucket of popcorn.

“All right then let’s start this thing.” Amy says enthusiastically pumping her fist in the air.

“Do you even have a movie in mind?” Harper says walking over to the couch with Ava clinging on to her arm like a stereotypical couple.

You notice Harper also has a small smudge of Ava’s lipsstick on her lower lip, making you wonder what the two of them were doing. What ever it was they seem all lovey dove now, as Harper sits on the end of the other side of the couch with Ava snuggling up next her. Haper then puts an arm around Ava and, Ava in return hugs Harper’s waist. This is a such stark comparison to how you’ve seen them interact so far. Perhaps their relationship goes a little bit further then just bdsm buddies.

Amy then takes her seat in between you all, and the blanket is spread around so that every one is under it.

“So what’re the movie You got Amy anything good?” Harper asks.

“You’ll see it’s one of the greatest of all time is all I’ll say.” Amy says.

Amy the flips though a few menus, and selects a movie called Upon A Midnight Rose. The movie starts and it opens to an old black and white title card with stylized letters. The film then shows an establishing shot of a city full of people going about their day. The cars, advertisements, and style of dress, look straight out of the 1950s.

“Where did you find this Amy, it looks ancient.” Harper says.

“Shh shut up it’s awesome give it a chance.” Amy retorts to Harper’s snarky remark.

The story starts out following our main character a mid twenties boyish Private eye. As the movie carries on it tells the tale of a young 18 year old private eye going across to Europe where he is tasked with solving a series of mysterious events taking place around an old castle. From there the P.I. then is captured by the countess of the castle, and she tries to break him and, turn him into one of her many personal plaything.

There are a bunch of sex scenes especially bdsm scenes. However it’s not just plain old smut, as the story turns in to a well written battle of wits, will, and desires. As both the P.I. and the Countess attempt to seduce the other. Both try to sway the other to their side, the Countess trying to turn the P.I. into her submissive toy, and the P.I. trying to convince the Countess to reveal her secrets, and perhaps let him, and the other men under here control go.

During a few of the scenes you feel cock trying to get hard in it’s cage. It swells, and pushes again it’s plastic pink prison, almost as if it’s screaming to be freed. For most of the movie your constantly trying to keep your arosual, yet you can’t seem to turn yourself away from the truly hot stuff on the tv. Amy instantly takes notice of you struggling with the cage, and sees it fit to subtle tease, and touch you though out the movie. Leaning into you so that you were now sandwiched between both her, and Riley. Amy gently rubs and, pinches and, pulls at your nipples, when even something hot was on screen. She also fondle your cock as well, massaging, and caressing your balls to get you even more worked up. Occasionally you have to stifle little girly moans, as you just couldn’t help but vocalize because of the teasing. This makes your cheeks go hot with embarrassment as Amy made you dance perfectly up her tune, almost mirroring the situation between the P.I. and the Countess on screen.

It also doesn’t help that Riley is still holding you tightly, not letting you even shift position to try at get away from Amy’s tortuous, roaming hands. Though it doesn’t seem like Riley is intentionally trying to assist Amy. Riley simple seems to be so engrossed by the movie that she doesn’t even notice what’s happing between you and Amy. You could probably ask her to let you go but... No! What if she wants to join in on the teasing instead? Better to just tough it out rather then risk Riley getting involved. Its a hard though as by the third act of the movie pre is dripping from the head of your penis, and the tightness of he cage is really getting to you. Amy doesn’t let up either actually increasing the torment as the movie draws to a close. At the end of the movie the P.I. gets close enough to the Countess that he finds outta at she actually an ancient goddess. She has spent centuries collecting men she desires and brainwashing them to stay with here as slaves for ever.

However the brave hero is able to make the Goddess fall in love with him and in return for letting all the other men free, and never pursuing any other. In exchange the P.I. selflessly offers to stay with the Goddess for all eternity as her lover, and servant. Though a heroic sacrifice non the less it’s not so bad for P.I. he has fallen in love with th goddess and would love no to big more to stay with her forever. Finally movie finally ends with the young P.I., and the Goddess laying naked together in a bed of roses where P.I. offers him self up to the Goddess and the screen fade to black as the two intertwine bodies with each other.

“Soooo whatch you guys think?” Amy asks hoping every one thought the movie was fantastic.

“It was fucking awesome Amy, thanks for showing it to us I never would have checked out some old stuff like this.” Riley says giving Amy a thumbs up.

“Y-Yeah I really appreciated all of the actors performances, and the hero really was the pinnacle of youthful determination, and a bit of charming nativity that was a really good match for the countess’s domineering, and enticing demeanor.” You said your artist eye showing.

“Heh I knew you would appreciate it Doug, for one reason or another.” Amy says that last part as she grabs your caged cock, and shakes it around a little bit grinning.

“Harper how did yo- oh.” Amy turns to see Harper and Ava had dozed off during the movie.

The two of them were snuggled up cutely, Ava sitting in Harper’s lap as Harper held her in her arms. Ava sat snoring away with using Harper’s breasts as a soft pillow.

“We should get to bed to.” Riley yawns.

“Yeah your right...” Amy admits yawning her self.

The three of you then carefully slip out from under the blanket as to not disturb, the sleeping pair.

“They look real cozy huh.” Riley says eyeing the two.

“Yeah sleeps always better with the comfort of a warm body with you.” Amy says matter a factory.

She then turns to you and Riley.

“You guys want to do what there doing, my beds big enough for all three of us...” Amy says in a sing song voice, as she points her thumb to the her bed behind her.

“I’d be down for that “ Riley stretches her arms above her head.

“I- um okay.” You start to feel your cock hardening again.

“Great!” Amy then in one smooth motion flings her bra, and shirt off.

“Ummm Amy that’s not what I meant when I said I want to go to bed, I’m tireeeeed.” Riley groans thinking her friend has more “active” activities in mind.

“Pfffttt don’t you know sleeping together is best naked, no cloth just bare skin.” Amy says stripping off her bottoms as well.

Now naked she gives a Riley an expecting look.

“Sounds like BS, but Finnneeeee.....” Riley sighs as she undresses quickly.

She plops all her clothes next to her, and you see her penis for the first time. She has a thin cock that looks to be just slightly bigger then Amy’s. Above it is a noticeable lack of pubic hair, which makes you wonder if she waxes it.

“There happy now?” Riley asks giving a little stylish twirl of her naked body for Amy.

“Yup.” Amy has a beaming smile and gives Riley a thumbs up.

You cock is again hard as can physically be in the cage as you look at both the naked girls infront of you. You have no idea how your going to get to sleep when there like... like that! Amy then grabs one of the spare blankets, and all three of you climb into bed together. Immediately Riley and, Amy sandwich you between them, and you find your self bing spooned from both sides. Riley in front of you, and Amy behind you. They are so warm as they wrap their arms and legs around you, leaving the three of you a tangled mess of limbs. Your heart was beating a mile a minute right now. You never in a million years thought today you would end up in bed with not one but TWO sexy naked girls. Their tits against you, their cocks just a few inches away from your body. God damn it your getting so hard! Though the girls don’t seem to notice, actually starting to settle in for sleep.

“Night.” Riley says giving you a kiss on the nose as she shuts her eyes.

“Nighty night.” Amy says who sits up briefly only to kiss you on the cheek.

Then both the girls seemingly settle in for sleep.

Do you actually sleep, or does some funny business go on?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)