Movie Night at Erika's 2 - Now That's a Dilemma

The movie is fine. It's a simple, entertaining slasher but nothing more than that. A group of very stereotypically American teenagers are being hunted by a shapechanging doppelganger and the first few have already died in a variety of stupid ways.

You and Zoey are lounging next to each other on Erika's couch while she herself sits separately in a comfortable armchair. As she usually tends to do, Zoey has a arm around your shoulder and you're leaning into her side. The movie is quite fast-paced, so none of you talk all that much except for in moments in which the characters behave exceptionally stupid. Like when two of them are off fucking while the doppelganger brutally mauls someone to death. Then another character hears the OBVIOUSLY overly violent bashing sounds and somehow figures that must be the couple banging and goes to take a peek. Like, the perversion fits the character – that's essentially his only trait – but no one in his remotely right mind would mistake those sounds for sex. That poor girl is hysterically screaming and crying for help. Also, the entire time, the fucking two somehow don't hear a thing.

Regardless, despite the ridiculousness, the movie is quite enjoyable for what it is. After a while new characters are introduced which suggests it's going to go on for a while longer, so you make yourself more comfortable. You sling a leg over Zoey's lap and really nuzzle into her side now. It's a rather strong display of affection in the presence of Erika, but the girl has literally seen and heard you banging. She'll live. She does glance over to you two quite regularly though. Whenever your eyes would meet, however, she quickly turns back towards the screen.

The movie goes on and it's honestly turning into low-key porn at this point. While friend after friend is getting decapitated, dismembered or otherwise eviscerated, that one couple just keeps boning everywhere. It's not just one continuous scene, either. They were fucking in that upstairs bedroom first, but the next time we see them, they're suddenly rawdogging in the woods outside. Next, girlie's getting her face fucked on the docks by the lake. After that, they're on the backseat of the broken down car the group had earlier. And the entire time, every single other character in this movie is getting annihilated in a baffling amount of truly absurd and grotesque ways. Like, the gore is absolutely excessive. There's a pretty gnarly sequence in which a character's spine is ripped out and used as a flail. Then in the midst of that, the camera cuts to the two fuck rabbits.

Truth be told though, the (very many) sex scenes are genuinely moody and actually quite hot. They might seem like they belong to an entirely different project, but that's some pretty aesthetic stuff. By the third sex scene, the three of you have kinda stopped joking about it. Actually, you're pretty sure, you can feel Zoey's hardon under your leg that you have draped across her lap. Also, you catch more and more of Erika's glances at the pair of you. In a presumable lack of wariness, she eventually doesn't react fast enough to avoid you looking back and catching her.

She then quickly turns away, but you're pretty sure she's blushing. Erika. Erika's blushing. You're not sure you've ever seen this girl blush in the whole - what - 13 years or so that you've known her. She's rarely ever genuinely embarrassed since she's always been the type of person who felt pretty content in her own skin, just simply too relaxed to be self-conscious. So something about either the movie or the way you and Zoey are snuggling is apparently... hold on, is she horny??

Right as that suspicion takes form in that mind is when she suddenly stands up from her armchair and clears her troat. "I'll... I'll be right back." she mutters and walks off without further comment. Zoey and you exchange a puzzled look.

"Is it just me or is she a bit weird today?" asks Zoey.

"Nope, definitely not just you." you confirm and nod.

"You know... I knew quite a few girls in my day..." Zoey begins, seemingly pondering whether or not to say what's on her mind.

"Quite an understatement, but yes, go on." you interrupt her.

"And, you know, I obviously know her from... back then. So this might sound weird but... I think the girl's bricked up." she theorises in a strangely cautious manner, like careful not to offend you as Erika's long-term friend.

"Honestly, yeah. I've never seen her like that." you admit.

"Well, I did and that really reminded me of that."

"You think the flick got her so worked up like that?" you ask sceptically. Like, the sex scenes are surprisingly good and all, but at the end of the day it's still just a cheap slasher.

"Pff, a bit, maybe." Zoey dismisses with a chuckle. "But I'm not sure you'd like the actual reason."

"Oh boy. Come on, hit me."

"Yeahh, she totally wants to fuck." Zoey claims, not dropping her voice one bit.

"Oh my god, keep it down!" you hiss back at her, throwing a quick glance towards the door. "And what do you mean 'she wants to fuck'? You think she wants a threesome with us?"

"I mean I'm not sure about that, but she definitely wants to fuck me. Trust me, I know when girls get in the mood." Zoey explains, clearly amused by the situation.

"Well, is that all that surprising? Like, you've done... stuff already." you reply.

"No, of course not, but I didn't expect her to mask it this badly."

"Yeah, I'm actually with you on that. The cleavage too, that's so weird for her." you agree, glancing towards the direction she disappeared.

"Well, she prolly had some mid ass sex for a while and now that her dude's gone..."

"Now she's pent up."

"Yep."

"Huh." you huff and think, actually pausing the movie at last, mid passionate 69-ing. "So what do we do now? Do we even do anything?"

"Well, I'd be down for a fuck, get it outta her system." Zoey replies, nonchalantly reaching over to grab a cucumber and chomp down on it.

"Oh yes, how I'd love to have my girlfriend fuck my best friend." you deadpan back at her.

"I'm just staying. She'll prolly carry that around for a while if nothing happens."

"Hold on, nothing's stopping her from getting a new guy."

"Hah, yeah, sure. If that's all she wants." Zoey laughs, earning a questioning look from you. "Okay, let me put you in her shoes. Imagine you get this" - she points down at her lap - "but then you gotta put up with bad dick for two or three years. Would you wanna have some average shit after all that wait or this?"

"Damn, you can be so cocky sometimes, it's crazy." you snicker and shake your head. She's got a point though. Zoey's good. Really good, as it's well established. And from the thankfully little information that you've got about her and Erika's past adventures, there's little doubt that your good old friend is quite the fan as well. Hm, maybe this is an issue after all.

"What? That's the only thing I'm good at, I'm not gonna be humble about it." Zoey shrugs.

"Mhm, sure. Lemme think." you shush her and take a moment. Would you be okay with having Zoey fuck Erika? That's the big underlying question here. Ever since you've learned about their past and seen how hard Denise flirted with her, you sort of dismissed the prospect of your partner having sex with your closest friends, but there's a serious dilemma here. With Denise it's just her typical antics, fuck that. But Erika? Like Zoey said, she got to experience how good Zoey is in bed. Then she had an unhappy relationship for a few years with obviously bad sex. Now Zoey has re-entered her life through you. And she's gonna be here for a while. Like, you're not one to say forever, but you don't plan on ending this banger relationship with Zoey anytime soon, nor do you want to strictly separate Zoey time and time with your friends, including Erika. 'To get it out of her system'... would a one time thing be that consequential? Maybe it could be that easy, having them bang just this once and everything would go back to normal afterwards. They're all reasonable adults, especially Erika - normally. You'd definitely all agree on never ever telling Denise about it or you'd not only ever hear the end of it, but Denise would practically DEMAND her own ride on the Zoey train.

"Damn, you're thinking hard." Zoey remarks, snapping you out of your thoughts.

"I am." you reply and lean forward, putting your chin in your hands. "Once. We could maybe do this once."

"Sweet."

"But I'm NOT gonna be the one telling her."

"Tell me what?" suddenly sounds Erika's voice from the door. Oh shit.

"Ah, n-nothing. We were just talking about the movie." you quickly wave her off. Zoey looks back and forth between you and Erika and grins.

"No, we were not." she says and lifts your leg off her lap to stand up. "I'll explain, but not here." she tells Erika and walks up to her. Well, fuck. That's what you get for saying you don't wanna tell her. Like, you still don't want to literally offer your best friend a fuck with your girlfriend, but also damn. Zoey's really not wasting time here.

"Uh, wha-" Erika begins, but is cut off when Zoey guides her back out the room.

"Don't worry, it's cool." you can hear Zoey say before her cap-covered head peaks back into the living room.

"What the hell??" you mouth quietly at her, a bewildered expression on your face. Zoey responds with a thumbs up, then her head is gone again.

"What the fuuuuck." you sigh, looking over at Ulisses, who's busy licking his paws. "They're just gonna talk, right?" you ask but Ulisses doesn't respond. He's a cat, he can't talk.