Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by GladiusBonus GladiusBonus

Who fucks her where?

Melissa and Claire fuck your girlfriend

The girls return with 2 dildos, a cheap-looking green one, and a dark large one, both strapons. "That one's mine," giggles Claire as she grabs the black one. Melissa, takes hold of Doe, her 38DD breasts pressing against Doe's back, as she straps on her generic dildo and penetrates your girlfriend's ass. As Doe lets out a soft moan, Claire immediately thrust her oversized strapon into your girlfriend's vagina and takes hold of Doe's 36D breasts.

"UHH" moans Doe as you watch lustfully. "John!" Doe grunts, fighting back the moans of immense pleasure as Claire takes another big thrust. "These fake cocks pale in comparison to your flawless tool, so smooth and suckable." A little bit of precum moistens your tip and you are filled with immense love for this girl, who is treating you to the best day of your life.

Amanda, noticing the desire in your eyes, takes hold of your hands and places them on her ass cheeks. She then begins to sway from side to side, saying that while Melissa and Claire handle Doe, she will happily be your fuck toy. Taking this as your cue, you pull Amanda towards you and sit her down on your lap. She happily hops onto your dick and begins to ride you, moaning incoherent sounds of fervent bliss.

Noticing that you are now engaging Amanda in intercourse, Doe, breaks free of Claire and Melissa, dashes over to you and passionately kisses Amanda and takes hold of her modestly sized 32C breasts. Amanda, realizing who had just playfully pawned at her breasts, slowly orgasms and hops off you, allowing Doe to take her rightful place as queen of your cock. You begin to fuck Doe like never before, newfound passion burning inside of you. As you rail her tight pussy, she calls you things you'd never heard her say before, such as her dream fucker. Meanwhile, Claire and Melissa, disappointed about not finishing Doe but intrigued by the passion of your thrusts and flails, and shocked at both Doe's and Amanda's euphoric states both race towards you and stand by your head. "Wait!" exclaims Amanda, "let John decide who he wants to join his girlfriend on him." She finishes smirking as she begins to prop up her massive breasts.

Who shall join your girlfriend and you?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)