More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 12 by ZeeRay905 ZeeRay905

What does Natalia choose?

Make Marcie Hungry for Semen

Marcie couldn't believe what was happening. Not only was she topless, on her knees and eagerly suckling a near total strangers cock, but she was enjoying it!

Part of her mind railed against the strange forces controlling her body, and yet, when she saw the head of Roy's cock poking up through her breasts, within licking distance of her tongue, she felt the ability to resist actually doing it. That option was there, she could feel it, like a deeply ingrained muscle memory, though she had never in her life tit-fucked a guy's penis. It was there, but she had a choice whether or not to do it. However, as the penis returned again, and again out of her breasts, her cleavage now getting a little bit slick with Roy's precum, her mouth started to tingle and water. It was the same strange feeling she'd had last night when she had been eating out Natalia's pussy. A deep animal desire to pleasure Natalia with her mouth, yes, but also a change in how her mouth felt on a fundamental level.

It was like the slightest touch to her tongue, the roof of her mouth, her gums, her inner cheeks (even her teeth!) sang along her nerves just as sweetly as the feeling of her own fingers against or inside of her pussy. Like her tongue was a new clit, her lips new labia, the roof of her mouth a new g-spot (her uvula her... cervix? Marcie put an end to that line of analogy before it got truly stupid). And anyway, it was getting harder and harder to think coherently, with Roy's delicious looking cock so close to her mouth. On one particularly firm stroke of her breasts against his cock, the tip of his penis touched her lip - only gently grazing it, but the feeling of this penis touching her lips sent a shudder through her.

It would feel so good to have this penis in her mouth right now! But the strange **** wasn't forcing her, content to have it tantalizingly close and moving in and out of her cleavage.

Finally, she made her decision and began licking at the penis as it appeared. If she had been standing, her knees would have gone out and collapsed her to the floor, so strong was the wave of pleasure that went through her as soon as her tongue touched his cock. At this point, all coherent thought stopped and, after a few more licks, she was giving up on the breast-job and joyously sucking Roy's cock, moaning around this treasure as it slid along her tongue all the way to the back of her throat. Eventually, she felt she absolutely had to reach one hand under her skirt and start masturbating, or go mad with the desire to cum.


With my decision made, I got up from the table and went toward James, who was intensely watching, partly out of disbelief, the blowjob going on at the other end of the living room. I put a gentle hand on his shoulder, which made him startle and look toward me, smiling immediately with self awareness as he saw my amused smile.

"That's uh, quite a sight," he said, trying to be casual and yet still complimentary.

"More of a sight than I was outside?" I pouted coyly, grinding a toe into the carpet. It's hard to pull off coy when you're a tall girl, fortunately, James was taller than me by at least two inches.

"Mm... not quite," he said, barely missing a beat, to which I smiled broadly.

"Thank you. And not just for the compliment, but also for taking care of me out there."

"You're, uh, you're very welcome."

"Do you think I could ask you another favour? Even though you've done so much for me already today and we've only just met?"

"Uhh... sure?"

"Do you think you could let us pleasure your cock as well?"

"Uh...!"

"Please?" I pouted with wide puppy dog eyes. "It would mean a lot to us."

"Um, yeah, okay," he said, bewildered.

Smiling, I led him by the hand over to where Roy was standing and Marcie was kneeling. Squatting down to the left of Marcie, I put a hand on James' hip and positioned him so he was facing Marcie's left side and angled so that, when he got his dick out, it would be within her peripheral vision. Then I helped James unbutton his shorts and coaxed him to pull down his underwear, which he did.

No sooner was James cock out (it was bigger and girthier than Roy's and a lot more than I had counted on!) did Marcie's eyes go wide and she pulled her left hand away from her pussy and toward James' cock, and began stroking it lovingly. She was now pleasuring two cocks simultaneously, with her right hand holding onto Roy's hip for stability.

My plan was simple, Roy would cum first, giving me 20 extra gems for my 40th orgasm achievement, which would mean I would have 60 gems total. Then I would use 50 of those gems to purchase [Hungry for Semen], hopefully giving Marcie the benefits of Roy's load in her tummy, but even if it didn't, when she started sucking James' cock, she definitely would.

It was a foolproof plan!

And then it all went completely wrong.

It all started with my assumption that Roy was going to cum first. I had taken his grunting and sucking in air through his teeth to mean he was close to orgasm. But the cowboy had better stamina than I thought, it seemed, and James, though more "hung" than Roy, had a problem which he had been **** to bring up when I asked him for permission to milk his penis.

Wikipedia defines this problem as follows:

Premature ejaculation (PE) occurs when a person with a reproductively functional set of male genitalia experiences orgasm and expels semen within a few moments of beginning sexual activity and with minimal penile stimulation.

What I saw was, at first, my plan going without a hitch: Marcie sucking off a grunting, moaning cowboy and jacking off a man dressed like he was ready for a day at the beach, and eminent victory at hand for my little scheme. So, getting up, I went back to the dining table to retrieve my phone and prep the purchase of [Hungry for Semen] when, half way to the table, with my back turned to the action, I heard James cry out in orgasmic apology.

"OHGODSORRY...! UUUGNNNN...!"

Spinning around, I saw James unloading an absolute deluge of semen against the side of Marcie's face as she continued to jack him off, using his own seed as lubrication. James was arching his back, his knees pressed together, arms flailing in the air beside him.

So, of course, like any rational, calm, scientifically minded individual would when an experiment goes off the rails, I panicked.

I panicked hard. Without taking a breath, eyes so wide with panic my vision was blurring at the edges, I snatched up my phone, accepted the 20 gems from the achievement menu, opened Marcie's profile page and purchased [Craves Cum on Face] for 40 gems, leaving me with only 20 gems to my name.

Almost no sooner than I had pressed the confirm button for the purchase, Marcie started moaning around Roy's cock with pleasure, almost **** on Roy's meat as she lost control of her rhythm and her breathing when the sensations of pleasure from the cum already on her face started to coarse through her. This is also when Roy started to buck his hips and shake and say things like "Whoaboy! WHOABOY!"

And, sensing what was about to happen (or maybe she just needed to catch her breath?), Marcie pulled Roy's cock out of her mouth and, taking her hand off of Roy's hip, began jerking Roy off over her face. This was done even as her other hand continued to jack off poor hyper-stimulated James, who was losing his shit over Marcie not stopping with the stroking of his dick after he had already cum.

Roy shot a decent load straight at Marcie's face, hitting her between the eyes and coating her eyes, cheekbones, nose and forehead with thick splats and ropes of semen. Roy's load wasn't as big as James' load, but it came at a slower pace, shooting in squirts with each stroke of Marcie's hand rather than the all-at-once deluge of James' cocksplosion. The result was that Roy was better able to evenly frost (glaze?) Marcie's pretty face with cum.

Eventually, with Roy panting, a huge smile on his face, and James biting down on a wadded up bit of his Hawaiian shirt, both men started to lose their erections. Then, first James, then Roy, lost it entirely, their still enlarged but flaccid penises hanging limp in Marcie's hands. And then, the trigger deactivated, and, not seeing any erections in front of her, Marcie stopped stimulating the two cocks, much to James' relief, and her hands immediately began attacking her own pussy. Rubbing her clit with the fingers of one hand and finger fucking herself with the fingers of another, it wasn't long before her body was wracked with an orgasm the left her screaming, back arched and facing the ceiling. And then, besides straightening her back and panting to catch her breath, she was still.

I spent a full thirty seconds watching to see what Marcie would do next, but, as she was sitting on her knees, unmoving, hands clamped against her tummy as she panted for breath, I decided I could leave them alone for a moment, as James' had collapsed into a sitting position on the floor and Roy was leaning against the wall.

I fetched them both a glass of water from the kitchen.

"Thank you, kindly, little filly," said Roy, accepting the water.

James' said nothing, he was panting too hard, but accepted the water gratefully, giving me a thumbs up when he managed to get the glass to his mouth and take a deep gulp.

Back with Marcie, she was holding her hands near her eyes, not touching them, as they were completely covered in layers of off-white, translucent semen. I realized she might be trying to clear the semen away from her eyes to open them, and what a predicament I'd put her in. Immediately I opened the app and found another customization I'd seen earlier:

[Eye Protection] 2 gems
This Custom Girl no longer suffers the effects of cum in her eyes. Semen or vaginal ejaculate will no longer cause her eyes to sting, burn, nor will cum be able to get into her eyes at all, instead dripping harmlessly away from her eyes to an adjacent part of her face, obeying gravity. This protective effect also effects the lenses of eyeglasses, and the coatings on glasses will no longer be damaged or the lenses stained.

Almost immediately after confirming the purchase. Marcie opened her eyes and blinked, her eyelashes protecting her from the cum dripping down her coated eyelids and landing, not in her eyes, but on her upper cheeks.

While I was there, in the app, and since I needed to burn gems anyway before the Custom Challenge was over, I decided to also purchase a 1 gem addon as well, thinking about our security deposit on the apartment.

[No Cum Stains] 1 gem
Cum released by or as a result of the actions of, and any cum released within five feet of, this Custom Girl will neither stain or crust upon carpet, indoor floors, or furniture, and will instead evaporate as it dries, leaving only the pleasant odor of cum in the air. When said cum gets on clothing, it will wash out easily the first time this clothing is washed.

On slightly unsteady feet (I assume her legs might have fallen asleep while on her knees), Marcie stood up, hugging herself, luxuriating in the feeling of the cum almost completely coating her face (certainly completely coating the left side of her face). With a sudden inspiration, I ran to the bathroom to grab a hand mirror and ran back to Marcie to show her. "Look at you!" I cooed, fawning over this young woman with the semen dowsed face.

Marcie gasped and took the offered hand mirror, staring wide eyed into it, forgetting that she was still topless from the tit-job earlier, wearing nothing but her school uniform skirt and cum, having taken her sandals off when she came inside. "This slut... can't believe it!" she said to no one in particular.

"Can't believe what?" I probed.

"This slut's never felt like this before... the... this slut doesn't have the words to describe this feeling! It's like this slut finally recognizes herself for the first time! Mmmf!" She started rubbing one of her breasts. "This slut feels so alive so... so pretty... it..." she shook her head, lost in the sight of her own cum covered face.

Not wanting to cause a narcissus effect, I gently, then more forcefully, pulled the mirror away from her. "Maybe you should eat something? Or have a glass of water?"

"Oh... oh yes. This slut is really hungry all of a sudden." At that, she turned toward the stack of pancakes still on the table and, even though I had not purchased the [Hungry for Semen] customization, licked her lips and the skin around her mouth, taking some of the cum into her mouth and eating it.

Interesting! I thought.


A little dazed, Marcie sat down at the table and buttered and poured syrup on her now-room-temperature pancakes. Part of her realized that these feelings were definitely akin to the other strange compulsions she'd been **** to act out recently, that she was being manipulated by some strange ****, probably connected to this "Gem Ladies" app that she had been told about by the cashier at Hot Topic, but now, part of her also did not care. She felt pretty. No! She felt beautiful. The sight of her face covered in thick, gooey cum gave her the same feeling as seeing a sunset or a breathtaking vista in the mountains. It felt right, it felt arousing, and it radiated a sensation of deep sexual and aesthetic pleasure throughout her that was hard to frame into words.

She had never felt her face was particularly unattractive, if a little plain and narrow, her hair a dull shade of brown (which is why she dyed it black), her eyes yet another boring shade of brown, her features handsome but nothing to write home about (in her eyes, anyway), and, with punky makeup she had discovered in her later years of high school, she had come to enjoy the hard, tough looks she could give herself that was at the same time fierce and glamorous. But seeing her face cum covered and glistening with the white splats and ropes of jizz, she felt sexy and elegant and true to herself.

She had always had a fetish for bukkake, ever since she had discovered what it was (the internet was truly a window to enlightenment!), and even though she had had boyfriends in the past, she had only ever gone down on a guy once before today, and she had swallowed that load, gaining another fetish for cum eating, but never doing it again before moving away from home to attend PCPA two weeks ago.

As she ate her pancakes and drank her coffee (and the water Natalia had brought her), part of Marcie was starting to think: Maybe this isn't so bad...


With Marcie sighing with contentment as she ate, Roy in the bathroom (presumably cleaning himself up and using the toilet after his blowjob) and James no longer on the verge of hyperventilating, I cleaned up my food containers and the bag the food had come in, put Marcie's other shopping bags in her room and plopped myself down in the middle of the sofa, calling James over to sit with me as I browsed Custom Girls for ideas. "Come sit with me. It's gotta be more comfortable than the floor."

Breathing still a bit unsteady, James complied, sitting beside me to my right. Not wanting to see my phone as I played with the app, I pivoted to a lying down position, with my legs across his lap and my head on the opposite (left hand) armrest.

"You so comfy!" I teased. "Do you have a leg or foot fetish or anything?" I asked, curious, now that I had placed my legs and feet across his body in easy reach of his hands.

He shook his head in the negative. "Aw, shame. I was thinking I was being all sexy."

"I think you and Marcie are very sexy."

"Th-thank you," Marcie said from the table. She was sitting with the table between us, facing us as we lounged and she ate. "Also, thank you for your semen, this slut loves it. Sorry if this slut was a bit rough with you."

"It's, uh, it's alright, anytime."

"Just be more assertive next time," I suggested. "When you're done, you can be done. Just take a step back and say no when you want someone to stop."

"I... I sort of liked it. A lot, after I uh... ejaculated. It was... stimulating. Just overwhelming."

"Yeah, it was for this slut too..." Marcie said.


While Marcie and James talked about blowjobs, semen and how much both of them enjoyed the sight of semen on Marcie's face (I got the feeling that facials were one of James' fetishes, but I didn't have a magic app that could confirm that for me), I browsed the Girls in Range list of Custom Girls. I did this because I realized I had another problem. Even as great as Marcie was turning out, already well on her way to becoming the cum-covered blowjob-queen of the school, I still had 17 gems I needed to spend and several achievements which were about to deposit even more gems in my gem bank, increasing the number I needed to spend before my account was maxed out. My current theory was that once the gem bank was exceeded, all the overflow was just lost, meaning that if I wanted my maximum money's worth (as it were) I would need to empty out my bank before it filled up to its maximum limit when the timer for the Custom Challenge ran out.

Primarily, the COLLECTOR OF CUSTOM GIRLS achievement chain looked ready to pop:

COLLECTOR OF CUSTOM GIRLS
Customize at least three different girls: 2/3. 10 GEM AWARD

And with the lowest achievement in the chain giving me 10 gems, who knew how much the next one would give me. As much as I enjoyed the progress I'd made with Marcie in less than a full twenty-four hour period, I wasn't sure I wanted to continue spending gems on her (or Dr. van Olsbracht) exclusively until I had cleared or expanded enough room in my gem bank. So, if I spent any of my windfall of gems on any other, new Custom Girls, I ran the risk of exceeding my gem bank again and losing even more gems. The solution was simple, use a bunch of low level (probably 1 gem tier) purchases to increase my number of Custom Girls to cheese the system while I could, spend a bunch of gems before this afternoon's windfall (I had about until 5pm) and then have a full gem bank again ready for more customization fun before the next Custom Challenge.

It all seemed so simple when I laid it out to myself that I sighed with a deep satisfaction of being on top of everything, at least compared to the earlier debacle with not taking premature ejaculation into account. What's more, James was now casually stroking my recently shaved legs with his hands, tenderly caressing my shins and thighs and knees and the tops of my feet. If I were a cat I would have purred. I enjoyed being casually petted and played with by a bigger, taller person. I also enjoyed how casual James was getting touching a naked girl lying her legs across his lap, how fulfilled Marcie seemed to be casually chatting with someone as she ate with two loads of semen slowly drying on her face.

I honestly could not stop myself from moaning as James caressed me and Marcie smiled through her mask of cum, and I honestly didn't notice when Roy came back into the room. By the time I opened my eyes I saw him sitting at the table with Marcie talking about... something? I was more interested in the fact that my left hand was now toying with my pussy as it had been left idle, and my right hand was holding my phone face down on my tummy. Had I zoned out while enjoying James' (and my own) hands on my body?

Maybe? It had been a very stimulating day.

Looking back at my phone, I sighed blissfully and dedicated myself to getting back to the task at hand: finding girls in range with whom I could cheese the system and get fat stacks of gems!

That's when I saw it. Somehow, suddenly, I had 28/105 gems, not the 17/105 gems I had expected! What the fuck was going on?

Gems Remaining: 28
Total Gems Spent: 113
Lifetime Total Gems: 141
Average Gems Earned/Day: 65.5

Girls Customized: 2
Achievements Unlocked: 13
Orgasm Count: 42

How does Natalia figure out what the fuck is going on?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)