Make Erica a tease...and set her loose on Amy

You and Amy walk up to the car to see Craig and Erica in the back seat deep in conversation. Both Craig and Erica look up as you approach, and start to get out of the car, Erica beaming at you while Craig looks at Amy apologetically.

“Hey cuz! Ready to get going?” asks Erica, leaning on Craig slightly, causing him to blush. You notice a slight damp spot on the seat where Erica had been sitting. You smile inwardly. Apparently teasing Craig was just as enjoyable for her as it was frustrating for him.

“We had a good talk,” you respond, as Amy nods in agreement. You’re still marveling at how much your short conversation had changed and rewritten Amy’s memories, not to mention giving her a burning desire that would never have crossed her mind only a minute ago. “I really am sorry, Amy.” Craig says, holding out his hands.

“N-no, it’s okay.” You couldn’t help but notice how Amy’s eyes trailed quickly down Erica’s body before catching herself. “John had some good points…and I guess in the scheme of things, it wasn’t really that big of a deal after all.” Amy steps forward to hug Craig. “I’m sorry for blowing up at you like that.”

“I’ll give you two a moment.” you say to the couple. As Amy and Craig embrace, you walk over to Erica, gesturing for her to get in the car. “Were you looking for a quickie before brunch, John?” Erica says with a grin. “I don’t think you’ve fucked me in front of your friends before…”

“Tempting idea. I do know how you love to show off your body.” you respond to Erica in a joking manner. “I mean, since you’ve been living at my place you’ve been relentless with me, haven’t you? You love to turn people on. If you think you can get away with it, you try.”

“Guilty.” Erica says with a grin. “God, I can’t count the times I’ve ‘accidentally’ forgotten my underwear around the house when you’re around. I’m so happy I’m your personal slut now. I can still tease you all I want *and* I get to fuck you after.”

“I don’t know how I resisted you all these years,” you say with a chuckle. You idly wonder exactly how much of an impact you’ve made in Erica’s memories of her life, now that she thinks that she’s always been a bit of a slutty exhibitionist streak. “You certainly got me and Craig’s attention. In fact, I think out of us four, the only person you haven’t got lusting after you is Amy.”

“What can I say,” Erica says with a wink. “I know how to get a guy’s attention.”

You nod. “You’re right, getting a guy turned on isn’t really difficult for you. I think it’s time you made it a challenge.”

Erica looks at you with a quizzical expression on her face.

“Why not try getting a girl’s ‘attention’ for once? How about Amy's? She's the only one of us you haven't managed to seduce yet, after all. Wouldn’t that be a fun idea?”

“That *is* a fun idea!” Erica says enthusiastically. “But…why would she pay attention to me in that way? Isn’t she straight?”

“It doesn’t really matter, does it?" You shrug. "Guy or girl, the thought of getting people hot excites you. Besides, it’s supposed to be a challenge, and I know how you are with those. You won’t rest until she’s turned on and you know it’s you who did it. The more she wants you, the more it’ll get you off.”

“Oh, it is so on.” Erica nods, determined. “But I’m supposed to be Craig’s personal slut for the day, right? What if he notices and doesn’t like it?”

“Well then I guess you’ll have to get around that. Be subtle. You’ll definitely have to listen to what he says, but I think despite anything he does, how to get Amy hot for you is always going to be on your mind. Just like thinking about what we’re going to do together after this day is over.” you say with a grin. You suddenly step close and trail a hand down her exposed lower half, running a finger along her pussy.

Erica shudders in response, unconsciously moving her hips into your touch. Her eyes close as she moves against your hand…but you notice they stay just a tiny bit open, looking off somewhere to the side. You follow her gaze to Amy, wide-eyed and watching Erica’s bucking hips with fascination from the other side of the car. She notices you looking at her, and quickly averts her eyes, shame and arousal warring across her face. Craig seems too interested in Erica himself to notice. You wonder how he'd react if he knew Amy and him might be thinking the same thing.

Erica smiles, turning back to you. “Huh, if I didn’t know better I would have thought she was checking me out. Guess I’m off to a good start.”

You smile, gesturing to Craig and Amy. “Shall we get going?”