Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 10 by Insighn122 Insighn122

What's next?

Lily's bump in the night

I laid in bed next to Alex. We were both just listening to the guest room headboard bouncing off the wall. Abby's moans of pleasure filling the house, our minds fixated on what happened, the image of Jake's big cock ploughing into her played on a loop in our heads.

"Sounds like they are having fun" I said with a smirk. I couldn't help but feel proud of myself. If Alex had suspected anything before then he surely wouldn't now. I expected to feel jealous, but the memory of them together, along with the sight of Jake's hard cock penetrating Abby, sent a shiver down my spine.

The thought of Jake's dominant presence and his large cock made me weak in the knees. I wanted more than anything to be taken by him again.

I couldn't shake the image of Jake's massive cock plunging into Abby. It left me craving the feeling of being filled up by him again. The sound of their rhythmic thrusts echoed throughout the house, adding fuel to the fire that burned deep within me. His raw, primal nature had awakened something in me that I didn't even know existed.

Alex's breathing slowed as he drifted off to sleep next to me. I laid listening to Abby's moans from the guest room. The steady thumping of the headboard against the wall. The sighs and gasps. All of it played out in my head as my imagination ran wild. I wondered what kind of position they were in right now. Were they facing each other? Were they doing it doggy style? I knew whatever it was, Jake's massive cock must be stretching Abby wider and wider.

My finger brushed over my pussy, imagining Jake's cock there instead. The feeling sent a wave of arousal coursing through my body.

As I listened to Abby's moans from the guest room, I could not help but fantasize about Jake's massive cock stretching me wide. I imagined how he would fill me, how his hands would grip my hips as he thrust deeper and deeper.

My finger slipped between my lips, rubbing the sensitive nub at its tip. My heart raced, fueled by the desire to feel his powerful cock stretching me, claiming me completely. I could picture Jake's dark eyes, his muscular arms holding me close, the taste of his lips on mine.

I imagined him climbing into our bed and taking me right here, while Alex lay asleep next to us. Trying to keep quiet while he pushed his thickness into me. The thought of Jake's massive cock inside me while my boyfriend slept nearby made me shiver with excitement.

My own movements increased now as I brought myself close to climax. The volume of their encounter increased with my own stimulation. I could hear Jake's low groans and Abby's high pitched cries of ecstasy. The sounds were making my entire body hum with anticipation.

There was a loud cry from Abby and then the sounds stopped altogether. It sounded as though, I thought, he'd fucked her ****. I stopped my own stimulation.

I silently slipped out of bed and headed for the bathroom. As I passed the guest room door I had to fight the urge to open the door and peer inside.

My pussy throbbed with wanton desires, the mere thought of Jake's huge cock filling me made me wet with anticipation. The idea of watching them together drove me insane, but I needed to remain silent and continue to listen.

I sat on the toilet, letting the events of the night wash over me. My body ached with desire, the memory of Jake's huge cock driving me wild. I couldn't shake the thought of him slamming into Abby, his raw power taking control. I could almost feel his hands gripping my hips, pulling me close as he thrust deeper and deeper.

Suddenly, the door swung open. It was Jake. I could only watch, frozen in place. As we held each others gaze, I opened my legs slightly, giving him an unobstructed view of my glistening pussy.

He walked slowly towards me, his eyes never leaving mine. He seemed unashamed of his nakedness, his strong body and massive cock fully visible.

He stopped in front of me and I couldn't tear my gaze away from his cock. It was only semi-hard, yet still bigger than any I'd seen before. It was glistening with Abby's juices.

"Where you listening to us?," he whispered. I nodded, unable to speak. Tearing my eyes away from his magnificent cock took all the willpower I had. I looked up at him, biting my lip.

Jake reached out and gently grabbed the back of my head, pulling me towards his cock. I opened my mouth, allowing his massive manhood to slide between my lips. His hands gripped my hair tightly, guiding my movements.

I could taste the saltiness of his cum mixed with Abby's juices as I took him deeper and deeper into my mouth. I looked up at him as I sucked, occasionally taking a little break letting my tongue dance around the tip of his shaft.

I felt his cock reaching full hardness and it spurred me on. I wrapped my lips around his thick length, taking him further into my mouth. I gently began to move my head, using my lips and tongue to create a rhythm that matched the passion of our earlier encounters. I looked up at him, seeking the pleasure and satisfaction on his face.

"How does she taste?" He asked. I answered by increasing my pace, my head bobbing up and down on his thick shaft. His hands held my head firmly, guiding the movement as he watched me take him deeper and deeper.

My hand moved between my legs, rubbing myself faster as I continued to suck him. His cock was getting harder by the second, his need growing stronger. With every thrust, I went deeper, feeling his cock grow in my mouth.

"Take that big cock," he commanded as he grabbed my head, pushing it down onto his shaft.

I obeyed, burying his whole cock into my mouth and gagging briefly. I took it all in, relishing the sensation of such a large organ in my mouth. I was beginning to get used to the size, although it still amazed me how it fit inside me. His hips began to move, thrusting his hips forward in a shallow rhythm.

My own need was growing too, and the feeling of his fingers tightening in my hair, guiding my movements, ignited something inside me. I pulled back, releasing his cock from my mouth. I stood up and turned around, leaning over the toilet.

I was wearing one of Alex's T shirts, so I lifted it up at the back, exposing my bare ass and pussy to Jake. He pressed himself against me, rubbing his rock-hard cock up and down my wet slit. The contact between his massive member and my soft flesh was electrifying. His touch sent waves of pleasure coursing through my body, making me want more.

He began pushing himself into me, his large cock stretching me and causing my walls to clench tightly around him. His hands gripped my hips tightly, urging me to meet his thrusts with my own.

I wanted to show how much better I was than Abby so I responded eagerly, matching his rhythm. We moved together in sync, each thrust creating a symphony of quiet moans and groans, filling the small space. Our bodies collided forcefully as Jake's monstrous cock continued to stretch me.

My legs buckled underneath me, but Jake held me upright. His powerful hands gripped my waist as he pushed deeper, making my entire body scream with pleasure. His hands left marks on my skin, but I hardly noticed as the intense sensations coursed through me.

I let out a series of stifled moans, still trying to match his rhythm. My pussy contracted around his cock, begging for more. I could feel his cock throbbing inside me, signalling his impending release. With every thrust, I squeezed him tighter, wanting to milk every last drop of his seed.

Jake grunted as he felt my pussy contract. My eyes rolled back as a wave of pleasure washed over me. I was coming, and it felt incredible. My legs shook underneath me, and I grasped the toilet for support.

Jake didn't let up. He pushed even deeper, his thick shaft hitting my cervix with each thrust. It was painful, but I welcomed the intensity of it. The discomfort only added to the overall experience, intensifying the feeling of being utterly taken by him.

Our movements became rougher, our breaths heavier. Jake's fingers dug into my shoulders, and his voice was ragged as he demanded, "Say my name when you come." I complied, moaning his name out loud as my orgasm crashed over me like a tidal wave.

"Oh god, Jake" I cried out as my body shook with pleasure. My inner walls clamped down on his throbbing cock, milking him until he cried out.

"Fuck, yes, Lily!" He yelled, his voice hoarse with lust. He pulled out quickly, a his cum splattering onto my back. His breathing was ragged, his chest heaving up and down. I stood there, feeling his warm cum dripping down my back. Looking back at him, I saw his face flushed and his eyes glazed over with lust.

"Thank you," I whispered. He smiled back, a mix of pride and satisfaction in his eyes. He reached out, gently cupping my cheek.

"You know what would have been better?" he whispered. I looked at him, expectantly.

"If we did it in your room, on your bed, while your boyfriend slept soundly just feet away," he suggested, his eyes alight with mischief.

"That would be incredible," I agreed, my heart racing at the thought. The idea of having him deep inside me while Alex slept oblivious next door sent a thrill through me.

Jake's eyes darkened, his pupils dilating with excitement. "We can make it happen," he promised, his tone heavy with desire.

"Anyway, you better get back to Alex" he said finally, breaking the spell.

I nodded obediently. "Thanks, Jake", I whispered, stealing another glance at his cock before turning to leave.

I crept back into my room. Alex was sound asleep. I crawled in next to him, feeling the cool sheets against my sweaty skin. Closing my eyes, I tried to ignore the vivid image of Jake's cock plastered across my consciousness. Images of Abby flashed in my mind as well, the memory of her enjoying Jake making me feel dirty and confused.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)