Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 12 by DonSilver DonSilver

What's next?

Lester makes a move

Back at the kitchen table, Sarah laughed. He can never just give up, can he?

She reread Dan’s last message. “Have to run honey. Whatever you decide to do, take pics :P”

Obviously, he wasn’t serious but it did give her some ideas on how to spend her day. She would torment and tease her husband through text messages and make him regret going into the office.

Thinking about her husband and turning herself on with her wicked ideas, Sarah unconsciously licked the yogurt off her spoon seductively.

Having waited long enough, Lester decided it was time to initiate phase one of his plan.

He opened his door, ensuring he did so loud enough to alert Sarah to his presence, and headed for the kitchen with only his socks on.

Sarah heard the heavy footsteps of Dan’s roommate making their way toward her. She was snapped out of her daydreaming by the realization that this was her first encounter with Lester after her loud sex with Dan last night. God this is going to be awkward. Dan, why aren’t you here?

As his footsteps drew closer, she debated between pretending not to notice him right away or being overly enthusiastic and trying to move past and ignore the elephant in the room. She was not prepared for what came next.

While Sarah was about to have another spoonful of her yogurt, she was treated to an eyeful as Lester made his way into the kitchen butt naked.

She involuntarily took in his hairy shape, her eyes quickly glancing up and down as he moved towards the coffee maker. She found a spot on the kitchen table to stare at.

Lester pretended he hadn’t noticed her and busied himself making a coffee. She hadn’t made a sound.

When his coffee was finished brewing he turned around to face her. “Oh hey, Sarah, I didn’t know you were here. Is Dan still sleeping?”

“Uh no. No. Dan is at work.” Despite the awkwardness of the situation, Sarah’s upbringing and manners made her look up from the kitchen table and meet Lester’s eyes.

“Really? On a Saturday that's not normal.” Lester was enjoying every second of this. He was intoxicated by being naked in front of a woman like Sarah, watching how uncomfortable she was while still trying to be polite.

“Yeah no, his boss called him late last night and asked him to come in. Some kind of emergency.” Sarah couldn’t help it. It was too awkward of a situation. His eyes quickly flicked down and looked at Lester’s dick.

She let out a small inaudible gasp as she saw his large member swaying between his legs. Lester saw her look and flexed a little, making sure she saw it twitch.

Sarah composed herself quickly and looked back up at Lester, avoiding his gaze and settling on a point on the wall behind him.

“Uhh Lester, you’re naked you know.”

Lester smiled inwardly. Obviously.

“Oh I’m sorry, does this make you uncomfortable?” He feigned concern. “I’m just so used to having the apartment to myself I guess it's sort of a habit.”

He didn’t move. He let his eyes wander over her body until she responded.

“Yeah if you could put some clothes on that would be great.” She made eye contact as she spoke and then quickly looked back down at his dick. She quickly adjusted herself and looked back up at his eyes “I would appreciate it.”

“Yeah no problem, I’m actually going to run out and grab some breakfast. Do you want anything?”

Sarah smiled and shook her head. “No, I’m alright thanks though. Just going to catch up on some work emails.” He totally saw me look at his dick. Goddammit. Talk about awkward. Way to go Sarah.

“OK, I’ll leave you to it. See you later.” Lester walked out of the kitchen smiling. Phase one complete: make Sarah aware of your cock.

Sarah sat there in silence trying to busy herself on her phone but not actually comprehending what she was reading. She could hear Lester moving around the apartment, apparently getting ready. She wasn’t able to breathe until she heard the sound of the front door close and the lock engage.

What the hell just happened? Did he come in here on purpose or was he really used to just walking around his apartment naked? She’d have to ask Dan about this later. I wonder what he’ll say….I’m never going to hear the end of it.

She scrolled back through her phone and opened her chat with Dan to read the last message.

“Have to run honey. Whatever you decide to do, take pics :P” it read.

Well, at least now she had a good response for her husband that was sure to leave him speechless for a bit.

“Guess what. Lester wore the same outfit as me. I guess clothing is optional today ;)” she smiled slightly and pressed the send button.

The image of Lester’s cock twitching popped into her head. She shuddered. Did she cause that twitch? If Lester found her attractive why wasn’t he hard? Didn’t she make him hard? What would his cock look like hard?

Sarah got up from the table and made her way to the bedroom. She needed to clear her head and nothing worked better than a nice long hot shower.

She began to get undressed, peeling off her hip-hugging sweat shorts and dropping her white t-shirt to the floor when her phone buzzed. She glanced at it, a message from Dan.

Smiling, she unlocked her phone and opened her messages. She has to stifle back a laugh at his response. “WHAT!?” Looks like I won.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)