Kylie

It wasn't easy for you to admit but there had always been some attraction to Kylie, she was a little freer than her sister, more joyful, you shared more interests and as much as you loved Anna that had always been a nagging what if at the back of your mind. You looked towards the room Amy was in and after everything she'd done for you you were going to have to break her heart.

"Hey Ames," you said walking in.

Amy read you like a book, like she always had and her face dropped. That look that once told you you were the only one in the world that mattered now told you her world was shattered.

"I get it," said Amy, "that's why, when she came here."

Amy cupped her hand over her mouth and sobbed but pulled away as you moved to comfort her.

"Did you ever really love me?" she asked.

"I still do," you said not lying, "but I'm being torn."

She shoved past you and as you walked out into the house Sara went after Amy and Nyx looked at you, searching.

"I get it," she said, "still harsh."

"Yea," you said, "I'll give her some space."

Nyx went after Sara and you walked out in the cold towards Kylie and what you had run away from. All of these emotions you were having now were a part of why you hadn't gone to Kylie after Anna, it seemed, somehow, a betrayal. As you entered the warm house to a very loud playing of Jingle Bell Rock Kylie turned to you and smiled.

"There he is," she said walking to you, "you talked to Amy."

"Yea," you said, "she's-"

Kylie put a finger to your lips, "I came here for your Dipshit."

You held her in your arms as she rocked to the music.

"I wore this dress to remind you of Blake's wedding," said Kylie stepping back so you could see her.

That wedding, you'd danced, you'd laughed, you'd had a blast. As the night wound down you'd even slow danced with Kylie, her head on your shoulder.

"I lingered that night," she said, "I shouldn't have, I was wondering if you would kiss me."

"The thought had definitely crossed my mind," you said.

She untied the sash at the middle of the dress and shrugged it off of her shoulders.

"I'm all yours Dave," she said, "no more excuses."

You kissed her and she wrapped her arms around you kissing you back with all of her pent up desire. You pulled the dress off of her waist and let it fall to the floor. Her hands went to your belt and soon your cock was free. You kissed her neck, undoing her bra to let free her large perky tits.

"That was always the difference between me and Anna," said Kylie, "I'm a bad girl and I wasn't going to let anyone else get in my way."

Kylie worked your cock expertly with her hands, working your balls just enough, applying just the right amount of pressure as she stroked.

"If you had kissed me at that wedding," she whispered in your ear, "I would have let you have me."

Oh she was a very bad girl. She pushed you onto the edge of the bed and slid off her panties before climbing onto your lap, with a gasp she slid your cock in. Kylie wrapped her arms around you and kissed you slowly riding your cock.

"Don't hold back Dave," she said, "I know you've thought about this."

She started to work herself on you as you kissed her neck groping her perfect tits. If you had thought Kylie was like Anna the similarities ended in the bedroom. Anna was a pillow princess she wanted to be used however you wanted. Kylie knew what she wanted, if you thrusted her hips worked with you, when you stopped she worked herself on you. She was also much more vocal than Anna, "right there," or "a little faster."

"Oh my god Dave I'm gonna fucking," she moaned loudly, her eyes closed her hands gripping your shoulders as she came on your cock.

She kissed you hard running her fingers through your hair, "when I dream about that night and what could have happened," she said, "and I touch myself," she smirked as she continued to ride you, "you're always in control."

You grabbed her waist and threw her onto her back climbing onto her and sliding back in. You couldn't hold back, this was all too taboo and you couldn't wrap your mind around Anna and her sister who was moaning under you who had wanted to steal you away. Inhibition was gone, you slammed into Kylie sucking aggressively on her tit as she whined and clawed at you.

"Not inside," she pleaded as your cock throbbed inside her.

You barely pulled out shooting your massive load all over her stomach. As you caught your breath she pulled you in for a long kiss and cuddled up to you.

"Finally," she said with a smile, "you're all mine."