Keeping the original girlfriend satisfied

You get home with Heather and Katy fairly late. Mom and Ellen are up like old maids watching some ridiculous true crime special on Dateline. You wonder about those two... Ellen is so much like Mom in every way except appearance. But give it ten years and you bet they even look the same. They both just laze around and bitch... but here you are bitching about how much they bitch, does that make you any better?

"Oh look what the cat dragged in," Ellen says when the three of you enter together, "Quite the trio you three are becoming."

"He just walks me home 'cause the streets aren't safe here apparently," Katy says, looking to Mom, since she brought you all to this ridiculous place.

Mom shrugs. "Oh you need to grow up, Katy. And this place is perfectly safe."

You're pretty tired after a full eight hours on your feet waiting tables. "Well we're going to bed," you say. You wish you could include your little sister in that, but the rest of your family can't know you just took her virginity. Now you feel like a jerk for not saying anything to Katy before you came into the apartment and had to go back to pretending she isn't your girlfriend. Probably she could use some reassurance and kind words tonight, this is a defining night of her life. But she seemed to enjoy the deflowering quite a bit and was giggling pleasantly with you and Heather as you all walked home. She seems to be handling it fine.

"Don't make too much noise fucking the slut," Ellen says.

You should tell your big sister off, but that would start a family fight. You're all adults now and it's rather pathetic to be screaming at your family at this point. You let it slide and go to the bathroom to brush your teeth and get ready for bed. Katy flops down on the couch with Ellen and Mom... back in little sister mode, hiding her real relationship with you. That's another thing you'd like to change, but can't seem to figure out how yet. Oh the look on your mom and Ellen's face when they see Katy is your submissive girlfriend.

You and Heather take a quick shower in the bathroom, washing off all the grime from a day walking around town and working naked. You notice Heather cleans absolutely everywhere, even between her ass cheeks. So you do the same - why not be presentable for your ladies?

In your bedroom, you say, "Sorry about my family. Even Katy falls in with them. I should stick up for you though, even if they'd probably never stop being bitches."

"It's okay," Heather says pleasantly, "Nothing can ever be perfect, and it's hard for the youngest girl to stand up to her mom and big sister. I still am glad to just be living here, treated like a human being... by you at least, and Katy when big sister isn't around. Those two share a room huh?"

"Yeah, there's only three bedrooms here," you say, "Anyway, we can defy them a little bit."

"Oh?" Heather said, she's standing naked over your bed, looking sexy as ever with her shaved twat and big tits. As you might expect of the former village slut, her body is absolutely built for sex. Thankfully, her libido lives up to the love of sex her body suggests.

"Yeah," you say with a grin, "I'm going to make a whole lot of noise fucking you tonight."

Heather literally jumps up and down in excitement. "Yaaay! You still have energy after your busy day?"

"Of course," you say, looking at your blond girlfriend's big jugs bouncing up and down, so carefree. "I know you need to get fucked hard at least once a day. I can't neglect my original girlfriend just because I've got new ones. You're still #1."

She looks like she's going to melt from happiness. This is making you horny so you push her down onto the bed, and she just coos excitedly. You weren't joking about her needing to get fucked hard once a day... if you didn't give her this, she'd probably leave you to get her itch scratched, no matter how many sappy things you said to her.

You push her down on all fours. She's not a pure submissive like Katy, but she is very pliable in bed. You spread her ass cheeks and look at her hairless pink asshole. You admire how she keeps her body totally hairless, even here. Far from embarrassed, she wiggles her ass excitedly. You've always been curious about this and she couldn't be cleaner now, so you lean in and kiss your girlfriends puckered hole.

"Ooooh yeah lick my asshole!" she yells enthusiastically. She's just going on pure horny energy, but she's being loud enough that your sisters and mom will probably hear. Which is exactly what you want.

It's so perverted to lick a girl there, especially when she is totally clean and loves what you're doing. You lick it and flick her asshole back and forth with your tongue. It's pleasingly tight and sexy, maybe the last secret her body had left from you. You kiss it, then press your tongue in curiously.

"Ohhh fuck! Tongue fuck my asshole baby!" Heather yells. You push your tongue inside a lady's ass for the first time. It's warm and lovely, and surprisingly tight for a woman who's certainly had anal sex. You explore her depths as much as you can, eating her hot asshole eagerly. She moans loudly and her words leave no illusion that she's getting her ass eaten. You hope your mom and sisters are hearing every bit of this.

After a few minutes of licking Heather's ass, you say loudly "My turn!"

You lay on your back and spread your legs. To your delight, Heather is hardly offended or hesitant at the idea of licking a guy's ass. Fair's fair, after all, and you're as clean as she is now. You'd never thought much about this perverse act but now that you've found a woman who'll eagerly do it, you have to satisfy your curiosity about getting your ass licked.

You feel oddly effeminate with your legs spread as you lean against the baseboard, but you want Heather to do it in this position so you can see her, and so your cock is in her face too. She kisses your balls a greeting then lowers herself, kissing your taint all the way down to your asshole. This woman has no shame and you love it. With some women this would be weird and unpleasant but Heather is actually INTO IT. She's moaning as she kisses you down there, she's eager as hell. She is a true nympho and excited to do perverted sex acts with you, not ashamed.

Still, even if it's clean, a girl licking your asshole is very perverted. She's going at it too, kissing your anal ring then pressing her tongue inside you. Normally you're not very loud during sex but you notice the bedroom door is cracked. "Yeah, lick your boyfriend's ass, Heather!" you yell, hoping to rile up the peanut gallery out in the living room.

"I love licking you there! Do you like my tongue inside you?" Heather says loudly. Damn, she's all for loud sex your family can't help but hear. This is amazing.

"Yes! Stick your tongue in my ass, my slutty girlfriend!"

She goes back to eating your clean ass and you groan loudly in genuine pleasure. You can just reach her head and stroke her hair, then grab it to guide her in even closer as you feel her tongue inside you.

After making enough noise with this lewd act, you pull Heather up and fondle her breasts casually. Thinking about anal sex, it occurs to you that you've never actually had it. Heather's ass felt plenty tight and you decide this is the perfect opportunity. Katy would scream and say you'd rip her in two... of course she'd let you do it anyway, as a submissive, but you don't want to traumatize the poor girl. Yet. And Ruth would never let you fuck her ass since she only wants you to shoot your sperm straight into her womb so she can get pregnant. If you're going to learn anal sex, it must be with Heather.

"I want to fuck your ass," you say less than eloquently, but you're horny as hell.

"Oh okay!" Heather says casually, clearly not being the least bit apprehensive about taking your cock up her ass, "Can we still be really loud?"

"Butt of course," you say.

Heather gets on all fours on your bed. You love how this woman is as horny for sex as a stereotypical teenage boy, as horny as you, except from this position you can clearly see her shaved pussy lips and there's no doubt that she's all girl.

"You want your ass fucked huh?" you ask, not trying to get your voice down as you get grab some lube from the bedside table. You'd love to take her totally raw but... even Heather probably has her limits of what she can find pleasurable.

"Yeah baby! Fuck your girlfriend's ass! I want that big cock all the way up my pooper!"

You try not to laugh at her using such a ridiculous word. You get the impression guys didn't want her to talk before, they just wanted her to fuck... but you don't want to think about that part of her life. She's a new woman now. Your woman.

You get on the bed and it squeaks, but you don't care. You press your cock against Heather's butthole and find it pleasingly tight, rubbing your cockhead against her anus to get you both even more worked up. You look to the door and see it's still cracked, not open enough for someone to see in more than just the tiniest sliver, but it's not blocking much noise. Normally you'd fix that in a hurry, but not tonight.

Heather presses her ass against your cockhead. "You want my dick, huh?"

"Oh yes! Fuck my ass, baby!"

This woman makes you feels so good as a man. You press your cock forward, forcing her rosebud to open. You press your cock in gently at first, being new to this. You feel a woman's hot rectum around your cock for the first time and can't imagine doing this with a condom, the raw feel of Heather's ass is incredible. You greedilly plunge into her, obsessed now with getting your entire cock in her butt. The lube makes this relatively easy as your dick slides deeper and deeper. Heather's ass feels amazing, so tight and warm, and she's moaning as you shove eight inches of cock inside her. Then nine. Then all ten.

You're balls deep in your girlfriend's tight ass. "You took my whole cock in your ass!" you say loudly.

"Of course!" she said, "It's so big baby! Finally a man who can fill me... you're the only man who can satisfy me!"

That sure makes you feel good. Your cock is so hard it's aching. You start fucking Heather's ass hard. With the lube you're not hurting her, but she's grunting from the exertion of you shoving your big cock deep in her ass then pulling it out again and again. Faster and faster.

You're fucking her hard and gaining confidence. You pull your cock out and notice her hole is gaping slightly. This is so wrong, but you find it hot, and you're sure it will be tight again soon. You shove your cock back into her.

"Yeah! Fuck my ass!" she yells enthusiastically. She's actually enjoying being loud and letting your family hear. And why not? She hates how they call her a slut and exclude her because of her past. She's right to feel that way.

"Yeah, take my dick!" you yell, keeping the noise up, but also just feeling like saying it, "Rub your clit, I want you to cum too!"

She holds herself up with one hand and frigs her clit with the other. You press your entire cock inside her again, making your balls slap against her thighs.

"Fuck, it's so big! Keep it inside my ass, baby!"

You're happy to do that for her, pressing your cock all the way in and rutting around inside Heather's ass. You're about to cum but remember something and look to the door. It's cracked more now and there are eyes looking in. In the moment you're sure it's Katy, your ****-crazed perverted little sister, it figures that she'd be unable to resist watching.

You give her a good show, fucking Heather's ass, even pulling out and holding her hole open with your fingers for your own enjoyment, but also so the voyeur in the doorway can see. "Your ass is open baby!"

"Cum in it, please! Fill my ass with your cock and your cum!"

Heather's masturbating wildly. You plunge your cock inside her depths, groaning loudly as you ram your dick all the way in again. You give her few fast and frantic thrusts then she's moaning from an unfakeable orgasm under you, screaming loud to make sure your family hears. This sets you off and you're cumming too. You press hard against her ass cheeks, letting your cum shoot out deep inside Heather's rectum, filling her ass with your sperm like she wants.

"Take my cum!" you yell. She moans incoherently in pleasure as you blast rope after rope of hot cum inside her and she rides her orgasm.

You pull out eventually and collapse on your back, dick in the air. Heather falls on her stomach beside you. You look to the door, planning on telling Katy to come in if she can. Maybe your mom and big sister have gone to bed and you can make Katy do some perverted stuff. You can never get enough.

But when you roll your head over quickly to look, you realize that's not Katy watching you through the slightly cracked door. It's your sister all right, but not your little sister.

It's your big sister Ellen.