Keeping needy Jessica in the dark.

“I wish Jessica would not be able to hear this conversation.”

Tiffany knew she couldn't just sit in here forever, but she did not know how she should go out. Should I yell at the creep? Just storm by without saying anything? Ask for an explanation? Part of her was not even sure she could hide how aroused the combination of Jessica's arousal and her fantasies about what was happening outside her stall was making her. Tiffany and the other girls knew how arousing the smell of Jessica's juices could be; it was one of the unlisted perks of being a cheerleader, catching the scent in the locker room or when the creep toyed with her. She only barely kept herself from peeking, knowing that being caught spying could destroy her reputation completely.

“Hey, Tiff! Come on out!”

Damn! The cat was out of the bag here. Even with her fantasy nonsense, the creep had just said her name. Alex knew she was here. Putting her feet on the ground, she pulled up her pants and strolled out of the stall.

She had figured that the creep must have used her rights to Jessica's body to make a deal of some sort, forcing Jessica to wear something while touching her in the bathroom, so she would let her have some relief elsewhere. She was not, however, prepared for the sight of Jessica kneeling between the creep's legs, wearing her own panties, while appearing to eat her out. The creep can touch her, sure, but Jessica doing something like this? It was almost unthinkable. Jessica even had her hand in the panties!

“Lunch was especially exciting today,” Alex started, “I bet yours was as well. Jessica and I decided we needed to have a bit of relief afterward. Oh! Come here, I want to check if you still have my gift!”

Tiffany knew she shouldn't, that she should leave and pretend she did not see anything, but the creep always had a way of really revving her engine. Part of her couldn't believe herself as she stepped forward, moving up to the counter adjacent to her, but ever since earlier today she just could not resist these dirty suggestions from the creep. She could have just told the Creep the plug was still in, tried to avoid this whole mess, but before the creep even said another word she was already unbuttoning her jeans, a visible dark stain on the front, and letting them fall. Without her panties, the pair Jessica was now wearing while pleasuring the creep silently, she was bare bottomed to the room.

Tiffany gasped as the creep grabbed her ass. She gave it a playful squeeze before slowly sliding her fingers between her crack. The tip of her fingers brushed against the exposed part of the toy inside of her.

“Very good Tiff! You should try to keep it in until you get someone else to take it out for you, oh, and make sure you keep squeezing and clenching it. Really develop those back-end muscles!”

Tiffany clenched hard on the toy, the words of the creep pushing her, as she considered her words. The idea of needing someone else to remove it... she felt like she could die from the shame, but she also knew she couldn't resist the creep's suggestion. She flexed her muscles around it, the toy slightly pulled in further as she clenched before sliding back into the normal position when she let go.

“But... Jessica...” Tiffany started to say. Red embarrassment lined her face as she looked down at Jessica, confused as to why she was not paying her any attention right now. The head cheerleader looking like she was absolutely absorbed by what the creep had between her legs.

“Oh don't worry, she is way into my puss right now, she doesn't even know you are there,” Alex explained, running her other hand through Jessica's hair.

Alex was not aware that her statement was not entirely true. The wishes obscured her physical senses, but the genie was somewhat aware that someone else was here, from both what little her senses could tell her as well as being able to surmise what she could from the wishes.

I wish Jessica would not be able to hear this conversation

What conversation? Jessica immediately thought as her body reacted to this wish, the sensations strong as it reacted to her aroused state. Did someone come in? She tried to listen, to pick up any sounds, and try to determine what was happening around her. She could sort of tell there was more sound in the room, possibly behind her, but what concentration she did have kept being distracted by the creep's slit in front of her.

She wanted to listen, but her nose smelled the creeper's aroma; her eyes when opened fixated on the creepers sex; her mouth hung slightly open, her tongue tasting the juices she had been licking as she breathed in the aroma. Is she talking? Jessica could hear the sounds, almost catching a few words, as the creep seemed to be talking above her, but the earlier wishes made it so hard to free her senses from captivating compulsion placed upon her. Even the lightest squelch made from Alex's pussy contracting at her touch was much louder to her than the voices above.

Her arousal continued to flare as her senses remained focused on the creeper's sex, the wish to get arousal by 'experiencing it' feeding back into itself as the act made her aroused and brought it to her mind unbidden, which further raised her arousal. Unbeknownst to her, her hand had was freed when she stopped actively pleasuring the creep, but she seamlessly continued pleasuring herself as her arousal had not fully abated. The thought that she could even stop it had not even occurred to her, as she felt her juice's production ramp up, a small trickle quickly ramping up to a near constant drizzle as the arousal feedback continued on herself, while a small part of her mind registered something was said above her.

She held a gasp back as her panties suddenly sharply tightened, the soaked crotch pulling in with surprising strength as the fabric tightly pressed her hand against her nethers. Part of her leaking juices was being absorbed by the magic panties, while the rest leaked through the material and pooled on the ground below. The wish that had animated the panties gave it enough control to manipulate its form somewhat, tightening and loosening itself, using this to control its own desires.

Jessica's mind slightly pulled to the front as it recognized another voice. Was that Tiffany? Jessica could not quite register what words had been said, but it sounded just like her friend's voice. She could only keep her focus for a moment however, the shock just enough to push her into an orgasm. A small swell of pleasure and juices erupted from her as she rode it. It faded quickly; however, the sensation had only made a minor impact on the heat she felt.

That's it? Jessica's mind yelled in frustration, The relief it had provided her had been only a faint shadow of her previous... of the good girl orgasm. Her increasing arousal quickly wiped away what relief she got and, with tears of frustration, she reached out with her tongue and licked the creep's outer lips again. Her sheer need overriding the part of her mind reeling in shame that she was doing this in front of a friend, as her hand's movement, visible underneath the tight panties, became more intense as it started to push harder and faster.

Alex knew Tiffany was putty in her hands, figuratively and literally. The earlier wishes about being receptive to suggestions on the toy or bondage let her control her, while the other one about being aroused by Alex while still thinking she was a creep made her so much fun to toy with. Alex slightly pulled at the toy, watching the quick intake of breath Tiff made, before pushing on it with her finger. She looked over again at Cassie, the girl's brown hair with blonde highlights disheveled from her position on the ground. Cassie had always felt like the more innocent girl of the team, besides naive Tia, as well as having an elfin-like grace as she moved. She had always seemed like such an innocent free spirit compared to the antics of the other girls; it had been so fascinating to discover just how pervy she was.

Alex stifled a moan as she felt a quick lick from Jessica against her folds. Her genie had been inactive on the oral since she got off, still stuck nose-deep in against her folds, and she had only felt her breath until now. _Guess that arousal is really doing a number on her, _Alex thought as she felt another cautious lick against her, part of her mind equating the slow lick as both loving and needy, and she knew she should finish up soon.

“Would you be interested in a secret club, Tiff? “ Alex asked, her breath increasing as she felt Jessica becoming more active, “A place where those like us can express our interests with each other? I think me and Jessica might start one. I would be in charge of... oh that's good, activities and stuff, and Jessica would be a fine mascot.“

“Ah... I...”

“Come on, Tiffany, we are all perverts here. With your interests... I can't help but suggest you join us to explore them even further...”

“I...” Tiffany's face scrunched up as she said this, part of her **** about more people finding out, and another shamed at the arousal flushing through her as the creep continued to toy with her, mentally and physically. The creep had squeezed one of her cheeks, her hand feeling her up as she talked, as she gazed expectantly at Tiffany.

“I'll join... oh god, I'll join,” Tiffany gave her consent, shame and arousal tinged her voice as she gave in, unable to resist the creep's suggestions.

“I knew you would!” Alex said, a grin spreading out on her face before she turned to look back at the stalls, “How about you Cassie? I'll let you lick Jessica if you pledge to join, and look at how needy she is! I bet she would cum right on your face!”