Katie wants to continue playing

The first thing you saw was Brian adjusting his jeans with a huge grin of satisfaction. Right behind him, your wife. You could see shock in her eyes, but she was smiling. Her hair was a little disheveled, but she looked mostly ok. She wiped her lips as she sat down next to Brian again, and he passed his arm around her shoulder.

"That was great! Who's next?"

"Nobody. Katie, we're leaving" You said without hesitation.

"Come on! This is a party! And we're just playing a game!" Brian said with a smug smile as he held your wife tighter. "Isn't it, Katie?"

"Y-yes. Yes, sweetie. We're just playing!" She shrugged at you. You knew how persuasive those puppy eyes were, and she knew she could beg you with them, and you'd do anything she wanted. And now it seemed she wanted to stay. Of course, you could not leave her alone.

"You mean you... Want to keep playing?"

She nodded slowly and giggled.

"It's just a game..." She repeated.

"And it's your turn!" Mark told Katie. "Truth or dare?"

Now it's your turn to beg with your eyes. You were praying so hard she didn't choose dare and have those idiots make her do something weird. And it seemed to work!

"Truth!"

"Alright. Tell us... No, don't tell us, describe the lasy thing you swallowed."

You looked daggers at him. Your mind raced trying to remember what she had had before coming here. Was it an apple? Some yogur? A granola bar?

"Well..." She started, and she giggled. And so did Chloe and Diana. "It was... White. It was thick. So, so thick. So difficult to swallow!" You prayed again for it to be the yogurt "It was a little bitter and a little salty... And a little sweet... And very warm."

Warm? It could not be the yogurt. You glared at Brian, who still had huge satisfaction on her smug smile. Katie is flustered a little as she spoke, but the two other girls encouraged her to finish.

"And... There was so, so much of it. So much. And it was... It was so tasty as well..."

You could not believe what she was saying. Was she talking about...? Was that Brian's...?

"That sounds like a yummy snack!" Chloe said and winked at Katie, who just giggled. Katie looked at you with her most innocent "Sorry!" eyes. You don't really know how to feel.

"Dylan! Truth or dare!" Somebody said quickly.

"Dare." You responded without thinking. "N-no, wait...!"

"I dare you to continue playing blindfolded! Until we let you take it off!" Diana said, and immediately someone tied something around your head, coverin your eyes completely. The last thing you saw was your wife, and Brian's hand around her.

"W-wait! Stop! I don't want this!" You tried to stand up, but you felt two hands pushing you down again.

"Honey, it's just a game! Let's keep on playing a little!" You heard Katie say. You clenched your teeth and stopped trying to stand. Maybe she was right... But since you didn't know exactly what happened in the closet... Although it was so evident...

"Fine. Just... Just a little longer."

Everyone cheered, and even someone patted your back a little too hard.

"Brian, truth or dare?" Someone asked.

"Dare, of course!"