Julie

Walking over to Julie, you pull her up from her seat. Unclipping her overalls and letting them slide to the floor, you assess her more closely by groping her entire body. Judging from her slim, muscular body, you guess that Julie is a runner or swimmer. Shivering at your touch, she grips her boyfriends hand a bit tighter.

“You alright?” he whispers.

“It’s nothing, Leonard,” Julie whispers back. “Just thought I felt something.” Despite her words, she continues to shiver (even giggling a few times) as your hands slide over her.

Pulling Julie into a hug, you savor the warmth of her naked body against yours, feeling her tiny tits and hard nipples pressing against you. To your surprise, she leans her head against you, reaching her free arm around to hug you in return, sighing contentedly. Julie must really like hugs, enough that even the basic feeling that transmits to her still provokes a reaction.

Audrey finishes reading from her letter as you make your decision. As she moves onto discussing verses from her bible, you slide your dick between Julie's tight thighs until your member is standing to full attention once again.

Still lubricated from your time with Audrey, you feel like there’s no need for further foreplay. Pulling Julie away from her boyfriend, you lift her onto Audrey’s desk, spread her legs wide and slide your cock into her pussy. She cries out in pain as you tear her hymen. Leonard gives her a concerned look, but doesn’t object to (or notice) you violating her. Julie continues to whimper quietly with each thrust.

At first, you’re confused. You’ve slept with girls that were about as small as Julie, and they never had any problem with you. You eventually realize that your penis is larger than you remember it being, in length and girth. Another gift from the voice probably. For you, the tight fit of Julie’s virgin pussy feels heavenly. You thrust harder, feeling the pressure along your entire length. For her, your dick is almost too much to bear, especially considering this is her first time. You give Julie an apologetic kiss, but you don’t let up for a moment.

Leonard notices Julie’s discomfort, even if he is unaware of your presence. Although he’s reading from his bible with the rest of the group, he keeps sneaking peeks at his girlfriend.

“Are you sure you’re alright?” He asks,

“Really, it’s nothing,” Julie says. Her expression switches from a pained grimace to a mollifying smile (although tears are still running down her cheeks). You’re unsure if her reaction to you is somehow overridden by her reaction to Leonard, or if she’s just that good at hiding her pain.

Close to climax, you lift Julie up and maneuvering her into a full nelson, holding her legs up to give Leonard a clear view of her worn pussy. Julie squeals as she starts to orgasm, squirting fluid a fair distance, at the same time as you start to shoot your load into her. Aiming her at Leonard, you spray him in the face with a mixture of vaginal fluid and jizz. Covering him with the evidence of your lovemaking with his girlfriend, and the final few contractions from Julie’s vagina, squeezes a final wad of splooge out of you before you’re spent.

Setting Julie down, you help her back to her seat, noting the wobble in her step from her ravaged cunt. She wipes a final tear from her eye before taking Leonard’s hand again. They smile at each other, innocently enjoying their wholesome Christian love, while you savor the feeling of cuckolding a guy right in front of him. You take Julie’s chastity ring and add it to your collection.