John picks the man.

Despite not being happy about it, John knew every word his wife said was true. Being in a relationship is about comprising. He knew that her having another man's child was nowhere near normal, but neither was another woman having his child. None of this was 'normal,' and he just had to accept that. The only problem was whose child was she going to have.

"I am sure, Jenn, but it can't just be anyone; we have to be safe about this. It has to be with someone we trust." At that moment, John knew that he also didn't want to add anyone to the list of people that his wife fucked. So to John, best knownledge, the list of people that Jenn has fuck and that they at least quasi-trusted consisted of only one person. "What about Steve. Yea, I think he will be the best one." John couldn't believe he had just suggested letting his wife sleep with that man again, but it was the only one man that at least sort of fit his list of requirements.

However, Jenn did her best to hide her disappointment. Don't get me wrong, she was ecstatic that her husband was going to let her have a child, but she had another man that she wanted to be its father. Someone that she had a long history with and someone that deep down she knew she loved almost as much as she loved her husband. But it was too late now. She knows that attempting to get John to change his mind about the man would just risk her having a child altogether, and there was no way that Steve would ever turn the offer down. From this moment on, she was going to have Steve's child; it was just a matter of how it was going to happen.

As she starts to think of everything Steve is going to want to do while breeding her, her disappointment is quickly replaced by excitement