Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by ashrina ashrina

What's next?

Jesus it’s big

Go ahead, kiss it," he said.

She readjusted her grip. Her tiny hand didn't fit around his girth. She gave a few slight tugs, moving the tight foreskin over his plum of a cock head. She leaned in with her mouth slightly open but straightened before actually going in to suck.

"I don't know if I can even fit the end in my mouth. We never did this before," she warned.

"Don't worry, babe, just take what you can. Just watch the teeth." He laughed, and then said, "If you pull the skin back a little further, it might not be as thick for you."

"Okay."

She tightened her grip just below his massive head, then proceeded to pull the tight foreskin. It hardly moved, but after a moment, it pulled back enough for the ridge of Matt's mammoth cockhead to pop from under his tight sheath. Now the end of his thick cock was flaring wider than his already massive shaft.

"Wow, I can't believe I took this thing. You're a freak," she whispered.

"Ha, ha. What do you mean?" he said.

"Well, I didn't exactly realize how big you were back in school, but you're huge. I mean, you were huge then--that can't be normal," she said with a slight smirk. With that statement, his cock flared more.

"Well, it has grown some since then, ya know."

"Yeah, not by much. Like what, an inch?" she said, waving his hefty cock with her hand.

"Nah, like half an inch since then, but it got a tiny bit bigger since last time we fucked. That was like a year ago." He bragged.

"Uh, 10 months, remember?" she corrected him.

"Well, 10 months." He responded.

She finally leaned in, opening her tiny mouth wide. Motioning over his cock, she guided it with her tiny hand directly to her lips. I could plainly see that his cockhead was far wider than what her tiny mouth could take. She wouldn't have any trouble taking a normal-sized dick like mine (not that she ever tried to give me head), but Matt's was far too wide for her tiny mouth.

Her lips met his monster cockhead, but she soon realized how much thicker it was compared to her mouth. She opened wider; a quarter of an inch entered her mouth, and this quarter inch consisted of the very tip of his large member. She pulled off. She tried again; this time, three-quarters of an inch made its way into my girlfriend's tiny mouth, but again she pulled off.

"I can't fit it; you're too wide." She leaned in, mouth wide open, and using her teeth gently nibbled on the end of his oversized cockhead.

"Ouch! Watch the teeth." He laughed.

She closed her lips over the tip of his cock. Keeping them pursed, she pulled off while holding his monster at mid-shaft. As she pulled off, a heavy string of precum followed her lips that connected her tiny mouth to his heavy cock. The strand lengthened to four inches before it broke, splashing her slender chin and his thick head.

Her tiny hand released its tight grip. Matt's cock bobbed in the air but remained pointing directly at Abby's cute face. His tight foreskin slowly moved back over his immense cockhead, leaving about a third uncovered.

She stood up. "I don't think that is going to work."

"Well, let's try this." He said. Then he stepped closer, massive cock bobbing in mid-air. As he approached, his heavy cock gently hit her tight abs through her shirt, his thick head bending ever so slightly. Using both hands, he reached around her hips and pulled her shorts and underwear to the floor. Now her tight, shaved pussy was in full view. I could tell she was soaked.

Matt stood directly in front of her, cock bobbing. Abby, taking her tiny hand, encircled his massive cock and gently tugged it, pulling it close to her tightness. She had to widen her stance to accommodate his width, but his thick cockhead now nestled just outside the warmth of her super-tight pussy. I could see a glisten from her wetness on his heavy cock.

"I think I want to try to take your giant again," she whispered as she smirked.

Matt slid both hands around her slender waist and cupped both of her tight ass cheeks. He lifted her up, spreading her thin legs as he did. Her tight pussy rested on the base of his thick cock while his bulging, oversized cockhead snaked its way along Abby's tight ass. She wrapped her legs around his waist. He began to turn to sit on her bed with Leah firmly on his groin. As he did, I watched as her back faced my direction. I could not believe the size of his monstrously thick cock compared to her tight ass; it nearly reached the top of her cheeks.

He sat on the bed and adjusted so that both knees straddled his waist. In the meantime, his meaty cock bobbed between the air and her tight ass, gently slapping her ass as she moved.

"Uh, Leah ." He said, sounding slightly worried.

"Yeah?"

"I didn't bring a condom. Do you have the one I left here?"

"Uh, no. I kinda used it, but I'm on the pill now, so just remember to pull out."

I couldn't believe that she was considering fucking this guy.

"You used it? I thought you said the guy was smaller. He still fit in my size?"

"Uh, not exactly. It was really big on him, but it was all we had that night. It ended up slipping off, so we tried without, and it felt soooo good." She said reminiscently.

"Slipped off, huh? So, how big is he?"

"Ummm." She reached back under her pussy and grabbed his meat at its base. Gripping his thickness, she slid her hand up his 8+ incher to 5.5 (nearly 6) inches. She wrapped her thumb and forefinger around that spot.

"He's like this long. He'd come to about here." She said. She was right.

"Damn, I got a few inches on him then."

"Yeah, but he still reaches pretty deep inside. It feels really good."

My dick jerked.

"Well, I never did have to go very deep with you. So is he thick?"

"Oh no. Definitely not, but it still feels good. You're kinda too thick; his feels really good."

"Oh. So compared to me, how thick is he? I'm just curious." He said with a devious grin.

By now, she let go of his cock, but she re-gripped it to give him an accurate comparison.

"He's probably a third thinner, but you're abnormally wide." She giggled.

"That's hot." He said.

She slid down his legs, gripping the wide base of his massive cock. She positioned her pussy an inch or two above his thick cockhead. I thought to myself, "There's no way she'll take him in in this position on the first try." I was right.

"You know we're never gonna get it in in this position?" she explained.

He lifted his hips while she gripped his base and pulled his thickness toward her soaked pussy. Guiding his heavy cock, she pressed his thick cockhead against her tight vagina. As predicted, it didn't penetrate her tightness. The thick head bent and bowed from the pressure against her soaked pussy. It looked like she was pressing hard. Using her hand gripped at his enormous base, she rubbed the head up and down the slit of her pussy, but to no avail.

"We're definitely going to have to try something else. This thing is way too thick." She said.

"That's surprising, considering you're sopping wet," Matt said, motioning to his drenched cockhead.

"Yeah, well, it's not gonna be enough for your fat cock. Stop complaining anyway; it's not my fault you're a freak of nature."

"Come on, it's not *that* big. Besides, you've ridden me before. What's different?"

I knew from experience that Leah loved to be on top, but even my average dick struggled at entering her starting in cowgirl. Usually, I had to get her soaked before we tried.

"What's different is that we never started out with me on top, and we always had a bottle of lube." She reminded him. "Neither of which are happening today." She smiled.

"Well, I'll have to improvise."

Matt grabbed her by the waist and rolled her onto her back. Her firm 32D tits bounced heavily on her chest, those massive deep pink nipples rock-hard and jutting out like fat erasers, begging to be abused. He turned her body so that her legs hung off the edge of her bed while her torso remained on the pink comforter. He knelt to a squatting position between her legs and spread her slender legs. He ran his hands toward her tight ass and cupped her perfect cheeks. Using his thumbs, he worked the outside of her vice-like pussy. He leaned in and began licking her tight slit. Leah instantly gripped the blankets around her. Matt continued, eventually pushing his tongue past her tightness; he used his right index finger along with his tongue, thrusting in and out of her pussy.

"Ohhh....." she moaned.

From Matt's squatting position, I had a clear view of his cock. From here, it looked more like an elephant trunk than a college guy's dick. He was still rock hard, but the weight of the massive shaft and enormous head caused it to remain pointing horizontal from his body. As he ate out my hot girlfriend, his trunk of a cock bobbed in mid-air. Every few seconds, when Leah would make a deep moan, I would see his heavy meat jerk, cockhead enlarging and slightly protruding from his unusually tight foreskin; after a second or two, it would retract, sliding back over his massive head.

This went on for ten minutes; Leah moaning while Matt continued to bring her to orgasm with his tongue and finger. My own hand was in my shorts, jerking my own dick, using my spit as lube. My eyes moved from Abby's tight pussy to Matt's giant cock, and I wondered how it would push through her tightness.

"Please, Matt, I need it. I need it in me." She moaned, eyes closed.

Matt's cock jerked, more violently than before. The thick cockhead protruded from the tight skin, and I noticed pre-cum oozing from his heavy cock. When I say oozing, I mean it literally came pouring out. It resembled my own orgasm, but I usually jerked and dribbled; Matt's cock wasn't jerking--it was just oozing a stream of thick semen. I watched as it puddled on the floor. I thought to myself, "Hey, maybe they're not going to do it after all; it looks like Matt has a premature ejaculation issue. Pathetic." After a second, his foreskin retracted, leaving just the end of his massive cockhead protruding. The tightness of the foreskin seemed to stop the flow of cum.

"Okay, babe." He said as he came up for air. "You sure you're ready?"

"Oh, you made me cum like six times. I'm soo ready. I think I'm soaked." She cooed.

"Yeah, you are, but it's totally hot." He responded.

I watched as he stood up. His cock was still sticking straight out. "Could he still be hard? Was that just precum?" I thought to myself.

He spun her body so that the top of her head was in my direction. I could see down her tight body, her massive 32D tits heaving with each breath, those deep pink areolas puckered and enormous, her puffy nipples throbbing visibly, leaking a tiny bead of clear fluid from the tips as if her body was reacting to the overstimulation. Matt climbed up between her legs; using his right hand, he jerked his heavy cock a few times, then released it to bob in the air.

"Are you sure you're ready for this monster?" he bragged.

"Don't be a dweeb; just put that donkey cock in me." She giggled. "Sorry, I can't help but be dirty." She looked down at his meat. "Damn, Matt, it's soaked, and it looks like it's leaking. Did you cum already?"

He looked down. "Oh, nah, just a little precum. There's a lot more where that came from." He cupped his heavy nuts and smiled.

"Wow." She said. I could see in her eyes that she was comparing her precum to my dribble of an orgasm.

Matt grabbed his massive shaft and pointed his thick cockhead at my girlfriend's tight pussy. The head looked ridiculous next to her tight lips. He pushed against her pussy. She moaned.

"We're gonna need some help." he said reaching over to her nightstand he squirted vaseline onto his palm and rubbed it all over his obscene cockhead. His tight foreskin slowly pulled back as he nestled the huge head against my girlfriend's tight twat. He pushed harder; a third of his massive cockhead pushed past her entrance.

"Oh, that feels amazing." She moaned as he held still.

"Well, babe, that's just the tip."

With one hand on her slender thigh and the other around the base of his massive cock, Matt began to ease his monster into my tiny girlfriend. While I didn't have a perfect view, I could imagine her tightness slowly giving way to his oversized member.

"Oh, Matty, go slow."

It looked like Matt was in his own world. He continued to maneuver his fat cockhead in and out of her tight pussy. By now, the entire head was moving in and out, pulling her labia with each motion. I could hear her juices being displaced by the sheer size of his cockhead.

After a few minutes, Matt pushed deeper. Three inches--just under 1/3 of his shaft--was slowly shoving in and out of my petite girlfriend's tight pussy. While Matt's cockhead was wider than the top of his already massive shaft, the thickest was still to come. At four inches, his shaft widened, after which it was proportionally thick to the base. He moved deeper to just under five inches, pushing in and out.

"Oh shit, Matty, it hurts. I can't believe we did this before." She said in between pants.

"Yeah, babe, jeez, you're tight. Are you sure you've been having sex? Haha."

My stomach turned. He reached the six-inch mark. The sound of wet suction grew louder, as did the gentle squeaking of the springs on her tiny mattress. I knew from experience that her cervix was just over 6 inches deep; he had to be hitting it by now. Matt gave a gentle thrust, pushing 6.5 inches deep into Abby's tight pussy.

"Ouch! You're too deep; you're hitting my cervix."

"Come on, babe, I still got more to go." Said Matt, bragging.

"No, this is why we had to stop. You're too much. Now go easy."

After a few minutes, Matt picked up the pace. He started a slow thrust motion, moving four to five inches in and out of Abby's tight pussy.

"I'm cumming again! Go slow, go slow." She begged.

He left 6 inches inside of her and moved in circular motions around her pussy. I could only imagine his massive cockhead rubbing against her tight cervix. I could hear the juice oozing out of her with each thrust.

"Damn, babe, you're soaked, but you're still so damn tight."

Matt started to pound against her cervix, ignoring her pleas. His meaty cock looked out of place pounding my tiny girlfriend's tight pussy. I could see the lips pulling each time he pulled a few inches of his trunk out of her. "Would she ever be the same?" I thought.

Ten minutes had passed of Matt pounding her twat. He slowed, then reached up with both rough hands to maul her incredible tits, squeezing the lightly sagging mounds hard enough to make the flesh bulge between his fingers, her fat aerolas flushed dark and veiny as if ready to burst--stretching and distorting under his grip. He latched onto her puffy nipples with his thumbs and forefingers, twisting them viciously, yanking them outward until they stretched an inch long, the thick, erect nubs turning an even deeper pink from the ****, tiny beads of clear fluid squirting from the tips as he pinched and pulled harder, making her arch her back and cry out in a mix of pain and ecstasy. "Fuck, your fat nipples are perfect for this--look at 'em leak when I twist 'em," he growled, slapping the heavy tits side to side so they jiggled wildly, the areolas rippling, before clamping down again, rolling the puffy peaks between his knuckles roughly, tugging them like he was trying to milk her dry, her moans turning to whimpers as he roughed them up without mercy while resuming his deep thrusts.

"Are you doing okay?" he asked.

"Yeah, I came again, twice. I'm not used to your trunk." She said with a smile, her tits now red and marked from his ****, nipples throbbing swollen and abused.

With that, Matt straightened on his knees and grabbed her thin thighs. Positioning himself, he said, "Get ready for all of it."

"No, Matt, it's too big." She pleaded, but it was too late.

Matt pounded into my tiny girlfriend, shoving 6.5, then 7, then just over 8 inches of his massive cock into her tight pussy, pushing the fat head past her cervix.

"Oh... fuck, Matt. I can feel it! That's too big. Slow down."

The springs of my girlfriend's bed were screaming as Matt pounded her with all 8 1/2 inches of abnormally girthy cock, his hands returning to her tits, groping them brutally, fingers digging into the soft flesh as he slapped them again, focusing on those massive areolas, smacking them until they bounced and reddened further, then zeroing in on her large puffy nipples--pinching them so hard she screamed, twisting them 180 degrees, pulling them taut until the skin around the areolas stretched thin, the nipples elongating grotesquely under the rough treatment, leaking more fluid as he yanked and tormented them relentlessly, "These huge fucking nipples are mine to ****--gonna make 'em sore for days," he grunted, biting down on one while slamming into her, teeth grazing the sensitive puffiness before sucking it deep and hard, alternating to the other, leaving bite marks and hickeys across the vast deep pink expanses.

Matt pounded Leah for over 10 more minutes. I was in shock at this guy's stamina; he used every inch of his massive meat as he hammered deep into Abby's tight pussy, occasionally pausing the tit **** to slap her jiggling boobs or latch back onto a nipple, sucking and chewing roughly until she begged. Finally, he pulled out; his heavy cock came out with a pop, slapping his tight abs before bobbing and hanging (due to his massive size) just below his groin. Abby's pussy oozed her juices; a puddle stained her pink bed sheets, his cock slick with her juices, his massive nuts soaked, her tits a mess of red handprints, swollen areolas, and battered nipples standing out angry and erect.

"That was amazing. I came three more times." She cooed, wincing as she touched her abused chest.

"It's not over, babe."

He grabbed her by the hips and lifted her in the air. He positioned her tight pussy just over his thick cockhead. Lying on his back, he brought her down. With some maneuvering, he **** his thick cock deep inside my tiny girlfriend.

"Oh. My. G...." she moaned deeply.

Matt's hands clamped like iron around Abby's tiny waist, hoisting her up and slamming her back down onto his lap with a wet *thwack* that made her whole body jolt. His monstrous cock speared upward, the veiny girth splitting her shaved lips so wide the pink inner folds clung to him like a second skin, dragging in and out with every bounce. "That's it, ride this fat fucking dick like the size-queen whore you are," he snarled, bucking his hips to meet her descent, the obscene bulge in her flat belly rising and falling like a piston under her skin. "Your boyfriend's pathetic little prick never filled you like this--feel how I'm wrecking this cunt, stretching it so bad it'll never snap back for him."

Abby's curls whipped wildly as she threw her head back, a guttural scream ripping from her throat. "Oh fuck, Matt, you're *huge*--I'm addicted to your monster, destroy my tight pussy!" Her massive 32D tits bounced wildly with each brutal thrust, those enormous deep pink areolas rippling like jelly, her puffy nipples--swollen and leaking from his earlier ****--throbbing as he reached up to slap them hard, the flesh reddening instantly. "God, Matt, you're splitting me open--your huge cock's so much thicker, it hurts so good, don't stop pounding my slutty pussy!" she gasped, her voice breaking into a whoreish moan, grinding down to meet him, her tight walls clenching desperately around his invading shaft.

She slowly bounced on his meat stick. She soaked him with her juices, I could tell Matt was having trouble forcing his thickness into Abby's abnormally tight pussy. I couldn't believe after all this pounding she was still so tight. "Would she still be tight for me?" I wondered. "How could I compete with this guy?"

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)