Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 54 by Artican Artican

What will Jen do?

Jen wears the strap-on

Cher was a blonde bombshell straight out of a magazine. People would pay big money to see her the way Jen was seeing her right now; hot, wet and naked, raring to fuck! The fact that pinup model was actively seeking to fuck with Jen was making the shy bookworm’s head spin.

Old Jennifer would have found some excuse to get away, cowering and hiding from this situation, but WSW Jennifer was much more assertive. She didn’t even need to have a match to take what she wanted this time. She reached out and caressed the blonde’s heaving bosom. The first touch sent a spark down her spine. She was like a bottled up rocket, feeling Cher’s amazingly soft and warm goddess-like figure.

Cher grinned, gazing into the petite blonde’s eyes. It mesmerized Jen so deeply that she didn’t realize that she had unstrapped the harness off of Cher. It was in her hands when she looked down.

Cher stepped back and sat on the wrestling mat. She leaned back and beckoned Evee to join her. Evee cradled herself in Cher’s arms as they both watched Jen.

Feeling the pressure of the spotlight, Jen stepped into the strap-on.

“Oh boo!” Evee hissed.

Jen looked up, not knowing what she did wrong. She paused like a scared bunny, totally losing her air of confidence. She looked at Evee to clarify her displeasure.

“You’re wearing that over your outfit?” she complained. She then turned to Cher and asked, “Wouldn’t it be better if she took it all off?”

“I think you’re right, V!” Cher concurred, kissing and caressing her friend. She turned back to her guest and said, “I’d say it’s about time you join us, Jen!” She traced her finger over her own nude body as she eyed the petite blonde and licked her lips.

Taking the hint, Jen couldn’t be any more embarrassed. When she was given the role of referee, she had assumed she would just be in the background while the others played. She thought she could just get away with being an unobtrusive observer getting to see some live submission wrestling and victory session. Now, she was the center of attention, having to be the one to perform.

She wasn’t going to back out now though. She was too invested in joining a threesome with these gorgeously seductive supermodels! She put her self conscious thoughts to the side. It didn’t matter that she lacked their long legs, hourglass figures, vivacious hair and perfect skin; they still wanted her to be a part of the adult fun!

Jennifer braced herself, then stripped in front of the models. Even though getting naked in front of others was becoming more of a common thing for her. Normally she would get stripped naked by her opponent. This time, she was disrobing for an audience. It felt strange but gave her a rush of adrenaline as the pair of eyes stayed on her while she revealed her body to them. She felt so wrong to be doing this, but that only excited her even more. Her top and panties were quickly doffed, giving the models a full view of her bare body. She tried to pose confidently for them as they hooted and hollered their approval.

“Whoo! I knew you would look good naked!” Cher cheered encouragingly.

“Mmm… definitely cuter without clothes on,” Evee agreed, eyeing Jen with a hungry smile.

The attention was getting too much for Jen, so she quickly picked up the strap-on and slipped it on. As ridiculous as it was, she felt a little better putting on the dangling cock to cover her modesty. She synched it in comfortably and looked at Cher for what to do next.

Cher smiled and gently pulled Evee off of her, then opened up and gestured for Jen to approach. Jen’s heart was pounding. It was another situation she had never expected to experience; This beautiful, vibrant, engaging, sexy woman was inviting Jen to ravage her. Nervousness started to creep in again for the former wallflower. She took solace in seeing the burning desire flashing in Cher’s blue eyes.

Before she knew it, she was hovering over Cher’s nude form, dildo lined up over the model’s slit. The beautiful blonde looked even more amazing up close. Her scent was all around and it was like an aphrodisiac for Jen. The student guided the cock with her hand and eased herself into the supermodel.

“Ahh….” Cher exhaled softly.

While Cher fucking Evee was a salaciously frenetic affair, Jen’s approach was slower and sensual. She savored the feel of Cher’s perfectly toned body against hers as she pumped the cock in and out of the cover girl. Cher started to writhe under Jen’s control so Jen took her by the wrists and pinned her, keeping her pumping at a methodically steady pace.

“Mmnnn…” Cher moaned, still squirming underneath.

Suddenly, Jen felt something on her neck. It was Evee, kissing her. She felt Evee’s hands reach around and grope her breasts. Her mind went into an impulsive panic. She just realized that this was her first threesome! Ever! All her shame about how wrong it was to have sex outside of wedlock, let alone with another woman was hitting her twofold!

Instead of guilt, she felt a sort of freedom. She was defying her upbringing and no amount of shame was going to stop her for going through with this sapphic depravity! The feel of being sandwiched by the two models made Jen invigorated. Her thrusts had added gusto as they settled into a gingerly motion that the others took notice of.

“Mmm… she’s really getting into it!” Evee noted between neckings.

“I can feel that!” Cher gasped, gyrating her hips against Jen’s more pronounced pelvic pumps. “I like it! Keep it going, Jen! Fuck me just like that!”

“Ahh…” Jen panted, giving Cher the ride she was asking for. She leaned forward and started to suck on Cher’s perfectly proportioned tits. She had abandoned all trepidation and was going all in.

“OOh! She’s a wildcat!” Evee remarked.

“OH! OH! Take me, you beast!” Cher cried out, playing along.

Lost in character, Jen simply growled and thrust rapidly into Cher’s juicy hole, making audible smacks as the recipient moaned happily. Evee was all over the both of them, kissing and licking their body parts until Jen savagely pinned her down and started to eat her out.

“OOH!” Evee gasped, letting herself be taken. “I think we’ve created a monster!” she giggled, opening herself up to be ravaged.

“I’ll have to tame her then!” Cher declared. She sat up and flipped Jen down so that she could mount her cowgirl style. Evee climbed on top as well so that she sat on Jen’s face. They faced each other as they rode the smaller college student.

“Here we go!” Evee said, find her rhythm over Jen’s lips and nose. Jen opened her mouth and stuck out her tongue, letting Evee’s juicy cunt run over it. Evee shivered with pleasure. “Ahh… yeah!” she moaned.

Cher bounced up and down on the strap-on, grinding herself over it with each piston. Soon she started to kiss Evee and they made out on top of Jen. They spent several minutes enjoying each other like this when Jen’s self doubt started to creep back in again. She was on the bottom doing all the work while those two were having most of the fun. She knew she should be grateful just for this much, but was starting to feel like a toy for the two supermodels. She wondered if she was going to get any return attention from them once they’ve been satisfied.

Should Jen do something to get her needs fulfilled or should she keep the others happy in hopes that they would replay the favor?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)