Jason Reclaims Anna Lee

Anna Lee appeared at the back door, naked, doe-eyed like a kid who’d been caught stealing candy. Jason’s anger flared up and he suppressed the urge to slap her across the face.

“I’m at a loss,” he said quietly. “I don’t even know what to say to you. Who the hell is that? Why are you doing this?”

How could she look so innocent? Standing naked in the doorway, hair messy, skin glistening — she was irresistible. He didn’t want to lose her, even now.

Anna Lee moved in closer to him, gliding her hand towards his crotch. He grabbed her wrist and the coy look melted off her face momentarily.

“Fine, be like that. You’re no fun, you know that?”

Jason slapped her across the face. “Stop fuckin around. Tell me what’s going on, Anna!”

Anna Lee looked up at him, defiant. She smirked. “I got me a big nigger dick to play with, that’s what’s goin on.”

“I can see that. Who the hell is he?”

Anna pulled Jason in the house and closed the door.

“He broke in! I didn’t go tryin to fuck him, dummy. I didn’t set out to cheat on you.”

Jason was taken aback. “He broke in? And you’re keeping him here alone? You should’ve called the cops! Or me! Goddamn, Anna Lee!”

“Yeah, he was tryin to rob the place. Relax, he didn’t come here to hurt anyone. He tried to leave when he found out I was home.”

Jason tried to absorb this flood of bizarre information. She didn’t seduce anyone and take them home. Jason took a breath.

“And then you…you what? Tied him up?”

“Yeah, I pointed my daddy’s gun at him and tied him up. And then…well, I just thought I’d…” she shrugged. “…have some fun with em, y’know?”

Jason, almost to his own surprise, actually believed her. The thing is, Anna Lee was not shy about getting what she wanted. She was a sex-obsessed slut, but she wasn’t a liar. She was a straight shooter, unencumbered by the timidity that kept most people from trying to get what they want. She had no fear. If she moved on from him and had a new boyfriend or fuck buddy or whatever, she would just tell him.

“Maybe I’m crazy, but I believe you,” he sighed. “What are you gonna do with him? I mean, what do we do now?”

Anna touched his chest gently, looking up at him. “Well…did you like what you saw, baby?”

Jason stayed silent.

“Hm? Did you?” Her other hand glided down over his stomach, under his waistband and down to his cock. She grabbed him. “Mmhmm,” she cooed, stroking his cock gently in his pants. “I knew it,” she whispered in his ear.

Jason grabbed her shoulders and slammed her back against the wall. Anna gasped but kept stroking him. Their eyes met and they held each other’s gaze before Jason kissed her passionately, not caring in the slightest that she’d just been facefucked by a BBC. Maybe…maybe he even liked that she’d just been facefucked by a BBC. Their tongues intertwined, with Anna Lee pressing hers inside his mouth, flitting it around. Jason thought about her licking the man’s black balls, gagging on his shaft, begging for his black cock. He pressed his tongue into her mouth again and grabbed her by the hips.

He needed some reassurance from her, and he wanted to give some to her, too. He knew he didn’t want to leave her, and it seemed like she had no plans to leave him. But the need to drain his balls was greater. He unzipped his pants and loosened his belt buckle. Anna Lee looked up at him lustfully, her back still pressed against the wall.

“Baby, I-I don’t think my pussy can handle any more,” she looked apologetically at Jason. But his horniness overtook his pride.

“I think you probably couldn’t handle him right now. But you could probably handle me.” Jason wanted her bad.

Anna Lee’s face lit up. “Oh! You’re right. You’ll be easier to—“ She stopped herself. “Um…sorry, I didn’t mean—“

“It’s okay,” Jason interrupted. “I’m not self-conscious about my dick size, honey. It’s just…that guy is…”

“I know!” Anna said, eyes wide. “It’s a fucking anaconda!”

“Y-yeah.”

“I mean, it was huge! There are porn stars with smaller dicks! I almost can’t believe I fit it all inside me,” She was genuinely amazed.

“You don’t mind sloppy seconds, do you?” She said tauntingly.

Jason was so **** to fuck her he didn’t care. Or maybe he did, but he just liked it… Anna helped him take the rest of his clothes off, and Jason led her to the couch in the family room. This is where he planned on taking her virginity tonight. But he was too late — and only by an hour or so. If he had just been here a little earlier, he’d have been the one to deflower Anna Lee, penetrating her tight virgin pussy for the first time. Now he would be the second man to have her. He was still the first to fuck her mouth. And there was still her ass, too…he could be the first man to penetrate that tight little hole of hers.

Jason laid her down on the couch tenderly. Anna Lee smiled up at him. “I’ve been waiting for this for so long,” she said.

“I know,” Jason replied. “Me too. I shouldn’t have kept you waitin.”

“I love you,” Anna said.

“I love you, too.”

She spread her legs, inviting him to play with her. They made love on the couch, melting into each other’s bodies. Their hands clasped together as Jason’s strong chest pressed against her breasts, bouncing gently as they moved their hips together. Jason was surprised by how long he lasted. It must have been the nervousness — he really wanted to perform for her. Yes, she’d been loosened up not much earlier, but she was still so tight. It was better than he could’ve imagined. He was delirious inside her. She was a sex goddess.

She wrapped her legs around him, pawing his back and moaning, taking him deep inside her. He pushed her hips into the sofa with each thrust, deeper and deeper, until finally his strong cock filled her up with his cum.

He nestled in next to her, spooning on the couch.

“I can’t believe we just had sex,” she said breathlessly. “That was amazing.” They kissed again.

Jason didn’t want to ruin the moment. But as soon as he came, his mind went to what he saw through her bedroom window.

“Maybe I could just have some rough sex with her and get the aggression out,” he thought to himself.

He did his best to mask his jealous emotions, trying to focus on the fact that they just had sex. They just had sex! It really was amazing, and he really was happy. But he didn’t like sharing her.

Anna Lee could sense something was wrong. “Babe…I really am sorry about what I did earlier tonight. I know it was selfish. But I really wanted it. Like…a lot. And I thought maybe…maybe you wouldn’t be that bothered by it, at the end of the day. And I don’t think I was totally wrong about that…” She gave him a knowing smile.

Fuck. She wasn’t totally wrong. And he hated that. But why? Why not just give in…

“Let’s take a shower,” Jason suggested, interrupting his own thoughts.

Anna Lee gave him another kiss. “Should I tell that guy that you’re here?”

Jason laughed. “I guess. I don’t want him to get spooked.”

Anna bounced off the couch and ran to her bedroom.

“My boyfriend’s here!” He heard Anna Lee call out.

There were some panicked rumblings from the bedroom, followed by Anna trying to calm him down. Jason laughed and turned the nozzle on.

He stepped in as Anna Lee entered the bathroom. “Well, he’s all nervous again,” she said, stepping into the shower with him.

“Yeah, he probably thinks he’s not gonna make it out alive.” Jason and Anna burst out laughing.

“I don’t know, I’m worried, Jason…” Anna Lee said. “He might try somethin out of a misguided notion of self-defense. Wouldn’t you be scared if you were him?”

“Yeah, I would definitely not believe I was gettin out of this scot-free if I were in his shoes. We gotta build up trust somehow. Maybe we should give him our phone numbers.”

Anna Lee smiled faintly. “Oh yeah? You want me to give him my number?”

“If we wanna build up trust, yeah.”

Anna Lee kissed him and got on her knees. She draped his big white cock on her face and licked his balls. She rubbed her face back and forth across his manhood, opened wide and took both of his balls in her mouth. She sucked them gently as his cock stiffened. She looked up at him with her dark eyes, still lustful after getting fucked by two men that night. She licked his asshole, pressing his balls against her face. Fuck, she looked hot. She was degrading herself for him, trying to apologize in her own way.

A dark thought crossed Jason’s mind. “I am gonna punish you like you’ve never been punished,” he said to himself. Not tonight. Tonight was still special, despite everything. But he would have his ****.

As his balls rested on her pretty face, she continued tonguing his ass like the obedient slut she was. “Maybe I’ll fuck one of her friends,” he thought. No, that wouldn’t work. It’d be devastating for anyone but Anna Lee. She was a freak. She had two best friends, and she had made out with both of them herself. This kind of thing was always her idea. At sleepovers, she would find some way of getting them undressed and would cuddle with them under the covers. They’d run their hands over their naked bodies until they finally touched their lips together, kissing softly in a naked embrace.

So he couldn’t fuck her friends. She’d pretty much beat him to it.

Anna Lee went back to tonguing his balls, grabbing his shaft with both of her hands and stroking him. Jason’s cock was pretty big. She was reminding him of that fact.

He grabbed her hair and jammed his cock as deep as it would go down her throat. She wasn’t ready for it. He fucked her face for a few pumps before tossing her back. She choked and gasped for air. He slapped her face. She looked up at him, still submissive.

“Good girl.” He grabbed her throat and picked her up to her feet. She looked scared.

“Are you a good girl?” He asked.

“Yes, sir,” she replied.

“I want to see what else you can do with that nigger dick.”

She stood like a deer in headlights.

“I said, I want to see what else you can do.”

“Yes, sir.”

“Good girl.” He released his grip on her neck and she exhaled. His hand glided down to her ass. He spanked her and ran his finger along to the rim of her asshole. She tensed up. He put the tip of his finger in her ass and she whimpered, but then relaxed. “That’s right, slut.” He moved his finger around in a gentle circle, massaging the rim of her asshole.

Maybe he would inflict anal punishment on her. But as satisfying as painal would be, it wasn’t right for first-time anal. He could be the first to have that hole of hers, along with her mouth, which he’d already claimed. He didn’t want her first anal experience to be punishment.

No, she needed a good old-fashioned whipping. He would tie her up and break out the belt. He smiled reassuringly to her and took his finger out of her ass. “Good girl.” He kissed her gently, softly, and hugged her protectively in his strong arms.

. . .

“Now, I can’t decide if you’re the luckiest or the unluckiest man alive,” Jason said, striding into the bedroom with a bath towel around his waist. Anna Lee followed after, also wrapped in a towel. Jason laughed. “Goddamn, ain’t this a pickle.”

“W-what are y’all gonna do to me?” The man asked, trying to steady his voice.

“We ain’t lookin for no trouble. That was you — you broke into the house. And before you say it, I know you thought the house was empty. But I don’t know you. And you don’t know me. And you’re tied up. So I can see why the situation don’t exactly put you at ease.”

Anna Lee clung to Jason’s arm, leaning against him.

“But despite this strange predicament we find ourselves in, I don’t believe anyone involved wishes anyone else ill. Right?”

The man nodded fervently.

“Okay then,” Jason continued. “So what should we do?”

“Y-you could let me go,” the man said, cautiously.

“I will, boy, I will. I agree with you. But I need to know that I can trust you first. I know you ain’t goin to the cops. Neither am I. Neither is she. Okay?”

He nodded.

“I’m gonna let you go soon. But I’m gonna keep you tied up for the moment, because I need you to see that you can trust me. I could do anything I want to you right now. And you’re gonna see that neither of us wish you harm, and I’m gonna hope that that influences how you proceed when we let you go.” He paused. “But it’s hard to trust someone when you don’t even know their name. My name is Jason. You’ve already met Anna Lee. What’s your name?”

“Jamie.”

“Nice to meet you Jamie. Now, I understand why you wouldn’t trust me. You fucked my girlfriend! Wouldn’t anyone wanna kill a guy over that?”

Jamie squirmed uncomfortably. “Hey man, I didn’t—“

“But we’re wild like that, Jamie. It’s all good. Like I said, I’m leaving you restrained for a while to give you some time to process that we don’t wanna hurt you. This is a big misunderstanding, but it all could’ve gone a lot worse. I think this’ll all be resolved peacefully, I do.”

Jason picked up the gun and unloaded it. “I’m gonna go put this away. Nobody’s gonna be needin this.”

He motioned to Jamie’s pants lying on the floor. “Anna, get his phone, would you? Put your number in there.”

Anna did as she was told, calling her phone to prove it was real. Jason came back and showed Jamie his phone, scrolling through a few apps and proving that he gave them their real names. Jamie was starting to relax a bit.

“Anna Lee, did you give Jamie some of those dick pills on the bedside table there?”

“Oh my gosh, I forgot about that,” she said.

“Well, that would explain why his dick is about to touch the ceiling,” Jason laughed and shot her a knowing glance.

“I-I’d hate to see them go to waste…” Anna Lee said innocently.

“Me too,” Jason added. He turned to Jamie. “You don’t mind if she has a little more fun before you go, do you?”

Anna Lee dropped her towel.