Jake tricks her

Jake hungrily reaches around Audrey's waist to feel for her button and fly. Which he finds and undoes her fly just to yank down her shorts to her knees revealing her panties.

"Hey! Calm down, we can take this slow you know." Audrey snickers as if she's dealing with a child.

Jake, who's completely ignoring her, undoes his own fly and pulls out his semi hard cock. Audrey can't see lower than Jake's belt through her mirrored view so she doesn't have a solid line of sight of his cock.

Audrey moves her head trying to sneak a peak at Jake's cock so she knows what she's in for but her view just doesn't allow for it.

Jake catches her interest out of the corner of his eye and grins, "Wanna see it?" Jake smirks as he positions himself directly behind Audrey.

"No! No no. Don't worry about me, I love surprises." Audrey says as if she wasn't interested. Which is a complete lie. She looks back forwards towards he own reflection just waiting.

Jake reaches for the waistband of Audrey's panties and pulls them down to her shorts revealing her slit which is glistening. He also takes note that she hasn't seen his cock.

"Oh my god. You're so fucking wet!" Jake laughs looking up to meet Audrey's glare through the mirror.

"No! No I'm not!" Audrey says blushes and looking away from Jake's reflection, "just hurry up!"

"You sure your not horny? Because your body seems to really want me to plow you against this counter right now." Jake chuckles seeing how red Audrey's face is at the moment.

"Shut up! Just hurry up you jackass." Audrey yells as her cheeks take on a deeper shade of red. Her usual persona has shattered for the time being.

Jake moves his hips forward and just barely makes contact between her sweet entrance and his cockhead. Then he gets an idea to enjoy all of this a little more.

Jake loves hearing girls like Audrey think of themselves as hot shit then breaking them down into a hungry slut or just putting them in their place.

Audrey tensed a little when she felt Jake's cock touch her and she prepared herself to be fucked by Jake of all people. She hated being here but it was too late to bail so she might as well enjoy it.

"Ready?" Jake asked looking up towards Audrey who just gave him a little nod as she looked up towards the ceiling with her eyes closed, bracing herself.

Jake pulls back his hips from her body and brings his hand right behind her entrance. He places his other hand on her shoulder.

Jake's plan is to finger Audrey without letting her know it's his hand. So with that he thrusts his hips forward but instead of impaling her with his now hard cock, he pushes two fingers deep into Audrey and lets out a fake groan. Actually she was pretty tight around his hand though, surprisingly so.

"Aah- wait?" Audrey starts to let out a moan but stops realising that the "cock" in her wasn't large at all. She opens her eyes and looks over her shoulder at Jake with a confused look.

Jake however, continues to pull back his hips and thrust forward timing his fake thrusts with his hand plunging into her pussy.

"Jake." She laughs, "is that it? That's your cock? Seriosuly, you were just bragging to me how huge it was."

"Yeah, why?" Jake stops and looks up at Audrey with confused look as if there wasn't anything strange going on.

"Okay whatever we had a deal so just keep going." Audrey says looking back towards the mirror.

Jake continues this facade of fingering Audrey for a while. The whole time Audrey not even realising that theres no cock in her, she lets out the occasional moan but is still internally laughing at Jake's pride.